I'm using 1:1 dumps from my disc, and I'm fully satisfied with the loading speed. I don't care if it's 0.02sec instead of 0.03sec! (irony)
I'm already glad it can be launched from a loader and I don't need to swap the disc each time.
I personally don't see any use of compressed/extracted format to get a higher loading speed, but users seems to care while it's already faster than disc loading?
Not really.
When I was testing DML heavily, I did a lot of benchmarks with F-Zero GX, because I actually noticed the load times for some screens were longer than I remembered them. If I had not noticed it, it would not have been a problem, but noticing it prompted me to explore all options. For consistency, I measured the time it took to load the track selection screen after selecting one of the first four cups in Practice Mode (the fifth cup had longer loading time than the rest).
Here is what I found on my 32GB Lexar card:
- real GCN disc: 2 sec
- DiscEx format on SD @ 64KB clusters: 2.5 sec
- DiscEx format on SD @ 32KB clusters: 4.5 sec
- GCReEx format on SD @ 32KB & 64KB: 1.0 sec (both)
- DiscEx format on USB HD @ 32KB clusters: ~4 sec (this one I don't recall very well, but it was slow)
- GCReEx format on USB HD @ 32KB clusters: slightly less than 1.0 sec
So no, it's not milliseconds I'm talking about here. Now, some games don't have this issue at all, as far as I can tell. I never noticed any slowdowns with, say, Mario Kart Double Dash or Super Mario Sunshine. It really depends on the game and I did not test that many of them but I decided to optimize for the F-Zero GX worst case to avoid slowdowns in other games in the future. Also, some cards will have faster load times than others, particularly smaller ones. I tested DiscEx @ 64KB cluster size with a smaller card I have and the result was 2 sec, the same as the real disc but not as fast as GCReEx.
Knowing it is faster, I really see no reason not to use GCReEx, except on the few games that don't work with it. Once you extract the files, there is no additional maintenance required, so it's a one time effort.