# How far up did the ash go up in the 79 AD eruption

#### Dominator211

##### JFK's Jelly Donut
OP
Member
I'm doing this for a project (against my will) and I cannot seem to find one concrete answer some say it was 20 mi in the air and some say it was 20,000 m in the air so i am very confused... if there is a concrete answer i would like to know and compare this to a passenger plane which fly at about 40,000 Ft

#### sarkwalvein

##### There's hope for a Xenosaga port.
Member
I'm doing this for a project (against my will) and I cannot seem to find one concrete answer some say it was 20 mi in the air and some say it was 20,000 m in the air so i am very confused... if there is a concrete answer i would like to know and compare this to a passenger plane which fly at about 40,000 Ft
Erm... Perhaps I am lazy, but I would go with the Wikipedia statement about this (that of course could be wrong) and call it a day.
That would imply:
• It went 21mi up, that is 33Km in human units.
• A passenger plane (747, etc.) normally flies at around 9-10km (TBH, almost always I've flown it rarely higher than that, 40,000 ft is too high IMHO)
• Conclusion: It went up three times higher than a passenger plane.

#### DinohScene

##### Gay twink catboy
Global Moderator
Check Wikipedia and give the source.

If it's wrong, blame Wikipedia.

Seriel

#### Dominator211

##### JFK's Jelly Donut
OP
Member
Erm... Perhaps I am lazy, but I would go with the Wikipedia statement about this (that of course could be wrong) and call it a day.
That would imply:
• It went 21mi up, that is 33Km in human units.
• A passenger plane (747, etc.) normally flies at around 9-10km (TBH, almost always I've flown it rarely higher than that, 40,000 ft is too high IMHO)
• Conclusion: It went up three times higher than a passenger plane.
i have another site open that states otherwise
http://www.britishmuseum.org/whats_...rculaneum/pompeii_live/eruption_timeline.aspx

also i would like the info to be as accurcate as possible as my family has a very rich and close bond to pompeii

#### sarkwalvein

##### There's hope for a Xenosaga port.
Member
i have another site open that states otherwise
http://www.britishmuseum.org/whats_...rculaneum/pompeii_live/eruption_timeline.aspx

also i would like the info to be as accurcate as possible as my family has a very rich and close bond to pompeii
What do you mean? It says the same:
The cloud reaches its maximum height of over 30km then collapses spectacularly.
33Km (21mi) is actually "over 30km".

That said, I myself would accept the first one I found as true, and call it a day. (unless I actually cared)

PS: And regarding passenger planes "altitude", look for "average cruising altitude" not maximum altitude. You never really fly at the maximum altitude unless you want to waste fuel and you really need it (perhaps an emergency).

Last edited by sarkwalvein,
Quantumcat

#### Dominator211

##### JFK's Jelly Donut
OP
Member
What do you mean? It says the same:

33Km (21mi) is actually "over 30km".

That said, I myself would accept the first one I found as true, and call it a day. (unless I actually cared)

PS: And regarding passenger planes "altitude", look for "average cruising altitude" not maximum altitude. You never really fly at the maximum altitude unless you want to waste fuel and you really need it (perhaps an emergency).
it ust did a random google search ad 39k ft came up twice

#### sarkwalvein

##### There's hope for a Xenosaga port.
Member
it ust did a random google search ad 39k ft came up twice
That is almost sure the maximum height (I am calling this out of experience), because of that I suggest you to look for "average cruising altitude" for a Boeing 747-777 or whatever passenger plane you like.

#### Dominator211

##### JFK's Jelly Donut
OP
Member
That is almost sure the maximum height (I am calling this out of experience), because of that I suggest you to look for "average cruising altitude" for a Boeing 747-777 or whatever passenger plane you like.
I just really want to nail this project as there is a good price for 1st place and that i am also related to the guy that found it.... DEADASS

#### Quantumcat

Member
If you want to do well, don't do random google searches, hit your library and include proper references from books.

#### FAST6191

##### Techromancer
Editorial Team
"good price for 1st place"
If your attitude to the project was conveyed in this thread then good luck with that. In most schools of any reasonable size there is usually someone quite bored that will go all in.

If your profile is accurate and you are 14 it changes the requirements a bit compared to some other ages and skill sets, however you don't have to be limited to what they teach you (unless you are being examined on what they teach you in which case most lesser places, which is most of the world, will penalise you for colouring outside the proverbial lines, even if that is what physics says).

How do they tell today? Got atmospheric probes I imagine. Lacked those 2000 years ago though and time travel has not yet been invented.

The atmosphere was mostly the same though so you can use secondary indicators. The higher you go, the different wind systems you interact with and the further it goes.
Can you then dig down in sediment around the world to see what went on? Ice cores are a similar field in this instance.
Was it big enough to do one of those temperature drops, something that will be indicated in plant growth rings? Alternatively http://mentalfloss.com/article/29879/6-oldest-trees-world
Would blast damage (something not without documentation here) and resulting conditions allow estimation of the energy and thus able to be compared or extrapolated from a known event from modern times or with more documentation?

You need not be limited to one of those either -- a combined model is often a better one.

#### Dominator211

##### JFK's Jelly Donut
OP
Member
If you want to do well, don't do random google searches, hit your library and include proper references from books.
this is how i want to do MY project... thanks for your input

--------------------- MERGED ---------------------------

"good price for 1st place"
If your attitude to the project was conveyed in this thread then good luck with that. In most schools of any reasonable size there is usually someone quite bored that will go all in.

If your profile is accurate and you are 14 it changes the requirements a bit compared to some other ages and skill sets, however you don't have to be limited to what they teach you (unless you are being examined on what they teach you in which case most lesser places, which is most of the world, will penalise you for colouring outside the proverbial lines, even if that is what physics says).

How do they tell today? Got atmospheric probes I imagine. Lacked those 2000 years ago though and time travel has not yet been invented.

The atmosphere was mostly the same though so you can use secondary indicators. The higher you go, the different wind systems you interact with and the further it goes.
Can you then dig down in sediment around the world to see what went on? Ice cores are a similar field in this instance.
Was it big enough to do one of those temperature drops, something that will be indicated in plant growth rings? Alternatively http://mentalfloss.com/article/29879/6-oldest-trees-world
Would blast damage (something not without documentation here) and resulting conditions allow estimation of the energy and thus able to be compared or extrapolated from a known event from modern times or with more documentation?

You need not be limited to one of those either -- a combined model is often a better one.
i should have clarified... its a competition within my class alone... not with a school with 1300+ students

#### sarkwalvein

##### There's hope for a Xenosaga port.
Member
this is how i want to do MY project... thanks for your input
... then do it?
Nobody prevents you from taking a look into good old encyclopedia Britannica, and then further into the source of each citation, like we did back in my days.

#### Dominator211

##### JFK's Jelly Donut
OP
Member
... then do it?
Nobody prevents you from taking a look into good old encyclopedia Britannica, and then further into the source of each citation, like we did back in my days.
ok thank you for the input

#### Quantumcat

Member
this is how i want to do MY project... thanks for your input

--------------------- MERGED ---------------------------

i should have clarified... its a competition within my class alone... not with a school with 1300+ students
I can't imagine a teacher is going to pass an assignment with no references, or give a score much above a bare pass on one with only Wikipedia and the like references. But if course I remember that the quality of schooling in the US is not very high so maybe they don't teach you to reference at all. When I was at school, a quote from a book or website without giving the source was an automatic fail and referal to the principal (plagiarism), and no references at all was a probable fail unless the quality of the writing was very high.

Replies
9
Views
2K
Replies
3
Views
2K
Replies
14
Views
5K
Replies
1
Views
3K

1. 33K views

## Modders hint at potential kernel exploit hack for Xbox One consoles

It's been a while since Microsoft released the Xbox One, and despite its age, there haven't been any reliable softmod methods to hack the console. Until now. A post...
2. 24K views

## Majora’s Mask PC port 2Ship2Harkinian gets its first release

After several months of work, the Harbour Masters 64 team have released their first public build of 2Ship2Harkinian, a feature-rich Majora's Mask PC port. This comes...
3. 20K views

## The founder of Oculus is releasing a \$199 FPGA Game Boy system

Palmer Luckey is known for his pursuits into the world of virtual reality, having founded Oculus and designed the Rift VR headset. Prior to the \$2 billion dollar...
4. 19K views

## Doom for SNES full source code released by former Sculptured Software employees

The complete source code for the Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES) version of Doom has been released on archive.org. Although some of the code was partially...
5. 18K views

## Nintendo takes down the Breath of the Wild randomizer mod from Gamebanana

Another day, another Nintendo DMCA takedown against fan-made content. Just a few minutes ago, Nintendo issued a DMCA takedown notice against a widely known and...
6. 14K views

## Select PlayStation 2 games are coming to PlayStation 5

Sony is once more attempting to reintroduce players to their older library of games by re-releasing classic PlayStation 2 titles onto the PlayStation Store. During...
7. 14K views

## Skyward Sword HD randomizer announced with release date and trailer

Skyward Sword is a divisive title in the Zelda series. Hailed with praise at launch with a 93 Metacritic average, the game since received criticism for the...
8. 12K views

## Give-away Win a RG35XX SP Retro handheld with KeepRetro.com

We're super excited to announce that we have one of the new RG35XX SP retro emulation handhelds to give away to one lucky GBAtemp member! If you haven't checked out...
9. 11K views

## PlayStation State of Play May 2024 showcase - God of War: Ragnarok coming to PC

The latest State of Play is here. This is PlayStation's Summer showcase, providing updates to new updates on upcoming games and brand new reveals. The 35-minute...
10. 11K views

## Nintendo Direct - June 18, 2024 - new Mario Party, Mario & Luigi game, and more

That's right! It's time for the Summer showcase you've all been waiting for. A Nintendo Direct is about to air, bringing us 40 minutes of Nintendo Switch content. The...
1. 169 replies

## The founder of Oculus is releasing a \$199 FPGA Game Boy system

Palmer Luckey is known for his pursuits into the world of virtual reality, having founded Oculus and designed the Rift VR headset. Prior to the \$2 billion dollar...
2. 145 replies

## Modders hint at potential kernel exploit hack for Xbox One consoles

It's been a while since Microsoft released the Xbox One, and despite its age, there haven't been any reliable softmod methods to hack the console. Until now. A post...
3. 132 replies

## Nintendo Direct - June 18, 2024 - new Mario Party, Mario & Luigi game, and more

That's right! It's time for the Summer showcase you've all been waiting for. A Nintendo Direct is about to air, bringing us 40 minutes of Nintendo Switch content. The...
4. 115 replies

## Metroid Prime 4 gets new trailer, releases next year

After all the waiting, Metroid Prime 4 has finally gotten a new trailer. A two-minute teaser shows off some long-awaited gameplay, and the visuals. The game also now...
5. 111 replies

## Majora’s Mask PC port 2Ship2Harkinian gets its first release

After several months of work, the Harbour Masters 64 team have released their first public build of 2Ship2Harkinian, a feature-rich Majora's Mask PC port. This comes...
6. 107 replies

## Nintendo takes down the Breath of the Wild randomizer mod from Gamebanana

Another day, another Nintendo DMCA takedown against fan-made content. Just a few minutes ago, Nintendo issued a DMCA takedown notice against a widely known and...
7. 92 replies

## Nintendo Direct announced for tomorrow, June 18th, 2024

Nintendo have officially announced a Nintendo Direct for tomorrow, June 18th. The show will focus on Switch titles releasing this year and they have explicitly...
8. 73 replies

## Select PlayStation 2 games are coming to PlayStation 5

Sony is once more attempting to reintroduce players to their older library of games by re-releasing classic PlayStation 2 titles onto the PlayStation Store. During...
9. 70 replies

## The Legend of Zelda: Echoes of Wisdom announced, features playable Zelda

The Legend of Zelda is getting a new entry, in the form of Echoes of Wisdom. Styled in the same way as 2019's The Legend of Zelda: Link's Awakening, it's an isometric...
10. 65 replies

## Doom for SNES full source code released by former Sculptured Software employees

The complete source code for the Super Nintendo Entertainment System (SNES) version of Doom has been released on archive.org. Although some of the code was partially...

## Democrat member of congress at an event honoring terrorists

### Recent Content

12. #### Trails/Kiseki modding

Help Users
S @ SylverReZ: NES emulator on a Pico.