Best ZELDA game

[Fluto]

windwaker FTW!!!

 

[prowler]

Order I played completed Zelda games

- Twilight Princess (First and easiest)
- Wind Waker (FUCK THE SEA, FUCK FINDING TRI-FORCE PIECES but still

 

[DeathStrudel]

A Link to the Past. I got it for Christmas as a young child along with my SNES. I'm actually in the middle of playing it for like the millionth time right now.
OoT is great, but it feels like they just took aLttP and upgraded the graphics. The basic plot of both of them is essentially the same: three pendants, master sword, dark world, seven sages(maidens descended from the seven sages in aLttP), Ganon.

 

[J-Mirage]

A Link to the Past by far. After Ocarina of Time, the other games were losing Zelda elements and making them more lineal with more puzzle fashion and no overworld.

 

[Deleted member 473940]

Ocarina of Time

! Good old memories..

 

[Sumea]

A Link to the Past by far. After Ocarina of Time, the other games were losing Zelda elements and making them more lineal with more puzzle fashion and no overworld.

Wait -
You are saying that GREAT FUCKING SEA is not overworld to rival OoT? Or Twilight Princess, what mind you, even if smaller than WW, is still larger than the one field in OoT. Granted, in mind of scale ALTTP may or may not be larger or smaller, of course, it is hard to compare.

I am all about opinions, but statements that refer to factual things that just cannot be said to be opinions (I.E. "OoT had overworld and WW and TP did not, my opinion makes it right" ) - I kinda have to butt in and say something against that kind of... THING.

Also, They did keep quite a lot of the core of OoT in everything after OoT, and kept refining the Zelda elements. Again, thing that is debated, some people want change, and others see it as negative...

Well, I am not one to say more, since Link to the past is damn refined 2D zelda and stays like that to date even with Minish Cap and other GameBoy additions and so on.

 

[Ikki]

A Link to the Past by far. After Ocarina of Time, the other games were losing Zelda elements and making them more lineal with more puzzle fashion and no overworld.

Twilight Princess' overworld was gianormous.

 

[unseen4ce]

Went for Majora's Mask. Classic that I still play on my laptop and which I hope to see on 3DS.

 

[Schlupi]

Wand of Gamelon was the best Zelda ever! even Faces of Evil.

Lol, you are about to get beat up by a bunch of Zelda fans. We geeks can pack the punch of a regular person when we all work together!

Don't say that without playing them or you'll get GANNON BANNED!

Oh nice. that site is FULL of LULZ.

 

[Lily]

I think the best Zelda game is A Link to the Past. Simply because it is. It's followed VERY VERY closely by Link's Awakening on the GB/C. Sometimes depending on my mood it's hard to choose, but ultimately A Link to the Past was the pinnacle of the series, and it's never even come close since. (Except for Majora's Mask, but it's such a different kind of game that it's hard to compare.)

 

[Sumea]

Went for Majora's Mask. Classic that I still play on my laptop and which I hope to see on 3DS.

You are doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:

 

[_Chaz_]

Went for Majora's Mask. Classic that I still play on my laptop and which I hope to see on 3DS.

You are doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:

You're doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:

 

[Sumea]

Went for Majora's Mask. Classic that I still play on my laptop and which I hope to see on 3DS.

You are doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:
*SNAP*

You're doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:
*SNIP*

Wrong, they both are A FORM of doing it right

yours is just THE FORM of doing it right

 

[CrimzonEyed]

I have played them all (and finished them all) and those are the top five Zelda games in my opinion.

1. The Legend of Zelda: A Link to the Past / Ocarina of Time (i simply can't decide wich one i think is better)
2. The Legend of Zelda: Wind Waker
3. The Legend of Zelda: Twilight Princess
4. The Legend of Zelda: Majora's Mask
5. The Legend of Zelda: The Minish Cap

 

[machomuu]

Went for Majora's Mask. Classic that I still play on my laptop and which I hope to see on 3DS.

You are doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:
*SNAP*

You're doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:
*SNIP*

Wrong, they both are A FORM of doing it right

yours is just THE FORM of doing it right

But by thus being right in doing it right wouldn't they both be...right?

 

[Ikki]

Went for Majora's Mask. Classic that I still play on my laptop and which I hope to see on 3DS.

You are doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:
*SNAP*

You're doing it wrong.
This is a form of doing it right:
*SNIP*

Wrong, they both are A FORM of doing it right

yours is just THE FORM of doing it right

But by thus being right in doing it right wouldn't they both be...right?

Yeah, right.

 

[Deleted member 67270]

As much as I like LttP and OoT, I gotta say that Majora's Mask is my favorite. Sure the 3-Day time limit and traveling back to day 1 can sometimes be annoying, but the dark and emotional theme portrayed in the game is pretty well done. Sometimes I wonder if Link ever suffers psychological problems from traveling back to day 1 all the time.

 

[J-Mirage]

A Link to the Past by far. After Ocarina of Time, the other games were losing Zelda elements and making them more lineal with more puzzle fashion and no overworld.

Twilight Princess' overworld was gianormous.

A overworld fucking boring and static. It was like stay on the Kokiri Forest without the surprises and fucking boring. I expect more of this on next Zelda.

 

[awssk8er]

I think I would have to say I got the most play time and enjoyment out of Twilight Princess.

 

[Sumea]

A Link to the Past by far. After Ocarina of Time, the other games were losing Zelda elements and making them more lineal with more puzzle fashion and no overworld.

Twilight Princess' overworld was gianormous.

A overworld fucking boring and static. It was like stay on the Kokiri Forest without the surprises and fucking boring. I expect more of this on next Zelda.

Saying that TP overworld is "boring and static" can be applied with same formula of judging to, I dunno, EVERY ZELDA OVERWORLD MAP EVER.