As for this guys review (never heard of him) he comes of as a bit of an idiot and some of his points are just not true at all. Also why so late with the review? I think he is just trolling FF for hits!
Spoony likes to unmask certain issues prevalent in contemporary JRPG games which often make them a chore to play. Read what you've just written - you had to go
through the first disc to actually draw some enjoyment from the game -
that's not a good sign.
Oh, I can already hear the
"but RPG's in general take time to fully immerse the player in the game world" coming my way - no they bloody don't, I know numerous great RPG's and JRPG's which don't take anywhere between 20 and 100 hours to get to the point, you should
enjoy the game from the get-go.
I'd also like to point out that in an epoch of fascination with the idea of a sandbox world,
"The Final Hallway" is pretty inexcusable in its linearity. When your RPG or JRPG has the linearity of a Rail Shooter, you just
know something's wrong.
Spoony's not trolling, he's merely voicing out his opinion on what he finds wrong in the game - it's creative criticism. He doesn't just say
"this sucks, don't buy this game" - he states what's wrong with it and why, sometimes even how certain aspects could be improved. It's a very pleasant watch in my opinion.