Friendly reminder: The politics section is a place where a lot of differing opinions are raised. You may not like what you read here but it is someone's opinion. As long as the debate is respectful you are free to debate freely. Also, the views and opinions expressed by forum members may not necessarily reflect those of GBAtemp. Messages that the staff consider offensive or inflammatory may be removed in line with existing forum terms and conditions.
You are using an out of date browser. It may not display this or other websites correctly. You should upgrade or use an alternative browser.
Controversial trans athlete wins women's NYC cycling race
I also love how they throw at you to not "Assume" their Gender. Really now????? Tell that to Criminal Scientist, Biology, and Science. When Law Enforcement collect up DNA, they do not have any way of determining if someone is Trans, or whatever. It is only Male or Female based on DNA Markers. So, sorry, but Science and Biology says Male or Female. In fact, there are only a VERY short list of Insects or Animals that can change Gender, I think, and that is based in their DNA.
All the rest of Life on the Planet are Male and Female. Oh but Humans, yeah, apparently we want to be different, and mess with other Gender's Sports or Listings.
Where will it end???? You had a White Woman claiming to be Black, because she felt she is Black and should be identified as such. You even had someone apparently feel that they were Blind, so they Blinded themself, and another person saying they felt like a Amputee, to they cut of a Limb. Ok, so I feel like I am a Multi-Millionaire, can I demand the Bank reflect it, then?????
WHERE THIS WILL END???? MEN THINKING THEY'RE CARS AND TRYING TO COMPETE AGAINST CARS??? THIS IS RIDICULOUS
You're unable to bring up with anything that's not virtue signaling and panic, and still you bring up the topic to the forum, to shit on stuff that you don't understand and don't care to learn anything about. This is ridiculous.
No, i didn't intended to disrespect you at any point, if i did, i apologize, but stating that something is logical doesn't make it logical, that's not how logic works, you have to bring something logical about comparing trans people with disabilities.
WHERE THIS WILL END???? MEN THINKING THEY'RE CARS AND TRYING TO COMPETE AGAINST CARS??? THIS IS RIDICULOUS
You're unable to bring up with anything that's not virtue signaling and panic, and still you bring up the topic to the forum, to shit on stuff that you don't understand and don't care to learn anything about. This is ridiculous.
Post automatically merged:
No, i didn't intended to disrespect you at any point, if i did, i apologize, but stating that something is logical doesn't make it logical, that's not how logic works, you have to bring something logical about comparing trans people with disabilities.
You're wasting your time trying to explain to that guy - he's biased and doesn't accept the basic biological facts that men aren't women and can never be women and that it's wrong for men to compete against women in womens sports.
You're wasting your time trying to explain to that guy - he's biased and doesn't accept the basic biological facts that men aren't women and can never be women and that it's wrong for men to compete in womens sports.
"Similar to boxing championships athletes should compete in brackets based on weight and height in addition to gender (based on transition status), then it would actually be fair for all participants."
The transition status is notated as being a key importance in determining what is "fair", but it is subcategorized (suggesting that it is more important that they are recognized as one of the binary options, and that being trans is secondary) and also seems to have arbitrary thresholds.
"Similar to boxing championships athletes should compete in brackets based on weight and height in addition to gender (based on transition status), then it would actually be fair for all participants."
The transition status is notated as being a key importance in determining what is "fair", but it is subcategorized and also seems to have arbitrary thresholds.
Despite biological/physical facts/obviousness, people often brings "aDvaNcEd BiOloGy" to the matter.
To which I sometimes agree... to an extent.
For instance, there's been studies that shows that people identifying as a certain gender different than "tHE sOcIaLLy iMpOseD" have more hormones in their brains from that gender they identify with.
So that's a biological and scientifical reason to support the idea of people identifying as other's genders.
But just saying that Trans people deserves a Trans category.
It's not a matter of being against anybody, just get the category just like there's categories for disabled people.
That's equality, I support equality, the one that treats everyone as persons and nothing else.
I made an edit that may help clarify the problem I am seeing in it if you want to check again. The main contradiction I see is in the idea presented that we don't need "trans" categorization and ignoring that the solution presented already relies on trans categorization.
Despite biological/physical facts/obviousness, people often brings "aDvaNcEd BiOloGy" to the matter.
To which I sometimes agree... to an extent.
For instance, there's been studies that shows that people identifying as a certain gender different than "tHE sOcIaLLy iMpOseD" have more hormones in their brains from that gender they identify with.
So that's a biological and scientifical reason to support the idea of people identifying as other's genders.
But just saying that Trans people deserves a Trans category.
It's not a matter of being against anybody, just get the category just like there's categories for disabled people.
That's equality, I support equality, the one that treats everyone as persons and nothing else.
I made an edit that may help clarify the problem I am seeing in it if you want to check again. The main contradiction I see is in the idea presented that we don't need "trans" categorization ignoring the fact that the solution presented already relies on trans categorization.
Oh i see. But wouldn't they be leveled in height and weight (and wathever more may be needed) in their respective genders?
Wouldn't that be counterintutive to create a separate category for people who would have pretty much equal builds and able to compete with people from the "original" category?
Despite biological/physical facts/obviousness, people often brings "aDvaNcEd BiOloGy" to the matter.
To which I sometimes agree... to an extent.
For instance, there's been studies that shows that people identifying as a certain gender different than "tHE sOcIaLLy iMpOseD" have more hormones in their brains from that gender they identify with.
So that's a biological and scientifical reason to support the idea of people identifying as other's genders.
But just saying that Trans people deserves a Trans category.
It's not a matter of being against anybody, just get the category just like there's categories for disabled people.
That's equality, I support equality, the one that treats everyone as persons and nothing else.
TBH when you watch womens sports and mens sports you don't care about height or weight unless it's something like boxing where some featherweight champion would get knocked out by a heavyweight champion. What you want to see is the most skilled, fastest (etc) people in the world, not some "fair" category. Imagine how boring basketball would be if eveyone was the same size or they couldn't play, you would want the tallest and most skilled people to play. You don't have women's and men's sports for no reason, you are well aware that men are stronger/faster and their bodys are vastly different. A man claiming to be a women might have a mental issue, however they still have a mans body and the advantages that brings - that's why these "trans" men are dominating in womens sports and "trans" women are not dominating in mens sports. These people are nothing more than cheats and anti-women. They claim to want equality - but want to strip the rights of women away to further their own agenda.
Oh i see. But wouldn't they be leveled in height and weight (and wathever more may be needed) in their respective genders?
Wouldn't that be counterintutive to create a separate category for people who would have pretty much equal builds and able to compete with people from the "original" category?
Like that MMA trans fighter that broke a female's skull?
Gee!
Im sure that trans mma fighter got her skull shrunken enough to compete agains a biologically inferior woman.
Wonder why women's skull are much smaller and fragile than a man's?
"bUt thEy gOt WeIgHtEd"
"wOmeN aRe cLeArly wEak"
"gO tRanS"
TBH when you watch womens sports and mens sports you don't care about height or weight unless it's something like boxing where some featherweight champion would get knocked out by a heavyweight champion. What you want to see is the most skilled, fastest (etc) people in the world, not some "fair" category. Imagine how boring basketball would be if eveyone was the same size or they couldn't play, you would want the tallest and most skilled people to play. You don't have women's and men's sports for no reason, you are well aware that men are stronger/faster and their bodys are vastly different. A man claiming to be a women might have a mental issue, however they still have a mans body and the advantages that brings - that's why these "trans" men are dominating in womens sports and "trans" women are not dominating in mens sports. These people are nothing more than cheats and anti-women. They claim to want equality - but want to strip the rights of women away to further their own agenda.
Oh i see. But wouldn't they be leveled in height and weight (and wathever more may be needed) in their respective genders?
Wouldn't that be counterintutive to create a separate category for people who would have pretty much equal builds and able to compete with people from the "original" category?
As your quote says, height and weight, too. They are also categories.
My point is that they are using "transition status" to determine if they are fair competition with other males or females. It is a bit besides the point, but I'd assume that needs to have a stable constant that we can measure?
If a transitioner can "compete fairly" with other women because he/she/they are just as weak as the strongest women, this is the recipe to turn women's (and in extension, all) sports into a bio-engineering playground. If you ask me, it is already noticeable.
Today, April 8th, 2024, at 4PM PT, marks the day in which Nintendo permanently ends support for both the 3DS and the Wii U online services, which include co-op play...
A new Nintendo Switch firmware update is here. System software version 18.0.1 has been released. This update offers the typical stability features as all other...
With Apple having recently updated their guidelines for the App Store, iOS users have been left to speculate on specific wording and whether retro emulators as we...
The time has finally come, and after many, many years (if not decades) of Apple users having to side load emulator apps into their iOS devices through unofficial...
TheFlow has done it again--a new kernel exploit has been released for PlayStation 4 consoles. This latest exploit is called PPPwn, and works on PlayStation 4 systems...
Nintendo might just as well be a law firm more than a videogame company at this point in time, since they have yet again issued their now almost trademarked usual...
Another video game prototype has been found and preserved, and this time, it's none other than the game that spawned an entire franchise beloved by many, the very...
Anbernic is back with yet another retro handheld device. The upcoming RG28XX is another console sporting the quad-core H700 chip of the company's recent RG35XX 2024...
Two classic titles join the Nintendo Switch Online Expansion Pack game lineup. Available starting April 24th will be the motorcycle racing game Extreme G and another...
Nintendo has recently announced through their social media accounts that a new Indie World stream will be airing tomorrow, scheduled for April 17th, 2024 at 7 a.m. PT...
Today, April 8th, 2024, at 4PM PT, marks the day in which Nintendo permanently ends support for both the 3DS and the Wii U online services, which include co-op play...
Nintendo might just as well be a law firm more than a videogame company at this point in time, since they have yet again issued their now almost trademarked usual...
While rumors had been floating about rampantly as to the future plans of Nintendo, the President of the company, Shuntaro Furukawa, made a brief statement confirming...
With Apple having recently updated their guidelines for the App Store, iOS users have been left to speculate on specific wording and whether retro emulators as we...
The time has finally come, and after many, many years (if not decades) of Apple users having to side load emulator apps into their iOS devices through unofficial...
A new Nintendo Switch firmware update is here. System software version 18.0.1 has been released. This update offers the typical stability features as all other...
TheFlow has done it again--a new kernel exploit has been released for PlayStation 4 consoles. This latest exploit is called PPPwn, and works on PlayStation 4 systems...
DOOM is well-known for being ported to basically every device with some kind of input, and that list now includes the old retro game console in Persona 5 Royal...
Two classic titles join the Nintendo Switch Online Expansion Pack game lineup. Available starting April 24th will be the motorcycle racing game Extreme G and another...
Nintendo has recently announced through their social media accounts that a new Indie World stream will be airing tomorrow, scheduled for April 17th, 2024 at 7 a.m. PT...