santakuroosu said:
Raganook said:
Oh, and for the record...
VI>IV>X>VII>V>IX>VIII>I+II+III>XII
XII>V>VIII>VI>IX>I+II+III>X
Fixed.
Not putting up VII since I like it based on nostalgia and I don't quite remember IV.
Also, why the hell was XII at the last spot?
Any list with VI in the middle is wrong by default. I do approve of your V appreciation though.
XII: Worse than sub-par storyline. A practice in masturbation, since the game literally plays itself. An obscenely stupid set of rules that are made unavailable to the player during the course of the game (Read: Don't open randomly generated chests B I P Q and Z, then do these random things, and only THEN will it be a Zodiac Spear. Or, go through the mines, go to the chest, and with PERFECT TIMING, press the "open chest" button, and MAYBE you will get the shield, MAYBE."), and an overall lack of effort to develop any sort of attachment. Final Fantasy is about the storyline. Whether you prefer VIII, X, VI or VII, its the characters and their stories that you reflect fondly upon. FFXII lacked it, BIG time. Not to mention, the whole "Look-I'm-Playing-An-MMO-By-Myself" feeling was a bit bizarre. I clocked over 160 hours into XII. The first 40 was because I was enjoying it. It was at about this point that the game stopped being "fun". I kept thinking "I wonder what will happen!?" and hypothesizing about the plot. I didn't realize the rest of the game was a storyless grindfest. The last 120 was because I'm a completionist, and I've beaten all the rest of them, so I felt I had to. Rare monsters that only appear if a digit of your in-game time is right?! It would be nice if the game at least TOLD you this upfront. I just walked back and forth, back and forth, for hours upon hours. Any game that REQUIRES a strategy guide in order to just know the rules of how to achieve the challenges in the game has issues, and any Final Fantasy without a deep and twisting storyline belongs on the bottom of the list with the FFI-III-era titles.
However, this is a bit off-topic
. I would be more than happy to tell you even more in-depth and specific reasons why XII was scum in PM or another post
Needless to say, I stick with recommending FFIV DS to the topic poster as a good starter FF, since they wanted to start with a DS game. And again I reiterate that this would be far more enjoyable and comparable to other FF titles than FFIII DS. And it should be obvious I DON'T recommend XII