Gaming Nintendo ripped off a fan game.

Axodique · Sep 3, 2020

Nintendo announced a mario bros battle royale for Nintendo online subscribers, cool right ?

Apart from the fact that they took down a battle royale fan game and then a year later made their own.

Even when the sprites were changed they still took it down.

And the fangame is better, too.

limpbiz411 · Sep 3, 2020

oh yeah i remember this, it was a great fan game.

Peninsula · Sep 3, 2020

Or maybe Nintendo already the idea to make a Mario Battle Royale and it was in development at the time InfernoPlus released his Mario Battle Royale? The same thing happened with AM2R, which got a cease & desist around the time the Metroid 2 remake was released on 3DS.

CMDreamer · Sep 4, 2020

Peninsula said:
Or maybe Nintendo already the idea to make a Mario Battle Royale and it was in development at the time InfernoPlus released his Mario Battle Royale? The same thing happened with AM2R, which got a cease & desist around the time the Metroid 2 remake was released on 3DS.

And again, the fan game was way better than the one released by Nintendo.

TheCasualties · Sep 4, 2020

Really wish I had known about this game when it was happening. Mario 35 looks fun (Makes me want a not-banned switch, hopefully we can spoof a server) but this fan game was clearly a better implementation of multiplayer mario.

Edit: Is the code for this game still out there? Maybe there is a secret server where we can still play?

MikaDubbz · Sep 4, 2020

Still different enough for me to not care, with the enemies you can send to other players and powerups you can call upon in exchange for coins.

DiscostewSM · Sep 4, 2020

So Nintendo ripped off someone who was using Nintendo's IP....

Why can't people make their own original stuff rather than relying on what popular to drive them? Would save a lot of headaches with no C&D orders.

TheCasualties · Sep 4, 2020

DiscostewSM said:
So Nintendo ripped off someone who was using Nintendo's IP....

Why can't people make their own original stuff rather than relying on what popular to drive them? Would save a lot of headaches with no C&D orders.

The "Great artists steal" quote seems appropriate for this. This kid just wanted to make a multiplayer version of a game he loved. If you watch the videos you'll see. This was an amazing idea.

I agree making original stuff is a better idea but you never know where inspiration will come from. It's hard to create something totally new when so much amazing stuff has been created in the past. Inspiration has to come from somewhere. Sometimes it's a better idea to improve something already made.

Subzero100 · Sep 4, 2020

"Or maybe Nintendo already the idea to make a Mario Battle Royale and it was in development at the time InfernoPlus released his Mario Battle Royale?"

That is highly unlikely that they were making the same exact game they took down, but even if they were how come it too them so long to make a such a easy thing?

MikaDubbz · Sep 4, 2020

It's pretty clear that whatever team worked on Tetris 99 has made Super Mario 35, it may be that this game was 'ripped off', but the reality is, this game was inevitable in some form from Nintendo. The Battle Royale formula is a winning formula that can be applied to any genre and franchise, and slowly, but surely, that's happening. After applying the formula to Tetris, another big franchise was a certainty, so doing it to Super Mario is a no-brainer, just as applying it to the 3D platformer has proven to be a success for Fall Guys, and titles like Worms are getting the treatment as well (genuinely can't wait for that one). Surprised there aren't any racing battle royales yet, and I bet Bomberman is a game that will get one at some point.

fvig2001 · Sep 4, 2020

I lowkey hope that Super Mario War is brought back with multiple player support and online play

MikaDubbz · Sep 4, 2020

fvig2001 said:
I lowkey hope that Super Mario War is brought back with multiple player support and online play

Speaking of, if anyone can add Wii U Pro Controller support to the Wii build of Super Mario War and share it, I'd really appreciate it source is here: https://github.com/dborth/smw-wii and Wii U pro controller support code is here: https://github.com/FIX94/libwupc yeah I know this is a major hijack of the thread, but I saw an opening to reach more people with my request and took it lol.

tech3475 · Sep 4, 2020

DiscostewSM said:
So Nintendo ripped off someone who was using Nintendo's IP....

Why can't people make their own original stuff rather than relying on what popular to drive them? Would save a lot of headaches with no C&D orders.

It may be that the existing IP is what is driving them, especially when it comes to fan games.

There’s also a difference between basing something off existing work and starting from scratch, you may be a good level designer but not a coder, enemy designer, etc.

MohammedQ8 · Sep 4, 2020

Bladexdsl · Sep 4, 2020

did the same to AM2R it's use their shit or be DMCA'D

Peninsula · Sep 4, 2020

Subzero100 said:
"
That is highly unlikely that they were making the same exact game they took down, but even if they were how come it too them so long to make a such a easy thing?

It's not the same exact game though. Even from the small trailer we can see it's 35 players not 99, split screen not single screen, and different win conditions, not just race to the end of the 4 level world. Also, we have no idea how long it took them to develop this battle royale. They could have been sitting on the finished build for a year now waiting for the 35th anniversary event.

ShadowOne333 · Sep 4, 2020

And this is why I don't support Nintendo shit anymore.
Ditch their shit.
Emulate their stuff and don't pay them a cent.

They deserve to die the fuck off the industry for treating fans like shit.

Bladexdsl · Sep 4, 2020

Peninsula said:
They could have been sitting on the finished build for a year now waiting for the 35th anniversary event.

or they saw his game and thought hmmm what a great idea but first we need to get rid of his so only people will use ours

Deleted member 323844 · Sep 4, 2020

It also reminds the multiplayer mode of Super Mario Bros for Game Boy Color so I don't see the problem.

CMDreamer · Sep 4, 2020

MikaDubbz said:
[...] The Battle Royale formula is a winning formula that can be applied to any genre and franchise, [...]

Well Sonic franchise has proven the opposite, there's not much that can be made with it.

MikaDubbz said:
Surprised there aren't any racing battle royales yet, and I bet Bomberman is a game that will get one at some point.

If by "Battle Royale" you understand a multiplayer competition being held in realtime, then you're forgetting the Trackmania series.

Gaming Nintendo ripped off a fan game.

Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Just trying to be helpful

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Just trying to be helpful

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

fanboys triggered 9k+

Well-Known Member

QVID PRO QVO

fanboys triggered 9k+

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Similar threads

Popular threads in this forum