Phoenix Wright: Trials and Tribulations is officially my favourite DS game of all time. The story really got to me and the twists and everything were great. What also made this story better was how all the cases were directly linked. This should be GOTY 2007.
Obviously, I loved Zelda: PH as much as the next guy, but seriously all PH brought in was gameplay. Story was the same, Graphics pretty much the same. Frankly, the new gameplay with the timed dungeon and phantoms actually deterred me from the game.