Going back to basics: leaving PC gaming for consoles

gbatemp_title_banner_back_to_basics_pc_ps5.jpg

In what I can only feel like what was some hybrid mixture of a stroke of complete luck and sappy-movie-tier holiday miracle generosity, I find myself with a PlayStation 5 right in time for the holidays. It’s a sad state that merely buying a console has become a heroic feat, and yet, that fact makes it all the more exhilarating to be part of the next console generation. So, what better to do with this powerhouse system, than play Assassin’s Creed II; a game that’s over 11 years old, and originally released two console generations ago?

Backwards compatibility is one of the greatest features of the PlayStation 5 and Xbox Series line, letting players go back and experience an entire enhanced backlog of games while waiting for the heavy-hitting “next-gen” games to release, or while waiting for Cyberpunk 2077 to be in a playable state. Add to the fact that many of the games from the PlayStation 4’s library consisted of touched-up PlayStation 3 remasters in the form of Heavy Rain Remastered, Dishonored: Definitive Edition, The Yakuza Collection--every “trilogy”, “collection”, “legendary/definitive/ultimate/special” edition, and so many, many more; you could easily have a hundred PS4 games, none of them originating from that system’s own generation.

image0.jpg

In fact, I’ve yet to actually play a single PlayStation 5 game on my PS5. Perhaps it would be seen as bizarre, but as an ex-PC player, and only ever having owned the original PS4 and not the Pro, my favorite part about the PS5 is its ability to play older games at higher framerates or better quality. Games that I easily ignored on the base PlayStation 4 due to their performance have transformed into titles that I find myself wishlisting in hopes of nabbing them on sale at a later date. Even more exciting is that, as opposed to PC games which get dramatic price cuts seasonally, once a console game has been out for a while, the physical version tends to undergo a permanent price drop. It may not be as steep of a discount, but it’s affordable, and doesn’t require waiting around to be sniped during a perfect sale; the ideal combination for someone who’s just gotten a PS5 and is too impatient to wait for holiday price cuts just yet, or might have missed the best deals during Black Friday.

While I still hold an appreciation for PC gaming, the simple nature of consoles has won me back over. Yes, you can’t mod your games as freely, you can’t...try out all those fun demos from Codex, and the fidelity won’t come close to the best of what PCs are capable of right now--especially in the future--but at the same time, you also don’t have to do any fiddling with settings, there’s no worrying about the quality of a PC port, and most importantly, a PS5 doesn’t multitask; it has one purpose: games, and I find myself not getting distracted by things that might normally pull me out of an experience on my PC, like untimely Windows Update restarts, random BSODs, or compatibility issues after said updates. Perhaps it’s just part of my ongoing bad run of luck with PC gaming, but it took an entire hour of messing with settings, watching a game crash repeatedly, and desperately scouring the Steam forums with a friend after Detroit: Become Human stopped working, thanks to an Nvidia GeForce Experience update for Cyberpunk 2077 rendering the former unstable and unable to be played without rolling back to a random sketchy upload of a driver from over six months ago. That’s not something that would ever happen on a console.

pc y.png

The amount of customization PCs provide is a blessing as much as it is a curse.

This generation, Microsoft and Sony seem to have understood what might pique the interest of PC gamers: giving players that same option between graphics and performance, in a simple box that doesn’t ask much of its user; just download a game or slide a disc in, and It Just Works (TM). Of course, not everyone is going to see things that way, and that’s fine. After all, the PC platform is all about giving users the freedom of choice, and now, excitingly, PlayStation and Xbox users are able to get a taste of that glorious freedom, too.
 

bobmcjr

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Apr 26, 2013
Messages
1,156
Trophies
1
XP
3,215
Country
United States
For me, honestly the primary reason I avoid consoles these days is the lack of guaranteed preservable ownership over anything else (followed by build quality, but that's a different issue).

e.g., can I buy a game today, and play it 10 years from now without having to worry about whether I can even still download it, whether I need to track down specific hardware, whether a disc will still read, etc? If there is backwards compat, does it support all games or just a handful due to licensing shenanigans (cough cough JSRF on Xbone)? Do I have to buy them again? The track record for most consoles has traditionally been weak in this area, and although the PS4/PS5 and Xbone/XSX are a good start in that department, it'll take another generation or two to earn my trust.

While people usually argue that physical media is better for preservation, and while in the past this has been the case, given all the layers of DRM and other nonsense like day-one updates needed to make modern console games playable, I'd honestly consider PC DRM the lesser of two evils. At least on PC you have the raw files in some form that you can trivially back up, and DRM is usually a solved problem, at least moreso than on consoles. I also feel more confident knowing the digital PC games I bought 10 years ago are still completely playable today, and any that I buy today will still likely be playable in another 10 years.
 

Chary

Never sleeps
OP
Chief Editor
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
12,345
Trophies
4
Age
27
Website
opencritic.com
XP
128,345
Country
United States
For me, honestly the primary reason I avoid consoles these days is the lack of guaranteed preservable ownership over anything else (followed by build quality, but that's a different issue).

e.g., can I buy a game today, and play it 10 years from now without having to worry about whether I can even still download it, whether I need to track down specific hardware, whether a disc will still read, etc? If there is backwards compat, does it support all games or just a handful due to licensing shenanigans (cough cough JSRF on Xbone)? Do I have to buy them again? The track record for most consoles has traditionally been weak in this area, and although the PS4/PS5 and Xbone/XSX are a good start in that department, it'll take another generation or two to earn my trust.

While people usually argue that physical media is better for preservation, and while in the past this has been the case, given all the layers of DRM and other nonsense like day-one updates needed to make modern console games playable, I'd honestly consider PC DRM the lesser of two evils. At least on PC you have the raw files in some form that you can trivially back up, and DRM is usually a solved problem, at least moreso than on consoles. I also feel more confident knowing the digital PC games I bought 10 years ago are still completely playable today, and any that I buy today will still likely be playable in another 10 years.
This is a great point. Discs are just download keys at this point, really. (Unless you get from like, LRG and those releases are sparse)

There is the issue of OS updates rendering games unplayable, e.g. Fallout New Vegas not playing well past Windows 7, but as a counterpoint, there's always VMs and fanpatches available, if the game is big enough. It does rely a bit heavily on the community being there to support, though.
 

Xzi

Time to fly, 621
Member
Joined
Dec 26, 2013
Messages
17,743
Trophies
3
Location
The Lands Between
Website
gbatemp.net
XP
8,539
Country
United States
A few of these should be features already there, like the PS1 BC, but at the same time, it's why consoles are so much simpler. If you try to shove all these things into what consoles try to do, then they're just effectively PCs, with all the insane amounts of customization and you're back to square one because your PS5 caught on fire trying to play Skyrim backwards compat with 409 mods on an NES controller. That's the whole conceit of the article. Both have their strengths, and for some, that makes it worth the compromise.
That's fair, I don't mind taking mods out of my argument. The rest can easily be implemented without any additional complexity for the end-user to navigate, though.
 
D

Deleted User

Guest
I left the pc secne long time ago. In 2006 my parents bought me psp for my birthday. It was my first console and since then I slowly started to move from pc to consoles. In 2011 I said goodbye to my last gaming pc and I purchased normal laptop for studies. From 2012 I started to buy consoles regularly every year. Do i regret doing so? Nah.
 

Pipistrele

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Jan 21, 2019
Messages
770
Trophies
0
Age
30
XP
1,648
Country
Russia
I honestly can't stand PC gaming. I play some games on my PC but overall, I find PC gaming to be more work than reward, and the cost of constantly needing to update one's hardware not worth it. If there's something I enjoy about console gaming is that chances are higher that any game I buy for my systems is going to work, unless that game is Cyberpunk.
Any thoughts on indie gaming? It seems to be more reliable and cheaper on PC, and marketplaces such as Steam/GOG streamlined a lot of the hassle, so I'm personally sticking with combination of "console for big budget, PC for cool smallsies", but still kinda curious what other people think about this kind of approach to vidjagames.
 

The Catboy

GBAtemp Official Catboy™: Boywife
Member
Joined
Sep 13, 2009
Messages
27,947
Trophies
4
Location
Making a non-binary fuss
XP
39,338
Country
Antarctica
Any thoughts on indie gaming? It seems to be more reliable and cheaper on PC, and marketplaces such as Steam/GOG streamlined a lot of the hassle, so I'm personally sticking with combination of "console for big budget, PC for cool smallsies", but still kinda curious what other people think about this kind of approach to vidjagames.
Although indie games tend to be released first on PC, I rarely have the extra money to buy them on PC. Most of the time when I have the extra money, they've already been ported on everything else and I just end buying on whatever system it's released on or even my phone if possible.
 

Nerdtendo

Your friendly neighborhood idiot
Member
Joined
Sep 29, 2016
Messages
1,770
Trophies
1
XP
4,644
Country
United States
I'm a console guy through and through. With PC gaming, you get out what you put in. Sometimes it feels like a hastle just to get a controller working because if you have a game that doesn't support them, you have to get a keyboard mapper and remember your profiles and it's just a lot. Even at that point there are so many quirks that come with PC Gaming. Things like crashing for no reason, infinite launchers, keyboard and mouse control (blegh), and making sure you have a PC that actually runs the games. A lot of times, if you're building a low-end rig, you might as well buy console for the same price range and you know all the games will work on console. If you go high range, it's just a big money sink and frankly, I don't have that kind of money.
 

MikaDubbz

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2017
Messages
3,848
Trophies
1
Age
36
XP
7,303
Country
United States
I've put in a fair bit of thought as to downgrading my PC and just picking up a Series X... I probably would, but I have a heavy preference to kbm over controller.
Didn't Microsoft add keyboard/mouse support to the Xbone? Pretty sure they did, and if the Series X doesn't allow that now, I'd have to imagine it'll come in time.
 

Chary

Never sleeps
OP
Chief Editor
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
12,345
Trophies
4
Age
27
Website
opencritic.com
XP
128,345
Country
United States
Can't wait for someone to post this on PCMR lol
I’d laugh if they did, because it means they didn’t read the post. The entire point is that console players finally get a chance to have some of the finer things PC players have had for years, and that they’re a more viable option for those that want simplicity. PC still does what it does best, but maybe that’s not what some people want.
 

Goku1992A

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2019
Messages
1,823
Trophies
1
Age
33
XP
2,618
Country
United States
@Chary
To be honest with you if your PC is strong enough for next gen I would skip the PS5. IDK if you primarily use a keyboard but you can easily use an Xbox Controller for the next gen games. Now if you want to play the Sony excluvies then the PS5 would be sufficient. I wouldn't pay full price for Sony exclusives because the price drops dramatically.

I have plans on getting a PS5 and a Series-X in the next 3 years I'm trying to get them for $300 a piece.
 

Justinde75

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Feb 14, 2016
Messages
2,529
Trophies
1
Age
23
XP
4,553
Country
Germany
I personally much prefer consoles because I honestly can't sit at my desk for long and play games. Its alot more convenient to just have my ps4 on my tv and just be able to relax on my sofa when I finally have some free time. But PC does have alot of benefits imo.
 

Chary

Never sleeps
OP
Chief Editor
Joined
Oct 2, 2012
Messages
12,345
Trophies
4
Age
27
Website
opencritic.com
XP
128,345
Country
United States
To be honest with you if your PC is strong enough for next gen
I’ve got a 2080 Super and Ryzen 3700X. I have an ROG 144hz gsync monitor. I’ve got all the fancy crap. I’d still pick the PS5 tbh. (I miss my monitor though!)

I don’t even like Sony exclusives, either. I just enjoy playing a game for 3 hours without issue.
 
D

Deleted User

Guest
The straw that broke the camel's back in PC Gaming for me came some time back, in the early days of Bioware's games, namely Dragon Age; I noticed that the Console versions of the game got the better and more immersive Camera Angles, whereas my PC version was stuck in God Mode which disconnected me from the whole experience.

It was also around this time that I realised most of the fast-paced AAA Titles coming to the PC were ports of Console versions, with Keyboard Mapping put in as afterthought; this after I sunk in a hefty amount into my first Flagship Desktop Replacement Laptop.

I was insulted; I was paying more than the usual Desktop Gamer and much more than the Console Gamer, yet here I was getting scraps and afterthought User Experience. I started writing official complaints to NVIDIA as I was one of their first Generation of Desktop Replacement Laptop Users but it would take a few more years for the company to actually pay attention to Laptops and the people willing to shell out the most.

I then picked up the controls of a Console and enjoyed the hell out of it; I realised that the only person I have to blame is myself for expecting the Industry to respect me more just because I have better hardware. I also found the allure of Console Exclusives, which is why nowadays almost all of my Gaming is done on Consoles, outside of the obligatory annual play-through of Morrowind, SimCity 3000 and Fallout Tactics.
 

Goku1992A

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Nov 20, 2019
Messages
1,823
Trophies
1
Age
33
XP
2,618
Country
United States
I’ve got a 2080 Super and Ryzen 3700X. I’d still pick the PS5 tbh.

I don’t even like Sony exclusives, either. I just enjoy playing a game for 3 hours without issue.

I did read that you were having random issues with your PC so I completely understand. I still have extensive backlog from my PS3 and PS4 so I told myself before I buy anymore systems I should beat the games I already have. PS4 games are dirt cheap to buy now so I'm taking advantage I did manage to get FF7 remake and TLOU2 for $60 If I do buy a PS5 earlier than 3 years is because my PS4 had kicked the bucket. I was going to trade in my PS4 for a PS5 and my Xbox One S for a Series-X but game stop was only willing to give me $125 for each system so I just kept them.
 
Last edited by Goku1992A,

frankGT

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Nov 21, 2009
Messages
241
Trophies
1
XP
517
Country
Portugal
I love technology and hardware, for me the added complexity of PC is a plus that keeps me interested in it, I like to costumize and tune everything to a deeper level.
For me consoles just feel like a waste of hardware.
Even though i understand Op's perspective, for me 2 options doesn't cut it, and if now theres somehow a parity in performance as consoles are new and game tech is kind of stale, give it 2/3 years for consoles to start being pushed to their 30fps limit and pcs to fly by 2 new gpu generations ahead... As usual.
I get the appeal of consoles, and i have a switch to get that distinct library, but pc will always be my preference... A good costum desktop with top peripherals of course. ;)
 
  • Like
Reactions: mrcroket and Chary

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum

General chit-chat
Help Users
    Veho @ Veho: Software update might improve it.