dudeonline said:
ust because it never happened to you doesn't mean it never happened. There are more people in the world than your (lol) "dozens" of people that you modded consoles for.
It happened to 3 friends of mine atleast, and also happened to my brother, and I was there to witness it first hand.
If you read between the lines, it means that we doubt your claims. Perusing numerous Xbox 360 modding forums shows that you're pretty much the only one who's ever made such a claim, and now you claim it has also happened to everyone around you. Likely story.
Sorry, but your claim is unfounded. It appears more like an assumption that you made which you are now trying to defend, or simply a rumor you want to see take off. I can't speak for the topic creator, but I would sooner go with the majority than a single person's claim.
You also need to look at things from a logical perspective. Microsoft has no right to ban a console just because the currently-attached hard drive was previously attached to a system with modified DVD drive firmware. They're not trying to alienate their customers, they are trying to discourage piracy and encourage people to play legitimately. They want to sell more systems and keep people paying for Live. They couldn't accomplish that if they judged a system's integrity based soley on the fact that it's using a hard drive that was once attached to a modded system. That would be completely irrational. Microsoft didn't become one of the largest and wealthiest companies in the world by being idiots. They know how business works and they are well versed in legalities.