Hacking Will my the 3DS brick?

  • Thread starter Thread starter Culeak
  • Start date Start date
  • Views Views 3,844
  • Replies Replies 25
Actually that is NOT the question here.
My reply was to someone claiming that it would be impossible for nintendo to brick 3ds that use flashcarts.
I simply want to point out that they 1) can in fact pull it of should they ever decide to and 2) already gone through with it in a similar case

What I said is, they can, and always could, but in this case, they don't have the right to do it!
Making something like that would result in huge amounts of people sueing Nintendo!
And as what was already proven, they are different cases, and in Wii's case, they had the right!
This is not about just bricking, but what way they are using to hack the system!
 
The OP asked if it can be done, and the current system does not do it.

The case is similar, but not the same. There's important differences. A misread of a real cart could result in a brick if they went the route you're talking about, but that's risky which is why Nintendo chose to go the current route. Note that both flash carts and misreads of real carts produce the same error from the console (which tells the user to refer to the manual, which gives generic help messages that don't even mention flash carts or piracy). This points out that giving a generic error is a conscious design decision by Nintendo, and there's some precedent as well. In the gameboy boot sequence, some static data is read from the cart (the Nintendo logo), and if the data is malformed the system locks up instead of going on to read and possibly run corrupt data. In addition to not allowing carts with modified data to boot, this can save the user headaches such as games corrupting or erasing their save data if the gameboy starts reading and then executing bad instructions.

On a technical level there's quite a difference in risk associated with modifying firmware versus using a third-part accessory (which a flash cart is). How many people do we see bricking their PSPs by modifying flash0 and touching other stuff they don't need to? Lots, and they have themselves to blame, Sony has no obligation to help them because they're the ones that messed the system up with unauthorized modification of the unit itself. How many people do we see bricking their DSi and 3DS units by modifying the internal software? None, it doesn't happen. The unit itself is never modified, that's the important distinction.

"Well if things were different they could brick it." Yes, and if Scar helped Mufasa up the clif instead of throwing him off in The Lion King, the movie would turn out differently, duh... but that's not how it is.
 
"Well if things were different they could brick it." Yes, and if Scar helped Mufasa up the clif instead of throwing him off in The Lion King, the movie would turn out differently, duh... but that's not how it is.
I laughed.

Costello...

EDIT: Anyways, OP got his question answered, all this stupid bickering is just...stupid.
 
The OP asked if it can be done, and the current system does not do it.

"Well if things were different they could brick it." Yes, and if Scar helped Mufasa up the clif instead of throwing him off in The Lion King, the movie would turn out differently, duh... but that's not how it is.
That something is not done does not mean that it is impossible to do.

The wiis firmware can be (and regularly is) updated.
That something is not done now does not mean that it won't be done in the future.

But if you chose to believe otherwise I can't help you.

 
That something is not done does not mean that it is impossible to do.
Just because something can be done doesn't mean it will be done, or that it's a good idea.

The wiis firmware can be (and regularly is) updated.
The DSi and 3DS have firmware updates as well.

That something is not done now does not mean that it won't be done in the future.
I'm making an educated guess based on all the past experiences. There's no cases of the Wii being bricked that are congruent to the DSi and 3DS. If I can see a case where the Wii purposely bricks itself due to a third-party accessory, then the way the two units are used for homebrew and the risks associated with them will change, but that's not how it is.

But if you chose to believe otherwise I can't help you.
If you want to live in a fantasy world I can't help you. :P
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum