Neat. Proof of concept.
I'm surprised that the PS1 actually can notice the ATIP wobble. I've always had my doubt about this. Normally read-only drives don't notice it (the signal from the pregroove is at least an order of magnitude weaker than the main signal)… in addition to the small amplitude.
This makes the task significantly hard than I thought; and I already thought it was VERY hard.
I've not really understood what has been modified on the writer in order to write
a) bigger (like Plextor GigaRec in reverse mode)
b) strange patterns simulating the wobble
My own thoughts went more into the direction of abusing the tracking coils while writing a CD with the help of an external signal. No idea if this is even possible at the insane speed needed (22.05KHz multiplied with the current write speed).
Neat. Proof of concept.
I'm surprised that the PS1 actually can notice the ATIP wobble. I've always had my doubt about this. Normally read-only drives don't notice it (the signal from the pregroove is at least an order of magnitude weaker than the main signal)… in addition to the small amplitude.
This makes the task significantly hard than I thought; and I already thought it was VERY hard.
I've not really understood what has been modified on the writer in order to write
a) bigger (like Plextor GigaRec in reverse mode)
b) strange patterns simulating the wobble
My own thoughts went more into the direction of abusing the tracking coils while writing a CD with the help of an external signal. No idea if this is even possible at the insane speed needed (22.05KHz multiplied with the current write speed).
There is a 22khz filter specifically for testing the wobble on the PSX (among other hardware I believe). From my understanding, what he is doing is burning abnormally long pits and lands to the point that it is affecting the tracking, generating the exact same signal as i.e. a modchip. He is sort of writing over the actual pits and lands by making them so large (which effectively removes the 22khz CD-R signal since this causes the CD-R to spin faster and the PSX 'misses' the telltale sign that this is a CD-R and not a licensed CD-ROM). He does this in the lead-in (which is normally zero data) right next to (and sometimes over) the TOC since this is very early days and the method hasn't been perfected.
All of the issues this has currently (besides booting reliability) can be worked around by making a self-booting Tonyhax Boot CD which then just plays whatever normal CD-R backups or import discs. I really can't wait for more info to be released.
There is a 22khz filter specifically for testing the wobble on the PSX (among other hardware I believe). From my understanding, what he is doing is burning abnormally long pits and lands to the point that it is affecting the tracking, generating the exact same signal as i.e. a modchip. He is sort of writing over the actual pits and lands by making them so large (which effectively removes the 22khz CD-R signal since this causes the CD-R to spin faster and the PSX 'misses' the telltale sign that this is a CD-R and not a licensed CD-ROM). He does this in the lead-in (which is normally zero data) right next to (and sometimes over) the TOC since this is very early days and the method hasn't been perfected.
All of the issues this has currently (besides booting reliability) can be worked around by making a self-booting Tonyhax Boot CD which then just plays whatever normal CD-R backups or import discs. I really can't wait for more info to be released.
With this new development squash some of my assumptions:
ATIP will not to be detected as wobble due to very tiny amplitude.
This is why I've never considered speeding up or slowing down – this idea suggests itself – to prevent the 22KHz filter noticing it. This makes the PS1 protection even more impressive than it already is.
A burner with CFW can't do anything to create wobble.
I still believe the firmware has no direct control over the tracking hardware and can't introduce deliberate tracking error
Not writing wobble but something else to simulate it fooling the detector is what I've not considered
I've been thinking about this topic up and down to the point it is driving me insane. And with my extremely low skill level I could not do anything myself.
To the person who made it this far:
=========
I still want to know if the tracking coils are able to wobble fast enough to write a wobbled track. I have to emphasize that neither the PS1 nor a PC drive actively follows the ATIP wobble. The lens normally does not move that fast (a service manual mentioned 5KHz as cutoff frequency where the pickup stops trying to follow tracking error). The deliberate ATIP wobble has such a low amplitude that it doesn't cause any problems not actively following it. It can be noticed by different light intensity on each light detector while staying in center of the track.
Some explanation without warranty for correctness – to the best of my knowledge – might be wrong, or incomplete:
==============================================================================================
The sled can not remotely be positioned as accurate as it would be needed. In normal operation the tracking hardware gradually moves the lens from one side to the other following the spiral track – roughly moving the laser 1.6µm per rotation. At some point the sled has to move a bit and tracking coils move the lens back to the other side… gradually following the track until the sled moves a bit…
This is very, very far from 22.05KHz movement frequency. Let alone faster! If we burn at 4x the movement frequency required would be 88.2KHz so that the resulting signal meets the expectations of the PS1.
Yesterday – lucky coincidence – I bought a used and not really working all-in-one HiFi thing (3CD changer with MP3 support, 2 music cassette, radio, external input). Gave the lens a cleaning and now it is running smoothly. What has this to do with the topic? I could see the servo in extreme action on this thing! Not the tracking, but the focus servo. The CD drive is of exceptionally low quality with a HUGE imbalance. Not defective or worn, just really bad. Even when spinning the CD while the machine is off shows to the naked eye the disc goes up and down… and so does the focus servo with the lens to keep in focus (completely successful!)
That is the speed in which the focus (and tracking) usually work. As we can easily see it ourselves by just looking, it should be pretty clear that this is not in kilohertz range.
Granted, the wobble movement required for introducing a slight tracking error is much smaller – a tiny fraction of the maximum movement sideways. But the required frequency is insane!
A comment on the larger pit size speeding up the CD in the read process:
===========================================================
In certain boundaries this is within the specification. A 63min CD-R rotates roughly 17% faster compared to common CDs. Going to 150% speed like mentioned in the thread is pretty extreme, but can be done with Plextors out of the box (and usually does not cause trouble reading). The question is: Is it necessary to go that far? How much faster does it have to spin for the detector not noticing ATIP anymore? The other mentioned problem – reducing the pit size back to normal after the lead-in area – would be easier if the speedup was less extreme.
Despite the CD standard demanding the pit size to not have more than 0.1% deviation across the whole disc(!), drives are very lenient and can synchronize with changing data density (SecuROM new for example has sudden changes of 3% in data density up/down and for the most causes no problems despite violating the standard heavily). I fully agree with the suggested idea: Gradually reduce size back to normal in small steps. Should not lose sync this way or cause read errors and burn full commercial games without torturing the aging mechanical parts by permanent higher speed than intended.
What I can add for the other direction – slowdown: PS1 does not perform well with smaller pits. I could get GigaRec 1.2 (83% of normal pit size) to be detected as audio CD. No chance with level 1.3 (77% of normal pit size). Generally no drive is obliged to read discs with smaller than normal pit size.
A burner giving accurate control over the pit size (with ability to change on the fly) would be able to fully beat SecuROM (maybe also the DVD version).
A new Nintendo Switch firmware update is here. System software version 18.0.1 has been released. This update offers the typical stability features as all other...
As each year passes, retro games become harder and harder to play, as the physical media begins to fall apart and becomes more difficult and expensive to obtain. The...
While rumors had been floating about rampantly as to the future plans of Nintendo, the President of the company, Shuntaro Furukawa, made a brief statement confirming...
TheFlow has done it again--a new kernel exploit has been released for PlayStation 4 consoles. This latest exploit is called PPPwn, and works on PlayStation 4 systems...
Nintendo might just as well be a law firm more than a videogame company at this point in time, since they have yet again issued their now almost trademarked usual...
Nintendo has officially announced that a successor to the beloved Switch console is on the horizon. As we eagerly anticipate what innovations this new device will...
Another video game prototype has been found and preserved, and this time, it's none other than the game that spawned an entire franchise beloved by many, the very...
Anbernic is back with yet another retro handheld device. The upcoming RG28XX is another console sporting the quad-core H700 chip of the company's recent RG35XX 2024...
DOOM is well-known for being ported to basically every device with some kind of input, and that list now includes the old retro game console in Persona 5 Royal...
Two classic titles join the Nintendo Switch Online Expansion Pack game lineup. Available starting April 24th will be the motorcycle racing game Extreme G and another...
Nintendo has officially announced that a successor to the beloved Switch console is on the horizon. As we eagerly anticipate what innovations this new device will...
While rumors had been floating about rampantly as to the future plans of Nintendo, the President of the company, Shuntaro Furukawa, made a brief statement confirming...
Nintendo might just as well be a law firm more than a videogame company at this point in time, since they have yet again issued their now almost trademarked usual...
As each year passes, retro games become harder and harder to play, as the physical media begins to fall apart and becomes more difficult and expensive to obtain. The...
Ubisoft has today officially revealed the next installment in the Assassin's Creed franchise: Assassin's Creed Shadows. This entry is set in late Sengoku-era Japan...
A new Nintendo Switch firmware update is here. System software version 18.0.1 has been released. This update offers the typical stability features as all other...
TheFlow has done it again--a new kernel exploit has been released for PlayStation 4 consoles. This latest exploit is called PPPwn, and works on PlayStation 4 systems...
After rumour got out about an upcoming NES Edition release for the famed Nintendo World Championships, Nintendo has officially unveiled the new game, titled "Nintendo...
DOOM is well-known for being ported to basically every device with some kind of input, and that list now includes the old retro game console in Persona 5 Royal...
The number of layoffs and cuts in the videogame industry sadly continue to grow, with the latest huge layoffs coming from Microsoft, due to what MIcrosoft calls a...
@Jayro, I don't see whats so special about the DS ML, its just a DS lite in a phat shell. At least the phat model had louder speakers, whereas the lite has a much better screen.
@SylverReZ if you could find a v5 DS ML you would have the best of both worlds since the v5 units had the same backlight brightness levels as the DS Lite unlockable with flashme
A woman with no arms and no legs was sitting on a beach. A man comes along and the woman says, "I've never been hugged before." So the man feels bad and hugs her. She says "Well i've also never been kissed before." So he gives her a kiss on the cheek. She says "Well I've also never been fucked before." So the man picks her up, and throws her in the ocean and says "Now you're fucked."
You can buy drm free games / music / ebooks, and if you keep backups of your data (like documents and family photos etc), then you shouldn't lose the game. but with a disk, your toddler could put it in the toaster and there goes your $60