Blaze163 said:
So...what you want is in essence a Piracy version of the Nintendo Seal of Quality.
There's pirating and there's just plain taking the piss, you know?
You don't get it. Haven't you ever DL'd NES, SNES, Genesis or most any other legacy game ROMs before? You pick one game and DL it and when you unzip it, there are multiple files in the zip.....the same damn ROM over and over with slight variations, and a different "bracket code" ("[!]", for example) to denote the integrity of each. I'm not suggesting that you download one # game and get all the dumps of that game in one zip like legacy systems did, that would be some huge DL's! No, just when something gets dumped, give it a "bracket code" classification based on the dumping tool used and the integrity of the dump. If it is a dupe of a previous dump, but varies in it's integrity from what was already out there, then it just gets classed with a "bracket code" and added to the previous dump's # listing. Dumps that are already out could just have no "bracket code" and that would denote them low quality dumps automatically, unless the "bracket code" has been determined for that dump.
This would add a strain to places that actually have ROMs to add all the extra files with different class ratings (or at least attempt to make them have the most "perfect" dump of a given game). It would also be rough for sites like GBAtemp who just lists releases to add all the info on different class dumps, but see, that's piracy ain't it? It's not supposed to be easy. Besides, most people will only continue to DL the same game over and over until they get one that works for them right? Might as well at least be able to determine if you are DL'ing a truly different dump, or just the same one over and over again. Those "bracket codes" sure were useful back in the day, why can't they still be useful, especially with the upcoming 3DS and its even stronger piracy measures and expected critiquing of ROM integrity by the system?
I'm not saying it must happen or anything, just that it seems logical to put something like this in place for clarification, amidst all the arguments and confusion, it could be a good compromise to make our little community more of a "happy place" again instead of all the bickering over "release rules" all the time. I may be no programmer, but I know there are people out there who can examine ROMs and make these sort of determinations for "bracket codes" on the dumps.
It would certainly add a familiar (and almost nostalgic), but useful dynamic to DS/DSi ROM dumps. Especially since there is now an ever-clearer picture of what "ROM integrity" even is as far as DS games are concerned.