"
KINGOFNOOBS," I don't want to beat a dead horse, but I thought I'd mention a few things about your edited post.
There is no doubt that the price difference between a 512Mb SC Lite setup and G6 Lite setup is small. Sure, assuming that you can get a card reader for $4.99, you can get a 512Mb SC Lite setup for $100.98 (RHS + Newegg) as opposed to the G6 RHS bundle for $112.00.
I am not sure how you arrived at $97, as the memory is $23.99 without shipping on Newegg. If you use my earlier values (taken from Winsunx) and replace my value of $11.00 for the card reader with your value of $4.99, you will see that the price is virtually identical ($110.685 - SC vs. $110.215 - G6). I think this is just a result of the markup, shipping costs etc. on both items being slightly different on Winsunx and RHS. However, as I stated earlier, the 512Mb memory is slower than non-Ultra memory and is not as fast as the internal memory of the G6. Thus, given the neglible price difference of the two cards (when going the 512Mb route), I think the G6 Lite would provide a better experience and is a better deal overall.
You still have the "
And you get twice the memory.. (for cheaper/same price as G6 Lite)" line in your last post. As your own values indicate, that is not the case. I assume you just forgot to edit that line out. For the 1 Gig solution you used the slower and cheaper, non-Ultra
memory. To estimate costs for a 1Gig setup, I have been using this
memory which is more expensive and recommended by most. (It gives the closest performance to the internal memory of the G6 Lite.) Even still, you came up with a value that is more costly.