Remove subtitles from videos?

ShadowSoldier · Nov 29, 2013

I use my PS3 with PS3 Media Server to stream all of my downloaded stuff to the TV, but some files I don't like to watch because it bugs me, mainly the ones with subtitles.

I recently downloaded an english dubbed torrent of Highschool Of The Dead but the problem is when I watch it on the TV, it has subtitles although it's english dubbed. I already tried in the options on the PS3 to turn subs off, but obviously it only works for files on movies and such.

So is there a way that I can, on my computer, go to the videos, and take the subtitles out? For H.O.T.D it's .mkv files, and obviously I can turn the subtitles off in VLC/MPC but I want to permanently take them out so I can watch them on my PS3.

trumpet-205 · Nov 29, 2013

Is it hard subbed or soft subbed? You can only remove subtitle if it is soft subbed.

basher11 · Nov 29, 2013

assuming you downloaded soft subbed, use mkvmerge to mux the subtitles out.

ShadowSoldier · Nov 29, 2013

trumpet-205 said:
Is it hard subbed or soft subbed? You can only remove subtitle if it is soft subbed.

How do I know if it's soft or hard? (hue hue hue hue hue)

I just know that I'm able to turn them off in VLC.

If you mean is there a file in the folder of subtitles, there isn't. Only pics and videos.

basher11 · Nov 29, 2013

ShadowSoldier said:
How do I know if it's soft or hard? (hue hue hue hue hue)

I just know that I'm able to turn them off in VLC.

If you mean is there a file in the folder of subtitles, there isn't. Only pics and videos.

if you can turn them off they're soft subbed.

trumpet-205 · Nov 29, 2013

ShadowSoldier said:
How do I know if it's soft or hard? (hue hue hue hue hue)

I just know that I'm able to turn them off in VLC.

If you mean is there a file in the folder of subtitles, there isn't. Only pics and videos.

If you can turn it off in a video player, it is soft subbed.

Files such as mkv and mp4 are containers, a package if you will. Inside them consist of video track, audio track, and optionally subtitle files. In hard subbed case, there is no subtitle files, subtitle is burned into video track. There is no way to remove subtitle for hard subbed video.

For soft subbed case, simply use mkvmerge to remux mkv files without subtitle files.

YayMii · Nov 29, 2013

Hard subbed means that the subtitles are hard-encoded into the video, i.e. they're part of the video itself instead of just a text overlay. If you can turn them off in VLC, I'm sure they're soft-subbed. AFAIK, there is a way to disable them on the PS3's media player, but if you want to permanently get rid of them, you can try re-encoding the video files.

trumpet-205 · Nov 29, 2013

YayMii said:
Hard subbed means that the subtitles are hard-encoded into the video, i.e. they're part of the video itself instead of just a text overlay. If you can turn them off in VLC, I'm sure they're soft-subbed. AFAIK, there is a way to disable them on the PS3's media player, but if you want to permanently get rid of them, you can try re-encoding the video files.

You don't need to re-encode video files when dealing with soft subbed video files.

Simply use mkvmerge to remux mkv.

FAST6191 · Nov 29, 2013

For the record you can remove hard subs.
The obvious start is if they are in the black bars at the bottom of the screen then you can just crop and reform as necessary.

After that/if you are not that lucky the logo removal tools can be used. It is an absolute pig to do really well though unless you are lucky enough to have alpha subs.

From what has been said though it sounds like you have soft subs so I will stop here, as others said if your player forces them on then just remux the video but leave the subs out of it.

Tom Bombadildo · Nov 29, 2013

Because this is SS, it's probably best to link to a tutorial on how to do so.

That should have enough instructions on how to do it. (I only skimmed through the video though)

YayMii · Nov 29, 2013

trumpet-205 said:
You don't need to re-encode video files when dealing with soft subbed video files.

Simply use mkvmerge to remux mkv.

I simply suggested one way of getting rid of the subtitles. I know it's a bit more than necessary, but it was the first thing that came to my mind, and it does do what OP asked for.

ShadowSoldier · Nov 30, 2013

Tom Bombadildo said:
Because this is SS, it's probably best to link to a tutorial on how to do so.

You do know you can just ignore me.. right?

jargus · Nov 30, 2013

Just add the file to handbrake and leave the subs off. Problem solved

Tom Bombadildo · Nov 30, 2013

ShadowSoldier said:
You do know you can just ignore me.. right?

I was referring to how it's well-known you don't know all that much technology is all. :rolleyes:

trumpet-205 · Nov 30, 2013

jargus said:
Just add the file to handbrake and leave the subs off. Problem solved

Handbrake re-encodes video, not muxing them.

Each time you encode a video the quality degrades. When dealing the soft subtitle, you only need to remux the file. Re-encode video not only cause quality to drop, but also takes considerably longer than a simple remux.

rachelgreenhappy · Nov 27, 2018

ShadowSoldier said:
I use my PS3 with PS3 Media Server to stream all of my downloaded stuff to the TV, but some files I don't like to watch because it bugs me, mainly the ones with subtitles.

I recently downloaded an english dubbed torrent of Highschool Of The Dead but the problem is when I watch it on the TV, it has subtitles although it's english dubbed. I already tried in the options on the PS3 to turn subs off, but obviously it only works for files on movies and such.

So is there a way that I can, on my computer, go to the videos, and take the subtitles out? For H.O.T.D it's .mkv files, and obviously I can turn the subtitles off in VLC/MPC but I want to permanently take them out so I can watch them on my PS3.

You may try iDealshare VideoGo which can remove soft or hard subtitles from videos, it also helps to extract subtitles from videos or add subtitles to videos.
Simply google search how to use iDealshare VideoGo to remove subtitles from videos, you may will a step by step guide

cearp · Nov 27, 2018

you probably won't have to mux them out, in the mkvtoolnix tools just set the subtitle stream to default to 'off' - something like that

unless your player is forcing them on no matter what...?

slimhakz · Jan 16, 2019

If the subtitled are actually part of the video; your best bet would be to crop the video.

Remove subtitles from videos?

Well-Known Member

Embrace the darkness within

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Embrace the darkness within

hi

Embrace the darkness within

Techromancer

Dick, With Balls

hi

Well-Known Member

Well-Known Member

Dick, With Balls

Embrace the darkness within

New Member

瓜老外

Active Member

Similar threads

Popular threads in this forum