• Friendly reminder: The politics section is a place where a lot of differing opinions are raised. You may not like what you read here but it is someone's opinion. As long as the debate is respectful you are free to debate freely. Also, the views and opinions expressed by forum members may not necessarily reflect those of GBAtemp. Messages that the staff consider offensive or inflammatory may be removed in line with existing forum terms and conditions.

Am I the only person with consistent views? (COVID19/abortion)

Are you consistent with regards to abortion and mask-wearing?

  • Yes, their bodies, their choices!

    Votes: 18 16.2%
  • No, I am pro-choice [abortion], but for enforced mask-wearing in public.

    Votes: 72 64.9%
  • Yes, let us not be careless about human life!

    Votes: 13 11.7%
  • No, I am pro-life [abortion] but against mandatory mask-wearing in public.

    Votes: 8 7.2%

  • Total voters
    111

UltraDolphinRevolution

Well-Known Member
OP
Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2016
Messages
1,806
Trophies
0
XP
2,436
Country
China
I wouldn't attack unless necessary either. I assumed by self-defense, you meant that, you know, your life was genuinely in danger. Love the effort you're going through to try and turn this around on me though lol.
Well, because you are still dodging the question. You absolutely refuse to give an unborn child even the slightest of value.

Does the self-defence against a not-life-threatening attack by a pregnant woman look the same as against a woman who is not pregnant? Do you have any regard for the child?
 
Last edited by UltraDolphinRevolution,

SatsuiNoHowdy

New Member
Newbie
Joined
Aug 10, 2020
Messages
2
Trophies
0
Location
Street
Website
www.youtube.com
XP
45
Country
Japan
Wearing a mask is important to the safety of all those around you, especially loved ones, and it should be mandatory to not recklessly endanger the lives of others. However, I believe that it's within our best interest as a society to destroy all children, regardless of age, gender, parents, social standing, or whether or not they are sentient/"alive" yet.
 

MikaDubbz

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2017
Messages
3,848
Trophies
1
Age
36
XP
7,303
Country
United States
Well, because you are still dodging the question. You absolutely refuse to give an unborn child even the slightest of value.

Does the self-defence against a not-life-threatening attack by a pregnant woman look the same as against a woman who is not pregnant? Do you have any regard for the child?
I really haven't dodged any questions, if you don't like my answers, I'm sorry, but they are more than sufficient to the questions you've asked. I give an unborn child's life value, I just don't think it's value is equal to that of a life with a developed brain that has formed thoughts and memories. I've already explained this.

Why would I fight back against a non-life-threatening attack? That seems incredibly stupid, I'd just peacefully remove myself from that situation.
 
Last edited by MikaDubbz,

Taleweaver

Storywriter
Member
Joined
Dec 23, 2009
Messages
8,689
Trophies
2
Age
43
Location
Belgium
XP
8,087
Country
Belgium
They're not remotely the same thing though. Mask wearing is about protecting other people. Abortion is about protecting yourself.
Are you a fellow Jew? It is a very traditional way of thinking... that the child is "yours". Not another person. I respect this perspective. In this sense, you are correct.

However, I would think that the vast majority of people view it differently. I am torn on this issue, to be honest.
Okay, I know this is aimed at @The Real Jdbye and @DarknessPlay3r but I want to chime in regardless...

You (again) assume that the fetus is already a child at any point during the pregnancy. So this also affects the outcome ("is a child a person?" will always result in a "yes" from everyone, whereas "is an unborn fetus a person?" will wield varying results, and even most pro-choice will reply with something akin to "depends on its age")


On top of that: the "the child is yours (but the vast majority of people view it differently)" is...a weird way of saying. I'm not sure if you've got children, but when they(1) say that children change your life, they aren't kidding. I mean...my girlfriend and me have one of the nicest babies in the world (hardly ever cries, is 100% healthy and smiles at almost everyone), our parents help out a lot, we've got the financial means to support her AND the corona-situation means I get to spend even MORE time with her...but even in that situation there's a lot of things to factor in(2). A child requires A LOT of responsabilities. If you ask me, it just wouldn't be fair to ask this of couples (or even single mothers) who just don't have the capabilities to make the required changes to adjust to catering to a new life for basically the rest of their lives.

But even so...it simply doesn't hold a candle to the mask-wearing situation. No matter how slim the chance is you're infected yourself, it's not worth spreading that chance to others who might become (very) ill or might even die because of that. Those against it are simply gambling with the health of the people around them. It may be a calculated gamble (I trust that my parents-in-law have practiced safety measures - from masks - since last time I saw them, thus making the risk of infection acceptable), but in public that gamble increases exponentially. Perhaps not to a dangerous degree, but that is only because the vast majority still follows the measures. There's a direct inverse correlation between the amount of people practicing social distancing and mask protections and the amount of covid-cases a country has. It's not fun to hear, but that's what it is.

...and I still can't find any connection between those two situations. :unsure:




(1): family, friends, colleagues...pretty much anyone who has children
(2): as I'm writing this, I'm playing 8 hours of lullabies because she can't sleep otherwise :P
 

UltraDolphinRevolution

Well-Known Member
OP
Member
Joined
Jul 30, 2016
Messages
1,806
Trophies
0
XP
2,436
Country
China
I really haven't dodged any questions, if you don't like my answers, I'm sorry, but they are more than sufficient to the questions you've asked.
It was a yes/no question and you refused to answer with yes/no (not that you cannot write more after it, of course) thrice or so.
I give an unborn child's life value, I just don't think it's value is equal to that of a life with a developed brain that has formed thoughts and memories.
If they have some value to you, I applaud you. Many feminists and their allies are proud of abortions. The more the better. I also do not value a fetus as much due to the "parasitic" nature of pregnancy. However, I can see why some women might even value the fetus more than their own life (e.g. a late pregnancy, last chance of passing on their genes).
 

MikaDubbz

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Dec 12, 2017
Messages
3,848
Trophies
1
Age
36
XP
7,303
Country
United States
It was a yes/no question and you refused to answer with yes/no (not that you cannot write more after it, of course) thrice or so.
I explained my stance and explained that if that stance sounds like equality to you, then yes, it's equality. I don't view it as an issue of equality personally, because in a moment where my life is in danger of ending from some assailant, I literally couldn't care less about their gender, race, pregnancy status, etc. etc. All that matters to me at that point is survival. (Hence why you didn't get your simple yes or no, but you did get my stance on the issue all the same.)

If they have some value to you, I applaud you. Many feminists and their allies are proud of abortions. The more the better. I also do not value a fetus as much due to the "parasitic" nature of pregnancy. However, I can see why some women might even value the fetus more than their own life (e.g. a late pregnancy, last chance of passing on their genes).
I don't know if I'd consider myself a feminist or ally or not, and frankly i don't care, that is also besides the point. Frankly, if I'm pro or anti-abortion is also besides the point. The only point I've been making is that the two scenarios simply do not equate, so to ask the question of "how can you be in favor of one and not the other," holds no real merit and shouldn't be a question to be genuinely considered.
 
Last edited by MikaDubbz,

notimp

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2007
Messages
5,779
Trophies
1
XP
4,420
Country
Laos
But most people have contradictory views on this. What about you? (read survey questions carefully)
Most people go through life, following the wonderfull principle of 'follow the leader'. Its more economical. You dont have to waste energy to think on your own, which you could fail at - you know.

Also this isn't just a thing on the politcal right (people dumb doesnt discriminate.. ;) ), the left suffers from it as well.

(Be like - we so liberal and pro free expression, if you are 'minority du jour we put on a podest to feel better and for virtue signaling on insta', but the f*ck submit to our politcal correct speech doctrine, and we all have the same opinion regarding the importance of "something something nature/climate" and will bite you, if you dont.)

If you are looking purely for rationality - wrong planet. ;)


Another example would be - if a trans person dresses 'sexy' it'll be like 'you go girl, you show em!' if a girl does, its still 'slut - being enslaved by the patriarchy'.
Joe Rogan came up with this one - I'm just reiterating.. ;)
 
Last edited by notimp,

The Real Jdbye

*is birb*
Member
Joined
Mar 17, 2010
Messages
23,288
Trophies
4
Location
Space
XP
13,846
Country
Norway
Okay, I know this is aimed at @The Real Jdbye and @DarknessPlay3r but I want to chime in regardless...

You (again) assume that the fetus is already a child at any point during the pregnancy. So this also affects the outcome ("is a child a person?" will always result in a "yes" from everyone, whereas "is an unborn fetus a person?" will wield varying results, and even most pro-choice will reply with something akin to "depends on its age")


On top of that: the "the child is yours (but the vast majority of people view it differently)" is...a weird way of saying. I'm not sure if you've got children, but when they(1) say that children change your life, they aren't kidding. I mean...my girlfriend and me have one of the nicest babies in the world (hardly ever cries, is 100% healthy and smiles at almost everyone), our parents help out a lot, we've got the financial means to support her AND the corona-situation means I get to spend even MORE time with her...but even in that situation there's a lot of things to factor in(2). A child requires A LOT of responsabilities. If you ask me, it just wouldn't be fair to ask this of couples (or even single mothers) who just don't have the capabilities to make the required changes to adjust to catering to a new life for basically the rest of their lives.

But even so...it simply doesn't hold a candle to the mask-wearing situation. No matter how slim the chance is you're infected yourself, it's not worth spreading that chance to others who might become (very) ill or might even die because of that. Those against it are simply gambling with the health of the people around them. It may be a calculated gamble (I trust that my parents-in-law have practiced safety measures - from masks - since last time I saw them, thus making the risk of infection acceptable), but in public that gamble increases exponentially. Perhaps not to a dangerous degree, but that is only because the vast majority still follows the measures. There's a direct inverse correlation between the amount of people practicing social distancing and mask protections and the amount of covid-cases a country has. It's not fun to hear, but that's what it is.

...and I still can't find any connection between those two situations. :unsure:




(1): family, friends, colleagues...pretty much anyone who has children
(2): as I'm writing this, I'm playing 8 hours of lullabies because she can't sleep otherwise :P
That's essentially what I was getting at. Even if you have the right to choose whether to do things that may be harmful to yourself or your life situation that does not mean you should have that choice when it comes to harming other people.
 

omgcat

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2009
Messages
869
Trophies
2
XP
2,698
Country
United States
It was a yes/no question and you refused to answer with yes/no (not that you cannot write more after it, of course) thrice or so.

If they have some value to you, I applaud you. Many feminists and their allies are proud of abortions. The more the better. I also do not value a fetus as much due to the "parasitic" nature of pregnancy. However, I can see why some women might even value the fetus more than their own life (e.g. a late pregnancy, last chance of passing on their genes).


the historical standard is that if a fetus is harmed or killed without the consent of the woman, jail or fines are awarded. hell even the bible states that accidental miscarriage due to beatings or a fight is generally a fine. This follows since the fetus is just an extension of the woman's body. same as if you cut off a toe, finger, or arm/leg.
 
Last edited by omgcat,

notimp

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Sep 18, 2007
Messages
5,779
Trophies
1
XP
4,420
Country
Laos
That's essentially what I was getting at. Even if you have the right to choose whether to do things that may be harmful to yourself or your life situation that does not mean you should have that choice when it comes to harming other people.
But if you are hinting at mask wearing, you have to make that voluntary (but with social pressure), to increase compliance. (Its a 'my body, my rules' thing, if youd force it (in society, in general), people would revolt.

Apparently you can force it in certain sectors (public transport), or supermarkets, but people then still have some 'freedom to decide' in other aspects of their lives... oh god, I'm arguing for 'why dictatorships work aint I...' ;) ).

What the US did so horribly wrong (arguably) was to have their political leaders go on television and be like 'and you also could wear masks, I guess' people pick up on those social cues, and that sets group behavior.
 
Last edited by notimp,

omgcat

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Feb 15, 2009
Messages
869
Trophies
2
XP
2,698
Country
United States
But if you are hinting at mask wearing, you have to make that voluntary (but with social pressure), to increase compliance. (Its a 'my body, my rules' thing).

What the US did so horribly wrong (arguably) was to have their political leaders go on television and be like 'and you also could wear masks, I guess' people pick up on those social cues, and that sets group behavior.

sadly we also had to be wishy-washy with masks since there was hoarding in the beginning. even now our doctors and nurses don't have enough PPE. if everyone had enough ppe and our stockpile was filled, we would have told everyone to mask the fuck up on day 1.
 

wiindsurf

Well-Known Member
Newcomer
Joined
Mar 27, 2019
Messages
97
Trophies
0
XP
955
Country
New Zealand
What if it was your wife? Couldn´t she say "it is my body" both with regards to mask-wearing and abortion?

I was talking about abortion only. But sure, I'd respect her choice on either.
I actually don't have any opinions about masks nor feel the need to have an opinion. I'm not a subject matter expert nor willing to explore the subject philosophically. I'll wear one if required, if I'm asked or if I fel like it.
It seems you heard someone say masks save lives, you chose to accept that premise, and now you are drawing parallels with abortion. Good for you.
 

wiindsurf

Well-Known Member
Newcomer
Joined
Mar 27, 2019
Messages
97
Trophies
0
XP
955
Country
New Zealand
You must be the most liberal person on earth. Wow.

Labels... Can we think outside the box?
Laws should be about universal consensus, if there is none, there should be no laws. If there is consensus, then a law will naturally emerge.
Pain and suffering will transcend anyone's particular choice at any moment in life, whether you comprehend that or not.
And while I do have my personal bias I'm happy not to impose them onto others... or label them.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Sapphire01

kaputnik

Well-Known Member
Member
Joined
Sep 10, 2007
Messages
215
Trophies
1
XP
910
Country
Sweden
It's a comparison of apples and oranges. How can you even have a consistent view of two questions with completely different sets of input parameters, unless you boil it down to some grossly oversimplified question about the value of human life or something?

To reply to the specific question; got no objections to abortion, and wouldn't mind mandatory mask wearing.
 

Youkai

Demon
Member
Joined
Jul 1, 2004
Messages
2,552
Trophies
1
Age
36
Location
Germany , NRW
XP
2,445
Country
Germany
Not sure if I get that right but I for one thing everyone should do as they want as long as that doesn't necessarly harm anyone more then "normal" thus said if someone wants to Abort it is their choice, just imagine you got raped and would need to grow the Child of that Rapist and have to life and "love" that child the rest of your life ... I can understand if someone doesn't want that ! and "most" people would probably think long about stuff like this as there is always the chance that you won't be able to get a child anymore if something goes wrong with the abortion.


About Masks, I think it is utter crap forcing anyone to Wear one ! there are illnesses everywhere and usually when you are ill you should stay home but when I am all healthy I won't let anybody force me to wear such a thing -.-

All those people that are crying out right now got influenced to much by media ... even with the "high" ammount of deads in the US and Brazil the Worldwide numbers of people that died are still nothing more than a flys fart compared to lots of other things.

40-50 millions (half of them children) dieing because of starvation ever year but noone cares as its mostly happeneing in those poor countries -.-
8 Million die because of active or passive smoking every year ....
(look it up these are official numbers)

I am actually more scared to be run over by a Car as I had LOTS of close encounters on my daily way to work, even on the bicycle way sometimes Cars get super close to me when they think it is a good idea to use it as a parking space.

And currently in the Arktis where it should be minus degrees, they hare more then 30°c and everything is burning releasing lots of methane and CO2 as well as potentially frozen Viruses or whatever from ancient times which might be able to kill us all if we won't get killed from the earth warming before anyways.



So people saying we all need to wear masks and everyone who won't is unsocial are just hypocrits
 

duwen

Old Man Toad
Member
Joined
Sep 6, 2013
Messages
3,193
Trophies
2
Location
Bullet Hell
Website
www.exophase.com
XP
4,297
Country
United Kingdom
Abortion correlated with mask wearing is a dumb comparrison...
condom wearing correlated with mask wearing would be a better comparrison.

...And for clarification, I didn't cast a vote as none of those options allow for nuance and common sense.
 
Last edited by duwen,

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum

General chit-chat
Help Users
    Sonic Angel Knight @ Sonic Angel Knight: Time to just download more ram