Finally played it (then my Wiimote battery ran out ¬¬). Not as amazing as Nintendo is marketing it, but also far from the atrocity that the Internet's been calling.
It's quite fun and more deep than I thought. Making something sound good in it is a lot harder than it looks.. and Nintendo's been lying on their advertisements, it's not just Wiimote shaking, you have to press some buttons to get better results.. Anyway, you can change the songs into almost anything and doing so and hearing it later gives me a Mario Paint like vibe. Also, you can learn a lot about music from it.
My biggest complain is the music selection, Nintendo could have at least explored more their own library.. more Mario and Zelda songs, Metroid, Donkey Kong, whatever.. more Nintendo songs would add more value to the thing, more classical songs like Beethoven would be welcome too. And in the subject, you start with only a few songs and have to play the game to unlock more songs and instruments. Big let down to me.. and not a smart move IMO, if they're aiming this thing to non-gamers, those people are not used to games were you need to unlock stuff.. a lot of moms out there will look at the song selection and think "What? That's it?"..
Well, I'm curious to see how far I can take a song
From what I've seen until now.. I would give it a 6.5 out of 10..
Splashman said:
And do I really have to endure the griping
Twinkle Twinkle little Star in every single lesson??
Agreed
QUOTE(Splashman @ Oct 22 2008, 04:16 PM) Good thing us
pirates free living people who do what they want cause a pirate isthey are free at least get the chance to test-play games like these to determine the value before shelving out $50 for it. I'll probably hold off on it until it lands in the bargain bin... which might be never, if it finds its audience and sells millions.
I see it selling very well.. but not as well as WiiFit and WiiPlay.. people will get tired of it very fast IMO. As Kotaku's review said.. it doesn't have much meat really
edit: Here's a video showing the whole process of mixing a song with different instruments.. gives you a good idea of what can be done:
http://wiifolder.com/?p=120