I say Ps3 Move and Wii Remotes over Kinect.

 

Both the Move and Kinect are technically superior to the Wii, but when it comes to the library of games (using motion), you have to go for the Wii.

 

PS3 - Blu-ray player, better graphics, 3DTV compatable, Move - better system all around. I own a wii and the game selection sux for adults, wii motion plus support isn't there. Xbox is playing catch up and charges for their live network (netflix requires gold for example).

I guess if you want a completely pwned system though, the wii is it lol

 

move/ps3 has my vote, although if you want the largest library of games that have motion controls then definitely go for the wii.
Kinect just doesn't really appeal to me when I think about the fact that there is NO controller, you have to do everything. I guess it would be fun for a while, but I just cant take it seriously when I think about waving my arms around and rolling on the floor while being watched by a camera. And think of first person shooters on it...
Thats not to say Kinect is crap or anything, its just not for me

But back to the ps3/move and wii. I have both, and they are both fun, but I enjoy the move better. It's got HD graphics, and just seems far more responsive. There is also the fact that it uses a camera, so they could put you in to the game (like in eyepet), and its also got a decent mic, so you wont have to get a headset or anything to talk online.

 

Look into each console game libraries. See which console has the most game you want.

Though I recommend Wii, because it has a lot more fun games with motion controls. For $199, you'll get Wii + Wiimote Plus + Nunchunk + Wii Sports + Wii Sports Resort. It is the best package available with a valued price.

Kinect, while unique, currently lacks good game that utilizes its full potential. Move is very similar to Wiimote.