There are Japanese stores selling brand new black Taito paddles at the original suggested retail price of $20. In fact, I found two stores! Neither of them do international shipping, however, I can order using a mail forwarding service for one of them! The base cost of mail forwarding, however, would be $20.
I was thinking, since these seem to sell out so quickly, there's a good chance people would be interested in getting some at a low price. If enough people are down for it, we can place an order together and the mail forwarding wouldn't be a cost issue anymore. Then the controllers would be individually mailed out using economical shipping or dispersed by hand if you're local (I live in the GTA). Even better would be if someone had a friend living in Japan that would slap a new stamp on the box and send it on it's way, that kind of mail forwarding would be about 95% cheaper.