Gaming Dead Space or I am Alive?

[Guest0000]

Next week both games will be discounted to under $8 on US PSN. Am thinking of grabbing one with my $9 credit. So, which game has:
- more interestingness
- more fun
- better pacing or less mundane
- better controls
- less bugs
- more action
- good but not punishingly frustrating challenge
- more replayability

I know the similarity is only survival and one is a digital only game. If you're itching to comment on another game, you may compare Dead Space 2 with the rest. (; DS 2 will be discounted to $10.

Merci

 

[Wombo Combo]

Dead space is more fun imo.

 

[Terenigma]

Dead space 2 is better than both of those games but you should play the first game. So my vote goes Dead space.

 

[Guest0000]

Dead space 2 is better than both of those games but you should play the first game. So my vote goes Dead space.

Okay, no love for I am Alive it seems...

Time for a digress:
- If I want to pick up just ONE Dead Space right now, which one from the trilogy should I pick? I love horror but my brain is different than most--I'm wired to fight instead of flight in that situation. I prefer good controls over horror inducing tank controls.