Here is my personal ranking of all Paper Mario games:
1: Paper Mario 2 for Nintendo GameCube (It's my absolutey favourite game of all time. I got it when I was 7 years old... I have played through it 100 of times... The story is so funny and unique. The graphics are lovely desigend and I love every single character of this game. They are all extremly individual. I love all chapters of this game. My favourite chapters are chapter 3 and 8. The last chapter is my favourite because the boss battles and the story ending are so beautiful and epic...)
2. Super Paper Mario for Nintendo Wii ( I absolutely love this game... I have played through it many many times so far... The story is absolutely fantasic and it's very cool being able to play as Peach, Bowser and Luigi. It is also a good thing that many gameplay and level design elements of Paper Mario 2 can be found in this game as well... The mix between these elements with the very own gameplay mechanic of Super Paper Mario (changing dimension; 2D platforming) are very special and unique... Although the first hours of the game are very amazing (they are so amazing that they are at some points a better gaming experience than Paper Mario 2) many chapters are very strange and aren't very funny (for example I absolutely hate the chapter where you have to find the right apple for helping Peach)
3. Paper Mario for Nintendo 64 (I haven't played through the game yet... I only have played the first 4 chapters so far because I had sold my N64 before I could play through the game... Until now it's a worse version of Paper Mario 2 for me. Paper Mario 2 has better music, sound effects and graphics... Also the story of Paper Mario 2 is more unique...)
4. Paper Mario: Sticker Star for Nintendo 3DS (I love this game although many people say it's worse than Color Splash; Sticker Star is still innovative, it has a unique level design and I love collecting rainbow-coloured stickers)
...
5. Paper Mario: Color Splash for Nintendo WiiU (I don't like this game at all... for me it is a bad copy of Sticker Star)
1: Paper Mario 2 for Nintendo GameCube (It's my absolutey favourite game of all time. I got it when I was 7 years old... I have played through it 100 of times... The story is so funny and unique. The graphics are lovely desigend and I love every single character of this game. They are all extremly individual. I love all chapters of this game. My favourite chapters are chapter 3 and 8. The last chapter is my favourite because the boss battles and the story ending are so beautiful and epic...)
2. Super Paper Mario for Nintendo Wii ( I absolutely love this game... I have played through it many many times so far... The story is absolutely fantasic and it's very cool being able to play as Peach, Bowser and Luigi. It is also a good thing that many gameplay and level design elements of Paper Mario 2 can be found in this game as well... The mix between these elements with the very own gameplay mechanic of Super Paper Mario (changing dimension; 2D platforming) are very special and unique... Although the first hours of the game are very amazing (they are so amazing that they are at some points a better gaming experience than Paper Mario 2) many chapters are very strange and aren't very funny (for example I absolutely hate the chapter where you have to find the right apple for helping Peach)
3. Paper Mario for Nintendo 64 (I haven't played through the game yet... I only have played the first 4 chapters so far because I had sold my N64 before I could play through the game... Until now it's a worse version of Paper Mario 2 for me. Paper Mario 2 has better music, sound effects and graphics... Also the story of Paper Mario 2 is more unique...)
4. Paper Mario: Sticker Star for Nintendo 3DS (I love this game although many people say it's worse than Color Splash; Sticker Star is still innovative, it has a unique level design and I love collecting rainbow-coloured stickers)
...
5. Paper Mario: Color Splash for Nintendo WiiU (I don't like this game at all... for me it is a bad copy of Sticker Star)
Last edited by kai98yoshi,