Sigh. It does not work that way. The resolution of the current screen IS NOT DOUBLED (like in your picture). The bigger screen uses bigger pixels like the DSi XL. Therefore the games look as pixelated as they were on the normal 3DS.
True that I had the ratio wrong, but it will still look worse. Bigger pixels are easier to see individually and thus stand out more, even in motion. The more pixels stand out, the worse the graphics on said screen look. Ever see a 90" HDTV within 10 feet? It looks pretty bad compared to a 60" at the same range. In this case, bigger is not better.
When I heard of the DSi XL the first time, I facepalmed so hard. I thought the already low-res screen of the DS would be upscaled 2x and would look even shittier.
How I was wrong! Now I got one myself and I can safely say the games don't look more pixelated on the XL. The screen uses bigger pixels and therefore don't stretch the resolution of a DS game.
Do we have different models of DSi XL...? The pixelation is extremely noticeable, much moreso on the larger screen.
Nobody was expecting it to be stretched or skewed; we knew it's simply taking the same pixels and making them bigger. But that's not a
good thing. It's simply zooming an already low res pic into a larger low res pic. Even if it's in motion, it's still the same low resolution and now even more noticeable that it's a crappy resolution. It'll be exactly like it is on the DSi XL, and that ain't pretty.
If games looked pixelated on the Lite, they look pixelated on the XL. Does a game look good on the Lite? Then it will look as good on the XL! And with a bigger screen!
The major plus of a big screen is that immerses you in the game a lot better. People should try something first, before they start screaming nonsense
People, do not underestimate the (3)DS XL!
I'm pretty spoiled with my iPhone's retina display, so even playing games on the regular 3DS looks pretty awful. The larger screen will just exacerbate the issue.
Don't get me wrong, I would still prefer the larger size screen in this case. All I'm pointing out is that it's not going to look any better, and will more than likely look
worse. That's just something we have to put up with when it comes to Nintendo these days.