SvR 08 (with the all-touchscreen controls) was decent. It was fun in short bursts, but nothing I would play for more than half an hour at a time. SvR 09 was absolutely horrible - D-Pad with touchscreen AND face buttons.. the combination was very uncomfortable. As a massive wrestling fan and DS owner, I've been waiting for a game like SvR 2010 for the last two years. This year's iteration is much, MUCH better than last year. The controls are all buttons this year, and it's a much better experience. There are unlockables this year too, so it gives you something to aim for, and a bit of a purpose.