Xbox 360 S with Kinect vs 3DS vs NGP

[croagunk.master]

This is for my friend. He already has a ps3 and a ds lite, so keeping that in mind, state your views. No fanboys please! Tell me which one is the best to get.

 

[DeadLocked]

ngp
thank you, good bye.

EDIT: alright if you want a reason, he has a ps3 which is similar to xbox, he has a ds lite so 3DS won't feel THAT new, NGP is the one thing he hasn't got anything similar to.

 

[VentusVanitas]

Like I said in the Ask Gbatemp, NGP hasn't been revealed in it's entirety.

But based on first impressions, NGP for Uncharted, and 3DS for Zelda.

Screw Kinect, it's a freaking gimmicky piece of unresponsive crap.

So, go between NGP and 3DS.

 

[croagunk.master]

ngp
thank you, good bye.

State your reason. NGP is wayy too similar to the PS3.

 

[Guild McCommunist]

ngp
thank you, good bye.

State your reason. NGP is wayy too similar to the PS3.

Outside of it being handheld, having touchscreens, different controls, etc. I have a feeling that they'll allow NGP games to be played on a PS3, but you'll need a NGP first. There's gonna be touchscreen games I assume and how will they make up for that, for example?

Kinect is trash. Simply no good games for it and nothing interesting coming out for it for a long time.

3DS looks alright but the opening line-up is mediocre and the 3D seems like it'll be such a throwaway feature. You'll turn it on, go "WOAH IT'S SLIGHTLY POPPING OUT!", lose enthusiasm for it, and turn the slider off for the rest of the time.

I'd say NGP myself.

 

[croagunk.master]

Thanks for the suggestions. Keep 'em coming!

 

[Langin]

3DS, if he/she, really like Nintendo with their games, then yeah!

I have no particular reason for this.

 

[croagunk.master]

Any more suggestions?

 

[Depravo]

The best one for him is whichever one has the games he wants to play most.

 

[croagunk.master]

The best one for him is whichever one has the games he wants to play most.

He doesn't know much about videogames.

 

[rockstar99]

NGP because the PS3 already serves as a home console and is better than a 360 anyways.You can even link up the NGP to PS3 to play NGP games on the big screen.

 

[croagunk.master]

NGP because the PS3 already serves as a home console and is better than a 360 anyways.You can even link up the NGP to PS3 to play NGP games on the big screen.

Yeah but, isn't the NGP launch lineup identical to the games that are already present on the PS3?

 

[rockstar99]

NGP because the PS3 already serves as a home console and is better than a 360 anyways.You can even link up the NGP to PS3 to play NGP games on the big screen.

Yeah but, isn't the NGP launch lineup identical to the games that are already present on the PS3?

We dont know the launch lineup.

 

[croagunk.master]

NGP because the PS3 already serves as a home console and is better than a 360 anyways.You can even link up the NGP to PS3 to play NGP games on the big screen.

Yeah but, isn't the NGP launch lineup identical to the games that are already present on the PS3?

We dont know the launch lineup.

http://www.1up.com/do/blogEntry?bId=9069715

The games are identical to the games already present on the PS3 and the PSP.

 

[ByteMunch]

3DS or NGP, but i'd say wait till there's more info on the NGP

 

[rockstar99]

NGP because the PS3 already serves as a home console and is better than a 360 anyways.You can even link up the NGP to PS3 to play NGP games on the big screen.

Yeah but, isn't the NGP launch lineup identical to the games that are already present on the PS3?

We dont know the launch lineup.

http://www.1up.com/do/blogEntry?bId=9069715

The games are identical to the games already present on the PS3 and the PSP.

Its fake
No MH
Also franchises are the same, the games might be different

 

[croagunk.master]

NGP because the PS3 already serves as a home console and is better than a 360 anyways.You can even link up the NGP to PS3 to play NGP games on the big screen.

Yeah but, isn't the NGP launch lineup identical to the games that are already present on the PS3?

We dont know the launch lineup.

http://www.1up.com/do/blogEntry?bId=9069715

The games are identical to the games already present on the PS3 and the PSP.

Its fake
No MH
Also franchises are the same, the games might be different

Yeah, you're right. It might be fake. Also, don't you think that the price will be a bit too high when it launches?

 

[Langin]

NGP because the PS3 already serves as a home console and is better than a 360 anyways.You can even link up the NGP to PS3 to play NGP games on the big screen.

Yeah but, isn't the NGP launch lineup identical to the games that are already present on the PS3?

We dont know the launch lineup.

http://www.1up.com/do/blogEntry?bId=9069715

The games are identical to the games already present on the PS3 and the PSP.

Its fake
No MH
Also franchises are the same, the games might be different

Yeah, you're right. It might be fake. Also, don't you think that the price will be a bit too high when it launches?

Maybe, but they may lower the price soon. If it is really to high, that only fanboys of sony buy themselves one.

 

[rockstar99]

NGP because the PS3 already serves as a home console and is better than a 360 anyways.You can even link up the NGP to PS3 to play NGP games on the big screen.

Yeah but, isn't the NGP launch lineup identical to the games that are already present on the PS3?

We dont know the launch lineup.

http://www.1up.com/do/blogEntry?bId=9069715

The games are identical to the games already present on the PS3 and the PSP.

Its fake
No MH
Also franchises are the same, the games might be different

Yeah, you're right. It might be fake. Also, don't you think that the price will be a bit too high when it launches?

Yeah it will but when you asked, I answered regardless of price because I didnt have your budget

 

[Guild McCommunist]

http://www.1up.com/do/blogEntry?bId=9069715

The games are identical to the games already present on the PS3 and the PSP.

Its fake
No MH
Also franchises are the same, the games might be different

That article is complete crap too. A good chunk of it is speculation or just the OP being a fanboy. Idiots think the PSP library is nothing but "watered down versions of console games". People with actual coherent thought think it has at least a decent library.

And there's NO announced launch line-up for the NGP. I mean they showed off some of that Uncharted game, announced a few franchises that'll be on there, and demoed some PS3 games on there. That's about it. I mean, the 3DS was announced with Kid Icarus and Ocarina of Time and all these other games coming out for it but when you look at the launch line-up now, you don't see a lot of those announced titles on there.