The Hori Pro Controller has an X360-like D-Pad. That's horrible. Basically for this I'd prefer the Pro Conttroller. And people comparing prices are just saying whatever. The original Xbox One controller costed around 70 bucks, was bad (that's why they replaced them with the One S Controller), and the XB1 costed a merely 500 bucks at this time. The Wii U Pro Controller also costed around 75 bucks when it was released, and that's the same for all controller just after the release. In 5-6 months the price will have dropped.