Too bad he doesn't live near I do, I'm giving a 22" Mitsubishi CRT away lol.
To build off of that Craigslist idea, look at the "giving/free" section of Craigslist for your area if you decide to go that route. People are literally giving away older TVs like that, like I am. Freecycle is a good site to check out too.
Only problem is it isn't the most space-efficient option. But I would really say that your best bet is gonna be to just emulate it then. Emulate, use one of
these if you want the controller, and just call it a day. ZSNES also supports, among various filters, artificial scanlines. The screenshot below shows Earthbound running with 25% scanlines added.