If you had to pick one. I would pick A Link to the Past.
O O F, NICEDefinitely any Super Smash Bros... but if I had to choose... the 3DS version with DLC unlocked...
No wait...
Actually, If I had to choose a definite game it would be: Pacman Championship Edition 2
Its such a shame that the follow up Yoshi's Island games pretty much suck. Especially Yoshi's Story and DS.Any Pokemon MD game, Yoshi's Island on the SNES, and Fable on the OG Xbox. I play all of these games over and over again already.
Yoshi’s New Island was the worst offender of them all, that game was just flat out terrible. I was able to find some enjoyment out of Story and DS, but I found no joy out of New.Its such a shame that the follow up Yoshi's Island games pretty much suck. Especially Yoshi's Story and DS.
I think you're forgetting Yoshi Touch & GoYoshi’s New Island was the worst offender of them all, that game was just flat out terrible. I was able to find some enjoyment out of Story and DS, but I found no joy out of New.