[Essentials] Manga

[GameSoul]

Just a comment: there are several anime-only and games entries on the list, and this is a manga list.
.

If you see any anime-only titles in the list, could you point them out for me?

Updated the list

 

[Pyrofyr]

MINUS 1
Death Note
Fullmetal Alchemist
Bleach
Naruto
Dragonball
Love Hina

PLUS 1
One Piece
Detective Conan
Great Teacher Onizuka
Air Gear (3)
Beelzebub (3)
Black Cat (2)
Chobits (1)
Claymore (1)
Dragon Drive (1)
Ichigo 100% (3)
IO (1)
Rave Master (1)
Rurouni Kenshin (4)
Samurai Champloo (1)
School Rumble (1)
Soul Eater (1)

 

[GameSoul]

I've made lots of changes to the rules and the list in the first post. Please glance over it. Also I will be allowing minus posts from now on, but they must have 5+ votes or more. Thanks.

 

[Pyrofyr]

It's nice to allow minuses, but some things just don't need to belong at all. It's fine though I guess I'll have to repost the ones that are under 5 if they ever get above 5.

 

[GameSoul]

It's nice to allow minuses, but some things just don't need to belong at all. It's fine though I guess I'll have to repost the ones that are under 5 if they ever get above 5.

I understand, I'm just trying to find some sort of balanced system. The Other category is just for mentions. The actual Essentials are for anything with 5 votes or more which is why I stated that.

 

[Deleted_171835]

Naruto
One Piece
Hikaru No Go (a bit childish but it introduced me to the Go board game)

 

[Mr.Mysterio]

Death Note
Gantz
Berserk

Really good mangas.

 

[soulfire]

i think every manga has its own kinda cool thing

my manga essentials:

one piece
full metal alchemist
strawberry 100 % ( its cool i mean it

)
fairy tail

 

[GameSoul]

updated

 

[DeMoN]

The only manga I read is Naruto. I prefer watching the anime for everything else.

+1 Naruto

 

[ENDscape]

DeathNote
Liar Game
Kurosagi
Gamble Fish

 

[fairlyevenparents]

+1
naruto
one piece
death note
yuyu hakusho
dragonball

 

[Pyrofyr]

It's nice to allow minuses, but some things just don't need to belong at all. It's fine though I guess I'll have to repost the ones that are under 5 if they ever get above 5.

I understand, I'm just trying to find some sort of balanced system. The Other category is just for mentions. The actual Essentials are for anything with 5 votes or more which is why I stated that.

In that case, perfect system.

--
+1 Hikaru no Go

 

[C175R]

+1
Flame Of Recca (I have the complete serie(33) in Japanese. IS the BEST)
One Pice
Whistle (Soccer Manga.Really Good)
Shaman King
GTO
Saint Seiyta

 

[BORTZ]

Nauto
Full Metal Alchemest
Dogs: bullets and carnage
Dragon Ball

 

[Cablephish]

Ok, instead of putting -1 votes for mangas that are only above 5, why don't you make another bracket next to the the one you already have for negative votes. That way we know whether people voted something up or down.

Honestly the idea of canceling out someone else's opinion is pretty harsh.

 

[Shinryuji]

I completely forgot this series when I put my first few down.
Tenjou Tenge!

 

[Pyrofyr]

Ok, instead of putting -1 votes for mangas that are only above 5, why don't you make another bracket next to the the one you already have for negative votes. That way we know whether people voted something up or down.

Honestly the idea of canceling out someone else's opinion is pretty harsh.

That would make everything too complicated. It would still be in "Must Read" with 50 positive and 49 negatives, or it would be on the top of "Other" with 50 positive and 49 negative because it still has '50'.

It also gives the impression that those people actually have taste.

 

[zeromac]

Kindaichi Case Files
Best Manga ever

 

[mrfatso]

Kindaichi Case Files
Best Manga ever

yup + 10000 to it

(if i could, i will )

unforunately, i could only find the cn version, but that's okay

and thanks zero for reminding me about reading it again

(translated from cn wiki entry: http://zh.wikipedia.org/wiki/%E9%87%91%E7%...%BB%B6%E7%B0%BF

- Kindaichi Files series
- Kindaichi Short File series
- Kindaichi Case series
- New Kindaichi series
- Akechi File series as well