Gaming what is your starter pkm going be?

[Demonbart]

Fire, always. So Cyndaquil

This. Plus, the nostalgia, I always went with Cyndaquil back in the day.

 

[Satangel]

Totodile all the way.

 

[.Darky]

inb4 people arguing which of the starters in the best.

 

[Robedom]

I'm going to pick Chikorita because that is the most decent grass type in the Johto pokedex

 

[Donald Serrot]

inb4 people arguing which of the starters in the best.

Too late.

I have to say I'm gonna go with Chikorita.
I actually went with Cyndaquil on the Japanese version so I want to try something different. Went with Piplup on Diamond, haven't gone with a grass starter before (but do have a forced encounter Bulbasaur and love it along with the other original starters my team is made of.)
Not sure if it'd be considered a spoiler or not... but just to be safe for those who care.

Spoiler

When I get to go back and pick one of the Red/Blue starters I'm going Charmander. He's who I got in my first game so I have a special attachment to the little guy.

 

[Requios]

HG: Chikorita
SS: Cyndaquil

 

[tajio]

I have chosen fire type starters all my life!!! Charmander, Cyndaquil, Torchic, Chimchar! and AGAIN SHALL I PICK CYNDAQUIL!!!

 

[Camshi]

Well, I think they are all good, due to them being pure breed Pokemon with only being consistently one type all through their evolution chain.

But think it'll be;

HG: Cyndaquil
SS: Totodile

 

[mameks]

Cyndaquil. 'nuff said.

 

[abrack08]

I usually pick water pokemon, but I also like Cyndaquil. This one and Red/Blue are the only ones I have trouble deciding... I like Squirtle, Charmander, Totodile, and Cyndaquil pretty much equally. The other two generations have only one starter as far as I'm concerned (Torchic and Piplup).

 

[outgum]

back on the retro Silver i always chose chikorita, but on the Jap version i got Cyndaquil
And i think this time ill toss between them, Good grass pokemon are hard to come by....
Totodile sucks ballz

 

[raulpica]

Totodile. I mean, learning Dark attacks on the last evolution? Heck yeah

 

[Law]

probably whoever the water one is, I always seem to pick those for some reason (except for ruby where I picked the fire chicken (at least I think that was ruby?))

 

[basher11]

always gonna pick cyndaquil. screw chikorita.

 

[soulfire]

totodile for sure water is awsome

 

[_Chaz_]

Tododile. I'm gonna make a team of stage 1 Pokemon.

I want to try Chikorita as well, however.

 

[junker_man32]

my starter pokemon will be your mom. she has orgasms cuz thats how she poketalks..JK
it would probably be some mudkippery

 

[Aeladya]

Cyndaquil...Totodile's evolutions are only good in the TCG IMHO.

 

[bozeefus]

if heartgold,

u get red gyardos later on in the game
you get ho-oh later on at lv 40

so chikorita.

=============

BUT, gyarados doesn't really have any water attacks and its special atk is pretty weak.

so maybe totodile

 

[outgum]

if heartgold,

u get red gyardos later on in the game
you get ho-oh later on at lv 40

so chikorita.

=============

BUT, gyarados doesn't really have any water attacks and its special atk is pretty weak.

so maybe totodile

Your point is moot XD
Ho-oh and that red gyrados both suck XD

LUGIA FTW!