Review cover Mayflash F500 Arcade Stick (Hardware)
Official GBAtemp Review

Product Information:

Frustrated by the lack of precision in fighting games with a controller? Stick it to your current input method by getting yourself an arcade stick.

attachFull207354

Take a moment to imagine this scenario: It’s the 1990s, and you’re in an arcade. All the cabinets for your favorite fighting games are neatly against the wall, just waiting to steal all your quarters. You choose one, and ready yourself by putting your hands on that classic arcade joystick and the satisfying, clicky, numerous buttons. 

Even if you didn’t grow up in the era of arcades, you’ve probably heard older gamers pine for the days of playing their favorite 2D fighters not with a controller or keyboard, but with a fight stick. That’s why, even to this day, there’s quite the handful of companies still putting out fight sticks for players that love that tactile input. This includes Mayflash, a brand you’ve probably seen in passing numerous times, through their controller adapters and various console accessories. This time, we’re going toe-to-toe with their affordable arcade stick: The F500. 

You might be thinking, “okay, this looks interesting, but what platform is it for?”. Well, that’s one of the biggest selling points of this arcade stick. This thing can connect to and be used on nearly any console you can think of, from the PlayStation 4, all the way back to the Sega Genesis. If you really wanted to, you could kick back and play some Street Fighter V, and then seamlessly switch over to your Genesis for some Streets of Rage. The way that you connect it is through a USB-female port, where you plug in your wireless controller to the arcade stick in order to connect it to your system. The method feels a little odd, but it certainly works well.

attachFull208023

Review image Review image Review image 

It also boasts support for the Xbox 360, PC, Nintendo Switch, the Neo Geo Mini, and even Android. So, if you’ve got an expansive library of arcade games all across your consoles, the F500’s got you covered. In the case of more modern platforms, the fight stick also acts as a passthrough, letting you plug your headset and mic in, so you can comfortably hear your audio and your voice calls, if you so choose.

There were two things that instantly caught my attention upon opening the box: The absolute heft of the F500, and just how shiny it is. The fight stick has a very solid feel to it, weighing enough that you probably won't want to keep it in your lap, but rather rest it on a table; especially due to the fact it has large rubber feet on the bottom to prevent it from slipping on flat surfaces. Meanwhile, there's a reflective acrylic faceplate, which can be replaced or customized with decals to sport your favorite fighting game designs. If you don't want to go to that much effort, you could even print out a design and place it beneath the plate. I like the sleek black design that it comes in, but I could easily see the fight stick looking nice with a colorful Blazblue theme adorning it. 

Another point in the F500's favor is that you can take the base arcade stick and modify it with parts of your choosing. You get the great build quality of the base, and you can mix and match whatever pieces you'd want, including Sanwa, onto it, making your own ideal custom fight stick. The options to trick  it out with third party offerings makes it a fantastic choice if you're into customizing your fighting game experience.

attachFull208025

Review image Review image Review image

Which is probably why the buttons included on the F500 don't feel the best. They're certainly good, but there's a bit of "mushiness" to them that you might notice. Almost as if they're decent, but just waiting to be replaced by higher quality parts geared toward the more discerning player. There's no tactility or feedback to accentuate your presses, though it also means that the buttons are very smooth to press, with little resistance. Whether or not you'll prefer this kind of button depends on your preferences, very much similar in vein to keyboard switches. 

Just like the well-built frame and the customizability of the arcade stick, Mayflash also went the extra mile in adding a small compartment for the USB cable for the stick. It stores neatly in the side of the device. Not only does it remove the annoyance of dealing with tangled cords, but it also gets the cord to travel from the side, to help hide it better if you've got it hooked up to a computer for a permanent wired setup. 

On the top of the stick are various buttons, including a much-appreciated home button, two different turbo functions, and a useful toggle between XINPUT and Direct Input to ensure compatibility. Also included in the box is an octagonal restrictor gate, if you need guidance on not moving the joystick too far in a given direction. 

Mayflash has done a fantastic job with the F500, making for a great arcade stick that both entry-level players and more dedicated fanatics can both enjoy. Even if it doesn't come with Sanwa buttons, you can easily take these ones out and replace them with whichever kind you want, giving you freedom to create your own perfect fight stick. 

 

Verdict

What We Liked ...
  • Feels heavy and solidly built
  • Wide compatibility with tons of systems
  • Allows you to customize and replace pieces
What We Didn't Like ...
  • The buttons could really do with more tactile feel or response to each press
8.5
out of 10

Overall

The Mayflash F500 is a great mid-tier fight stick for anyone who wants to relive nostalgic arcade heydays, or those that want to improve their fighting game skill. It also gets bonus points for giving you the option to improve the stick with replaceable pieces.
If you want a better feeling arcade stick, the Hori Arcade RAP4 Kai has better buttons right out the gate as opposed to having to mod it to get better buttons...(though you could still order Sanwa parts to help get it better still)

...which I'd do to both of my sticks if I wasn't in debt atm.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Vorde
first thing id do is replace all the buttons (the stick too if it needs it). im not sure why, but the x/y and a/b are reversed for the switch. this makes games tougher to learn. espescially when the game shows you the location of button to press, as in the kirby allstars boss battle. i ended up physically swapping buttons to match (this is in my nes30 8bitdo stick). then switch was smart and remapping the buttons is the way to go now. i wonder if this controller is supported by the remapping feature now? also, wonder if a happ style joystick will fit, i like the happ style better. the plexiglass, wonder too, if we can get some overlay artwork under there?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Silent_Gunner
This is really nice and well made, but did you guys know its not hard to build your own stick, you get to chose your own parts and its not too pricy at all (stick + buttons ~$40-60) unless you pick an expensive case. Most people use FocusAttack, there is ArcadeShock as well. Be careful as amazon/ebay are mostly counterfeit Chinese parts. Like the issues with the stick in this review could be easily fixed with some sanwa buttons and they're like $3 each (though like $5 shipping), the sticks are around 20, and it should be a simple wire swap without soldering (never solder buttons will screw up the internal springs) unless mayflash did something stupid.


Not selling out but here is my focus attack referral ;) mods are free to remove it: https://a.marsello.com/l/5e7dd83fb407890b00ffecfd
 
  • Like
Reactions: Jayinem81
I got a Wireless Xbox 360 Tekken 6 arcade stick and I have Mayflash NS Magic adapter that will work with it just waiting on the official Xbox 360 PC adapter for it to work. That will take care of Switch and PC, and of course it already works on 360. I have another big black arcade stick with no brand name on it that I bought probably 8 years ago that works with PS2 and PS3. Then I have a Tatsunoku vs Capcom arcade stick that attachs to Wiimote for Wii and it also works for Wii U. I need to see if that will work for Gamecube games on my Wii U I assume it does.

As much as I like this stick its over $100 so I think I'll stick with what I've got, pun.
 
Ericthegreat I'm kinda dumb when it comes to hardware I have two buttons on one of my arcade sticks that are stuck down I pulled them up but when I press them they stay down and get stuck again. Would that be an easy fix?
 
Ericthegreat I'm kinda dumb when it comes to hardware I have two buttons on one of my arcade sticks that are stuck down I pulled them up but when I press them they stay down and get stuck again. Would that be an easy fix?
Yep, you should just need to buy 2 buttons, if you want open it and see if there are quick connects holding the wires to the buttons, you could also pm me a pic of what it looks like in there so I can make sure.
 
I got this stick for Christmas, present to myself :)

Fab and precise review however in my opinion two small omision's and something I feel anyone considering this stick should know.

The placement of the USB input port (used to attach your joypads, essential for use) is in the worst possible place for an arcade stick and makes the stick practicly useless if playing on your lap as the usb port is facing you and could break very easily, look at the first image here and under where it says "arcade" on the stick is where the USB port is. Now its fine if using on a desk or if you are using a magic thumbnail device for bluetooth (another £20 for EACH system used with and a nightmare to find a seller !!!), however if plugging your controller into the port you cannot play any games with it on your lap. OK fair play .... playing with an arcade stick on your lap is less than ideal but when you dont have a desk then lap it is! My workaround is to use the ironing board lol.

Another con is trying to keep the stick connected to the attached joypad, that can sometime crap out on you mid game, which is not ideal when getting your ass handed to you in a fighting game. I have tested this with a few controllers (all PS4).

Please dont think I am knocking the review and I agree with the scoring however feel that should have been in with the cons.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chary
I got this stick for Christmas, present to myself :)

Fab and precise review however in my opinion two small omision's and something I feel anyone considering this stick should know.

The placement of the USB input port (used to attach your joypads, essential for use) is in the worst possible place for an arcade stick and makes the stick practicly useless if playing on your lap as the usb port is facing you and could break very easily, look at the first image here and under where it says "arcade" on the stick is where the USB port is. Now its fine if using on a desk or if you are using a magic thumbnail device for bluetooth (another £20 for EACH system used with and a nightmare to find a seller !!!), however if plugging your controller into the port you cannot play any games with it on your lap. OK fair play .... playing with an arcade stick on your lap is less than ideal but when you dont have a desk then lap it is! My workaround is to use the ironing board lol.

Another con is trying to keep the stick connected to the attached joypad, that can sometime crap out on you mid game, which is not ideal when getting your ass handed to you in a fighting game. I have tested this with a few controllers (all PS4).

Please dont think I am knocking the review and I agree with the scoring however feel that should have been in with the cons.
Interesting! I always appreciate comments from others who’ve also experienced using the hardware in question. So long as everyone’s polite, it leads to more discussion and information being spread :)

As far as the USB port thing goes, the headset jack does annoyingly face the player from the front, but the USB female port faces the back in my unit. And the permanently connected cable it has also faces away, from the side. For my use, I had it on my lap with a long micro USB cord plugged in, facing out, connected to an Xbone controller.

The PS4 disconnection issue could entirely be a thing, though I admittedly did only a little bit of testing on that front, with most of my time focused on using it with an Xbox/directly connected on pc.
 
Yep, you should just need to buy 2 buttons, if you want open it and see if there are quick connects holding the wires to the buttons, you could also pm me a pic of what it looks like in there so I can make sure.

I just got my 360 pc adapter and have been messing with my two arcade sticks all day. Both of them have buttons sticking. Kinda sucks they've been just sitting in my closet for years with no use don't know why that would cause the buttons to just stick. Here are the two sticks i have they're not the best or most expensive and I've had them a long time so I probably should not expect much different.

One is Tekken 6
Playtech Pro Arcade Fighting Stick

Not my videos just videos of the same sticks. I don't even know if I want to open them up because 1 I'm not sure I can lol 2 if I do there's a solid chance I can never put them back together knowing me.
 
So, I'm not a fighting game player and just want one for general mame purposes.Does anyone know if the mayflash f101 model is good pick for that? I can only find reviews for an "f100" model not f101, and they're all in relation to fighting games. I can't even find an f100 model anywhere either, so I don't know what the deal is there.
 
Does it have an analogue or digital joystick??
I'm not a hundred percent sure if I can answer this correctly, but I believe I know enough about it to answer. If you are referring to whether it's analogue as in whether the physical stick has 360 degree range of motion like an analogue joystick, then no. It's digital. Only 4 microswitches which combine to create 8 directional movement like a dpad. However, if you're asking whether it's detected by the console as a digital/dpad or the analogue joystick, than the answer is both. There is a switch that allows you to switch between the dpad and left stick, which is so you can play games that only support one or the other. Either way, however, the stick will still only have 8 directions.
 
If you want a better feeling arcade stick, the Hori Arcade RAP4 Kai has better buttons right out the gate as opposed to having to mod it to get better buttons...(though you could still order Sanwa parts to help get it better still)
.

Yeah just like Silent_Gunner said, I can vouch for the RAP4. It's a great stick, and honestly imo doesn't even really need a sanwa swap.

does it work with Switch?
 
FYI an arcade/fightstick won't make you magically better when you buy one.
You should only get one if you don't like pads for fighting games or pads hurting your hands too much imo.
This stick is a good budget option if you slap some Sanwa parts in it.
 
Looks like a good entry level stick, especially considering the amount of platforms it's compatable with right out of the box... if I was in the market for one, I'd consider this for sure - although the Hori sticks would probably edge it out.
...but I prefer a decent d-pad for my fighting games and have what I consider to be an assortment of the best 'pad' controllers for all the systems I own; whether it be the Hori FCPro for the last couple gen Playstations, the Madcatz pads for 360, the Ascii Dreamcast pads, etc.
I do own a few sticks too, but they're mainly relegated for when I have guests to compete with that prefer sticks.
 
Review cover
Product Information:

Reviews

  1. How endless can an endless ocean be?

  2. Based on Akira Toriyama’s manga of the same name, Sand Land is an action RPG that takes you into a fantasy open world to search for a legendary spring. Should you join this adventure?

  3. Looking to upgrade your wrist-worn timepiece without sacrificing the look of analogue watches? The Withings ScanWatch 2 hybrid smartwatch might be for you. Let’s see what it has to offer in this...

  4. Today for review, we’ll be taking a look at the latest gaming keyboard from Meltek, the CYBER01 magnetic switch offering!

  5. Claimed to be the world's most cost-effecient i9 Mini PC, we check out the latest from Geekom.

Site & Scene News

General chit-chat
Help Users
    SylverReZ @ SylverReZ: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Sjy9nc5QwBY