Pikmin 4 Switch 2 Edition upgrade receives poor reception from fans

The $10 upgrade has sparked angry user reviews and a 2.1 Metacritic user score, with players reporting lackluster improvements and worse performance than the original.

24 replies Share
  • Haha
  • Like
  • Wow
Pikmin 4 Switch 2 Edition upgrade receives poor reception from fans

The Switch 2 Edition upgrade for Pikmin 4 arrived last week, and it has not gone down well. The $10 upgrade promises improved visuals, voice commands and a set of new bonus levels - but a good chunk of players say it barely counts as an upgrade at all, with some even reporting that the game performs worse in some instances than it did on the Switch 1.

A slew of poor user reviews means the title is sitting at a 2.1 userscore on Metacritic, compared with 8.9 for the original game. Complaints include; the frame rate still capped at 30 FPS, longer loading screens than the original and new content that appears to be mostly reused maps from the original game that can also only be played at certain times.

One user review sums up the mood:

PrestonandTom on Metacritic said:
This ‘upgrade’ of Pikmin 4 somehow manages to make the game run significantly worse with standard load times going from 6 seconds to 30+ seconds. The framerate went from an consistent 30 FPS to an inconsistent 30 FPS.

Not every review is that harsh. One 7/10 review welcomes the bump in resolution and draw distance, but says those changes exaggerate the older textures. Others say the new bonus mode, while fun, does not justify the price for people who already own the game. Some players have also taken issue with the large Dandori Academy banner now on the title screen.

Over on the Pikmin subreddit, some fans think the scores are overdramatic and say the release is in line with Nintendo's other Switch 2 Edition upgrades.

Have you played the update? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

:arrow: Source
 

Related news

Discussion

And that's why you buy the Switch 1 version because Switch 2 "editions" are a complete joke.
I thought the pokemon and zelda ones are actually good improvements? (as they should be!)

I don't have a switch 2, so I have not tested anything myself.
 
I thought the pokemon and zelda ones are actually good improvements? (as they should be!)
They're okay-ish, all they do is bump up the resolution and give the graphics a slight upgrade-that's it. They just rebundled the Switch 1 release and added DLC on-top to make it seem like it's a good deal, but it's more expensive over picking up an original copy on the second-hand market which has the data on it since most SW2 titles consists of Key-Cards. Personally, I'm not a huge fan of this practice and that's why I call it a "mess". Doesn't offer any major differences; they should've made the DLC available for free on the eShop to apply to your existing games, but they did give you the option to download it for free if you have a Switch 1 copy, so...
 
  • Like
Reactions: cearp
That's surprising from Nintendo.

And that's why you buy the Switch 1 version because Switch 2 "editions" are a complete joke. Be prepared for the prices for that SW1 version alone to go up.
Kirby and the Forgotten Land Switch 2 Edition runs at 60 so in this specific case it was worth buying, but not this one.
 
I've also heard that they didn't implement mouse controls even though data miners found evidence that it was at least partially developed, in a series where you otherwise move a cursor around with an analog stick in order to beat the game.
 
This Nintendo "upgrades" should be free. Almost all other companies did upgrades for next gen for free (yes sadly there were exceptions).
Hyrule Warriors 2 60fps patch will cost $30. That's friggin annoying.

I mean, yes, it includes all DLC, but I just care about the 60 patch so that's a steep price.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Exnor
what did they expect it's just the switch 1 version afterall because the switch 2 is just a fucking switch-U.
Post automatically merged:

How could shiggy let this happen?
because he has very little influence in that company anymore his basically just a consultant now
 
Last edited by Bladexdsl,
Oh no, the Switch 2 edition wasn't as big an upgrade as they thought it did.... How much do you think the loading issues are due to Unreal Engine 4 being Unreal Engine 4 and the way the upgrade packs are used exasterbating the problem?
 
  • Like
Reactions: Adjule and lightwo

The Switch 2 Edition upgrade for Pikmin 4 arrived last week, and it has not gone down well. The $10 upgrade promises improved visuals, voice commands and a set of new bonus levels - but a good chunk of players say it barely counts as an upgrade at all, with some even reporting that the game performs worse in some instances than it did on the Switch 1.

A slew of poor user reviews means the title is sitting at a 2.1 userscore on Metacritic, compared with 8.9 for the original game. Complaints include; the frame rate still capped at 30 FPS, longer loading screens than the original and new content that appears to be mostly reused maps from the original game that can also only be played at certain times.

One user review sums up the mood:



Not every review is that harsh. One 7/10 review welcomes the bump in resolution and draw distance, but says those changes exaggerate the older textures. Others say the new bonus mode, while fun, does not justify the price for people who already own the game. Some players have also taken issue with the large Dandori Academy banner now on the title screen.

Over on the Pikmin subreddit, some fans think the scores are overdramatic and say the release is in line with Nintendo's other Switch 2 Edition upgrades.

Have you played the update? Let us know your thoughts in the comments below.

:arrow: Source

How did they botch THIS up?

I thought Pikmin was Miyamoto’s pride and joy?
 
  • Like
Reactions: cearp
I thought the pokemon and zelda ones are actually good improvements? (as they should be!)

I don't have a switch 2, so I have not tested anything myself.
Lmfao....

They're identically the same game, just one only appears to look better because its running on a 1080p screen.

We still get better emulating the original SW1 versions than what we pay nintendo for.
 
  • Like
Reactions: cearp

Site & Scene News

New Hot Discussed User Submitted