Reading all these posts, the begs the question- who DOES get paid here? Obviously it costs money to keep this website up, so is there a specific person/people getting the money?
And to the mods- how would your decision to become a mod have been swayed if you were offered pay? Would your thinking/reasoning change at all?
Who gets paid? The server host. The forum software, I think it's a subscription based license. The domain host. It costs a lot to run a site of this size and traffic.
Then, we have several competitions each year. Tempmas being one that soon will happen. And the Bounty has come back with 200 dollars of prize money, and a 500 dollar mini laptop thingy (sponsored!). The bounty happening 4 times a year.
And for those donating above a certain amount in the patreon, the ads are removed... which in turn means a "lack of income" from those ads.
Recently, Costello had to pay for some contest prizes from his own pocket (the Switch, comes to mind).
Oh, and paying the lodging for the reporter we sent off to E3.
So IF (and that's one big if) there's any money left to be made after all expenses, and all competitions, I think it's fair that the owner of the site gets a little spare change.
Now, if I was offered pay, would I have thought something else? Yes. I would have declined, or thought a lot more before accepting to join.
Getting paid puts a whole new level of pressure on you, to preform and to be very professional. But the biggest thing is how taxes and all the legal stuff that being paid brings to the table. Getting a paycheck from another country... hell, the banks here treat you as a criminal if you want to transfer $50 cash that you got from your granny for Christmas, to your bank account. They wanna do a background check, to see if the money comes from a criminal activity or if it's a case of money laundry.
So I would reconsider greatly if I was offered pay.