I actually got a Guilty Verdict on Case One. Either they made the game harder or I should feel really bad. The whole thing with Presenting Profiles and Evidence now threw me off.
Yeah, I just got stuck on case 2, trial day 1, and so I'll have to do that over. Then again, its similar to a few times in the first game, where I knew one specific thing was wrong, but it wouldn't let me present that evidence at the time, and I missed something else apparently.
Yeah, this game, like they say in the story, asks you to sometimes get 'outside the box'. Even if you know where the contradiction and know which evidence to put forward, the characters don't necessarily think like you do, and the judge/jury needs the proofs to be put in the right order.
Just look in the first case. I caught up early that you'd be 'calling' on that phone as a proof, but first they threw you off with that question about either 'checking the contact list' or the other one I forgot. Even if its plain obvious for us, our friend Judge needs something concrete building up to it first