"Your reputation score will ultimately see you slotted into one of three, colour-coded groups: “Good Player” (green), “Needs Improvement” (yellow), or “Avoid me” (red). Where you sit on this spectrum will be reflected on your gamer card."
Now correct me if i'm wrong but this just seems immensely trollable
Say if I had a game, on oh I dont know... CoD?
And someone steals my kill (OH NOES) I can spam anti-rep against them and have them branded as a "red player"
I see what the point is, and I see how it can be useful. But I highly doubt good gamers would take the time out of their lives to report people, they'd just ignore them.
This may just turn out the same as games like League of Legends where people spam: REPORT THIS N00B OMG every game.
Although
"The reputation algorithm is sophisticated enough to recognise when it may be being abused, confirming you will not be penalised for a few bad reports."
There is the chance that they could police this properly, and it will be great if they did. But if "Rep-Trolling" becomes big, the system may not be able to keep up.
But basically, if you get trolled one day, and rage at someone the next... You could see a hint of yellow creeping up on you.
The new system may also take into account current rep on Xbox Live, so if you have a history of raging. You wont be seeing green one XBO
so, xbox one fans...
how long can you stay green?
source
Now correct me if i'm wrong but this just seems immensely trollable
Say if I had a game, on oh I dont know... CoD?
And someone steals my kill (OH NOES) I can spam anti-rep against them and have them branded as a "red player"
I see what the point is, and I see how it can be useful. But I highly doubt good gamers would take the time out of their lives to report people, they'd just ignore them.
This may just turn out the same as games like League of Legends where people spam: REPORT THIS N00B OMG every game.
Although
"The reputation algorithm is sophisticated enough to recognise when it may be being abused, confirming you will not be penalised for a few bad reports."
There is the chance that they could police this properly, and it will be great if they did. But if "Rep-Trolling" becomes big, the system may not be able to keep up.
But basically, if you get trolled one day, and rage at someone the next... You could see a hint of yellow creeping up on you.
The new system may also take into account current rep on Xbox Live, so if you have a history of raging. You wont be seeing green one XBO
so, xbox one fans...
how long can you stay green?
source