I will have to use the Dpad to tell and I am reserving all judgement until word of the triggers; I am with Gahars in that it needs to be all a la the 360 or nothing for me to care. That said I am probably on record as being one that really dislikes the dual shock controller (it does not work for long sessions and the rear buttons are pretty much the whole problem for me) so yeah.
Touchpad- I say go for it. After the DS every menu system on a console that is not a mouse feels horribly antiquated so even if it only gets used for those I can get there. I know it will probably end up used for nasty QTE stuff. Done well it could be a third stick of sorts and that could do camera issues a world of good.
If the light on top can change colours as signals of a form (health bar, warm/cold directions, some other bar....) that would be great, I fear there is probably some disability (reasonable logic, horribly limiting in practice) stuff that might kick that in the head though.
Touchpad- I say go for it. After the DS every menu system on a console that is not a mouse feels horribly antiquated so even if it only gets used for those I can get there. I know it will probably end up used for nasty QTE stuff. Done well it could be a third stick of sorts and that could do camera issues a world of good.
If the light on top can change colours as signals of a form (health bar, warm/cold directions, some other bar....) that would be great, I fear there is probably some disability (reasonable logic, horribly limiting in practice) stuff that might kick that in the head though.