The only advantage from the XL that I think you'd care about is larger screen and better battery life.
The XL is kinda a lil too big but if you got donkey kong hands then your good, I like my DS Phat cause its the right size for me but I wouldnt mind a regular DSi except it has less battery then the DS Phat.I have fairly small hands, and I can no longer tolerate playing on a smaller DS. Since I own a DSi XL, it feels more natural in my hands. And the screens...once you try them, you won't be able to go back. And I'm pretty sure that if the DS phat fits in your hand fine, than the XL should fit too.
And the DSi has better battery life on average than the DS phat (9-14 vs 10 based on Nintendo's official specs)
QUOTE(Acenima @ Jan 1 2011, 03:43 AM) Also the DS Phat is already a huge object when going into my relaxed fit jeans so a DSi XL will be annoying having in your pocket. Since the DS Phat isnt a option I say get the regular DSi, if a huge size isnt the issue then go with the DSi XL.