TBH, both are equally bad, yours isn't very well formatted, the page is centred however the rest of the page, borders that is, are just completely empty, that's a lot of empty space, at least you could change the colours or something, seeing as it also depends from the resolution of the people watching the page, as for your friends, just ew... I hate it when people just go ahead and mosaic pictures like that, also, the text is barely readable, that alone makes it a turn off... Oh, almost forgot, your website really needs formatting, I'd advise you to put the login screen on the top part of the screen, normally it's the on the right side, but left can also work just fine, and centre the things, you should put the chatbox on top or in the centre, same goes for the games and pictures sections, appearance has a major factor in websites you know? A website might be extremely crappy, but if it looks nice to the eyes, people will still browse it normally, the opposite also goes (well, it happens more often actually), so make sure to improve that. Also, being young is no excuse for bad taste in layouts. xP Try browsing some websites with nice layouts so you can get the gist of how they look.