Anime - Help me out!

  • Thread starter Thread starter Tokiopop
  • Start date Start date
  • Views Views 10,131
  • Replies Replies 89
I'm going to have to disagree with all of the Death Note suggestions here. I think it has a great idea, but terrible execution.

The characters are pretty annoying across the board (L is pretty much "Hot Topic Sherlock Holmes", Misa is a shrill, useless Harley Quinn, etc.), and the Shinigummy Bears are more distracting than anything else. There has to be a better way to deliver exposition than that.

The plots also get ludicrously complex - there reaches a point where we exit "Xanatos Gambit" and enter sheer asspull territory ("Oh sure, I can perfectly replicate this book, down to every single minute scratch and crease, in exactly one night, by hand. Why not?"). The series seems desperate to top itself, and so the problem only continues to get worse as it drags on. Beyond that, the acting is... uh, rather over the top.

It's a shame because the core of the series is decent enough. It's a Holmes vs. Moriarty dynamic, except we're watching things from Moriarty's perspective. The show is at its best when it's just the two characters trying to one-up the other, getting caught up in heated mind games, and having to improvise new plans of actions as they desperately try to keep face.

Unfortunately, the show manages to ruin the one thing it had going for it halfway through. It reaches a completely satisfying conclusion and just. keeps. going. It tries to recreate the original dynamic but utterly fails (it fails twice over, in fact); the replacements are so laughably inadequate I have to wonder if it was some sort of joke on the audience.

Apparently the manga is even worse - it's supposed to extremely padded. "Death Bloat" would be a more accurate title.

I think there's a good show in Death Note, but you'd have to do a lot of digging to unearth it.

TL;DR: You're probably better off just watching something else.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Yumi
I love sword art. However, before I watched that I really came to love Fairy Tail and Bleach, they're similar to Sword Art but not as good unfortunately, the better if the two if Fairy Tail and is really funny!
 
You definitely need to try Death Note :D
Also give Fate/Zero a try... or you could just read the light novel. :x

And if you're looking for some good manga/manhwa(Korean manga), then I'd recommend:
1) Katekyu Hitman Reborn (omg, I loved this. Why'd it have to finish. Still had potential :c)
2) The Breaker (It's a manhwa but boy-oh-boy is it epic!)
3) The Breaker; New Waves (The Breaker's sequel)
4) Psyren (One of the most underrated manga out there)
5) D-Gray Man (Every character in this series is just plain epic)
6) Pandora Hearts (Weird but cool c:)

Sorry, I listed a lot of manga even though you're looking for anime. :s
Oh and one more anime I'm currently watching, Samurai Champloo, it's got amazing music synced with the fight scenes :D
 
I personally really liked Zetsuen no Tempest/Blast of Tempest which will finish next week. The show is about the death of a girl, mages, revenge, the end of human civilisation and how the hell that all connects. It has references to Shakespeare (Hamlet and The Tempest) and while there is some big action sequences, it's mainly build around dialogue. It isn't extremely deep, but it has great plot twists and it's one of the best shows I've seen lately.

I can also recommend Eureka Seven. It's centred about a boy and a strange girl in a world which is covered in a thing called the scub coral, which seems to improve life, but actually it's a hidden threat and the fate of the world lies in the hands of the boy and girl. I know, it sounds really cheesy, but because of the mystery around the girl and the heavy pressure on the shoulders of boy, the relationship between the gets really complicated. It's a great show, with a great balance between action and interaction between the characters.

I can also second what emigre said about Angel Beats, Air and Kanon.

If you are ready to get heavily confused and get drained in depression, you should watch Neon Genesis Evangelion. You will get confused and will need to read up a lot afterwards, but it's worth it.

I will definitely subscribe to this treat, so I can always give you more tips if you need some.

EDIT: I saw that people recommend Steins;Gate. Watch it. It's AMAZING!!
I agree! Evangelion is in my top 5! :D
 
I don't think evangelion should be suggested to someone new to anime.
it's lot of mecha battles, and lot of meaning (religious/psychological) which a lot of people didn't understood, didn't like the end, etc.

It's a good one, but maybe not a best choice for someone who may still have doubts or prejudice about anime.
I think it's best to recommend movies or series to let him see that anime can be beautiful (visually) and well directed, as can be a movie with real actors.

Anime is not a genre for me, it's a medium/vector for a story. a story can be written, filmed, drawn, 3D rendered, played, etc., it's just a different media used to communicate it.
I remember Jin Roh's autor who decided to make this one from his trilogy in animation instead of real actor because "he could render emotions better like he wanted it in anime than with real actors".
 
Here I thought you guys were all dead or hiding.

Anyway http://myanimelist.net is a nice site to visit for details of certain anime, recommendations and listing your anime/manga.
For example the page of the movie Ookami Kodomo no Ame to Yuki, which I recommend watching, shows synopsis, alternative titles, etc.
On the left in the statistics area shows the score of how those people who watched the movie from 1-10.
Below the ads on the middle part are some user reviews, then some recommendations.

Also near the bottom is the list of fansubbing groups who released their or other groups' fansub. The one on top isn't necessarily the best one.
Clicking that link(commiesubs) would take you to their page on MAL which has the link to their site. Wouldn't be necessary if you would watch it online on streaming sites though.

Above the fansubbing groups are threads about the episodes or the series in general.

anyway, here's my list http://myanimelist.net/animelist/nryn99 (pay more attention to the movies)
in addition to what some others said that's on my list;
Romeo X Juliet - it does become kinda magical at the end which felt weird.
Hotarubi no Mori e
Kare Kano - one of my favorites but it's from 1998

here's the clannad page to get some recommendations http://myanimelist.net/anime/2167/Clannad
 
Guys I think you've spent my whole summer :(

I can't wait until Friday; when I finish my assignment and can actually start watching some of these!
 
omg,..aw look at all of us. showing anime some love<3 ^_^

anyways, i remembered a really really good one you should try out.
It's a bit odd, weird, but really awesome. A must watch before your summer ends. ;D
 
You definitely have to watch Puella Magi Madoka Magica, i thought i wouldn't like it and i ended up watching all the episodes, there's also Panty and Stocking that i can recommend as well
 
I would recommend Death Note, but only when u've watched a few more anime. It can get really complex.
Code geass is absolutely recommended. That shit is a masterpiece. Both seasons.
I would also recommend Fullmetal Alchemist (Both the 2003 series and Brotherhood).
Elfin Lied was a hit and miss for me, but it's good.
Soul Eater is also a good one.
The "big 3 (Naruto, One Piece, Bleach)" as we call them, they're "good" but I'm not sure I would recommend it yet.
Steins;Gate is a must-watch.
Clannad.
That's it from me for now.
 
http://myanimelist.net/animelist/HellsMalice&show=0&order=4

I think that should order my list by rating...i'd suggest some but i'd probably be parroting my list.
Was kinda lazy and didn't read the replies of this thread (much).
My favorite anime of all time is and probably always will be Clannad. (it got me into anime when I thought all anime was crap)
Anything by Jun Maeda is gold.

If I had to throw out three random probably not said animes off the top of my head i'd go for Ef: A tale of Memories (and A Tale of Melodies), Sola and Kobato.
Moving a bit away from drama/romance, a random three would be: Mirai Nikki, Phantom: Requiem for the Phantom, and Darker than Black.
aaand lastly two comedy, Strawberry Marshmallow (dubbed is good) and A-Channel (because comedy in the middle of most series I watch = a good idea).
 
  • Like
Reactions: Gundam Eclipse
watch law of ueki. its great. afterwards, watch any other anime, and it will be even better. even naruto.
 
My favorite anime would be To aru Majutsu no Index so I recommend that.
It starts kind of weird tho. Like your typical fanservice anime and I can see why people would think that but it becomes so much more later on.
Story takes time to progress and I don't think anime even reached the core of the story yet.

I finished the anime and reading the light novels.
 
I started watching Another after finishing Kanon (2006) (which I really enjoyed!).

I know it's not really related to anything I originally talked about, but I thought I'd branch out in genre a little. I'm 4 episodes in now (5 including ep. 0), and I'm enjoying it. Not sure if I'll be able to sleep though... :lol:
 
Another has a good mystery, you won't sleep until the last episode :creep:
If you find the culprit before the end, you are a good detective ;)


If you like mysteries clue finding, you will like this anime too: Hyouka
(it was already suggested on the previous page)
 
I think you'll love Honey & Clover. It starts off slow, but gets really good 4-5 episodes later.
Also the classic Grave of the Fireflies - really heavy stuff.
 
Another has a good mystery, you won't sleep until the last episode :creep:
If you find the culprit before the end, you are a good detective ;)


If you like mysteries clue finding, you will like this anime too: Hyouka
(it was already suggested on the previous page)
No, I didn't guess it :(

I actually thought it was Izumi for a while, especially when she was on top of Mei (who didn't have her eyepatch on) because of how Mei was staring at her. I think I liked the horror/creepiness and mysteriousness of it all over the actual detective/clue finding side... Though I'm not saying I didn't like the clue finding side of it!

And I was already planning to watch Hyouka at some point, but thanks anyway :D Do you know any other good horrors? Preferably something similar to Another where there isn't a big scary looking monster as such (I find horror films that try to scare you with this sort of stuff lame, but horrors that are on a more psychological level I find really interesting and creepy)

I think you'll love Honey & Clover. It starts off slow, but gets really good 4-5 episodes later.
Also the classic Grave of the Fireflies - really heavy stuff.
Thanks for the suggestions, Grave of the Firefiles looks really interesting!
 
I don't know many other psychological-horror anime.

Maybe Gyo , it's a movie depicting unknown parasite-like life form taking over humanity.
It's violent and has some nudity scenes (I don't know if it can be a problem for you, but I prefer mention it).
I found it more disturbing and disgusting than enjoyable, but I guess it's psychological-horror.
It has a very bad note from watchers (2 to 5/10), but I don't think it deserve a note that bad. Maybe they didn't like it because of the theme and the way it's told.


Shiki
A vampire family installed in a rural town is feeding on the townspeople one by one.
People are trying to understand the decease origin but never imagine that vampire exists.


First two season of Jigoku Shoujo (Hell's girl).
If you want to take revenge against someone, you call the hell's girl and she will send the target of your hatred alive into hell, but you will also go to hell when you will die.
The anime is based on the relation between hate and revenge, and deciding which is harder to support : constant harassment from someone, or knowing you will go to hell one day.
The first season is following a journalist trying to understand who she is.
The second season show how that power can easily be abused and go out of control.
(third season was not very good in my opinion)


Maybe Persona 4
It's not really an horror theme, but you might like it.


Wasurenagumo : Short movie (single episode) from Student competition. Very nice :)
It's part of a 4 short movies released from animator training sessions held in 2010 and 2011.


Kigeki : Very short movie (10min) which you can find on youtube with english subtitles.
I like that one, but it's a personal opinion. I just like the legend and mystery side of it, with nice design.

This show made me discover Studio 4°C (an animation studio) which were doing a lot of experimental movies or animes. (they also create animation for video games, such as Catherine, or Rogue Galaxy)
I like finding and watching unknown stuff ;)
Don't be scared to pick random things too, but I guess you have a lot of suggestion in the thread to not be bored until this summer!


On anidb.net you can search by genre: Horror
there are a lot of anime in that genre, but not all of them are psychological. (and too many I never watched so I can't suggest more to you).
 
Death Note and Full Metal Alchemist: Brotherhood (and perhaps the original series, though they're inferior)
I haven't watched a lot of different anime, but those two were both great IMO, and they don't go on forever like a lot of anime does.
Also, if you like that kind of stuff, you should watch Lucky Star. Not much of a plot, but it was a good way to waste time.
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum