Nintendo is requesting $4.5 million in damages from a Reddit moderator

nitnendologo.png

Nintendo is going after more people who were involved in distributing Nintendo Switch warez and popularizing it on Reddit. A moderator, "Archbox", of the r/switchpiracy subreddit, is being sued by Nintendo for copyright infringement through distributing and hosting pirated Switch games. According to the court document, Nintendo attempted to reach out multiple times to the defendant, named James Williams, to get them to stop hosting "pirate shops" that would allow for seamless illegal game downloads from the Nintendo Switch console directly. Williams also requested user donations to help pay for the costs of hosting the illegal warez. Allegedly, after Nintendo reached out a final time with a cease and desist order, Williams stated a legal counsel would be in contact imminently, to which Nintendo claims never happened.

As a result, Nintendo is seeking $4.5 million dollars ($150,000 per infringement) from Williams in damages to their brand, as he was willfully breaking the law with "reckless abandon".

:arrow: Source
 
can nintendo/gamefreak sue the us government as well for copyright? bros are going after a reddit mod but not the white house. so they pick and choose who they take to court.
Totally different thing.

They can do cease and desist order to ICE for that video clip if they want, but what was it on? Tikto, IG or whatever, they're all in cahoot with Thump anyway so that won't go anywhere. Best result is they remove the video, that's it. Just like many musicians that tried to sue him for using their music without permission. Nothing came out of it.


This Reddit mod on the other hand was literally selling (access to) roms. Guy's been warned multiple times to stop what he was doing. And instead of lawyer up and be prepare, he sat on it for however long until it went on default. He could have settled this outside of court for a much cheaper pay out. But he's a dumbass like most redditors, so yeah he ruined his own life.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChronosNotashi
Just the same song and dance. You're desperate to post piracy on the internet? Even though you've been warned numerous times by, I DUNNO, frigging Nintendo??
Then you're stupid,
what you do is very stupid,
and not only you'll lose soooo much money, but you'll become a laughing stock for a lifetime.
At worst you'll end up in jail.

It doesn't matter what is justified or anyone's opinion about Nintendo, because Nintendo DID warn that reddit mod again and again to stop doing that shit. It's entirely THEIR fault for not listening. Once the big company is involved, it's time to face reality because the law is powerful and I don't think there's enough people on the internet who'd risk it and then pay up millions for the big N.

Sure, Nintendo pulls a lot of shit in recent years, but what we have this time is not a good example.
 
Of course. The bully doesn't go after the teacher, they go after the smaller children on the playground. The teacher doesn't give a shit as they aren't paid enough to give a shit.
Correction: the worldly admins tried to kill me and other teachers in certain workplaces because I defended students from physically violent bullies. false teachers are not teachers. Moving on.

moving on.png
 
Last edited by MPRTwice,
  • Like
Reactions: Dimensional
Yet the "heads" that come out have almost consistently gotten stupider and less able to practice basic safety measures against companies suing that even people using Napster/Limewire used to know. They're going to eventually win simply because of the sheer illiteracy and incompetence modern pirates have gotten will eventually lead to some form of major win that will make piracy harder to do in the future in places like the US or EU.
1000% agree
You can already see that with all those Ryujinx/Yuzu forks, some went absolutely nowhere, some do have some work put behind them but who could argue that the organization and work put behind them is even at 10% of the projects they're originating from ?

There's no "hydra" thing, of course some people will see this as an opportunity to take on the legacy of a project that was enjoyed by many and do some good work. But can we really pretend that Nintendo (or any other company) doing this doesn't matter, or worse, that it's actually somehow beneficial when the projects aren't even half as fleshed out ??

I always hate to say it, but what works is gatekeeping. When things get way too easy for the normies, it's bound to get worse for the rest of us. It's cool to be welcoming, to help learn about that stuff, so new people can learn piracy/warez/emulation and all that stuff, but making things too easy = the beginning of the end.
Very smart people are getting legally bullied, anyone who says they're a pirate shouldn't be thinking that's fine lol, it's much better to think about how to prevent that shit from happening





In this case, nothing of value was lost anyway, but it's time for pirates who want to host that kind of projects to learn opsec and how to make Nintendo's work miserable.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ChronosNotashi
can nintendo/gamefreak sue the us government as well for copyright? bros are going after a reddit mod but not the white house. so they pick and choose who they take to court.
looks like someone needs to read up on american law and the little thing called, the fair use act, which allows copyrighted material to be used for parody, education, or commenting purposes

and what was done with the pokemon theme song was both parody and commenting

but yeah, sure, keep white knighting for nintendo over the stupidest reasons possible
 
  • Like
Reactions: LokeYourLord
I mean this archbox guy hosted the biggest tinfoil shops ever.
The discord server of it had hundreds of thousands of users.
There was this other guy Teknik, I wonder if he also gut sued.
 
Still though, 4.5 millions is a ridiculous ask, blasting his ass in court should be enough.


I'm not sure what that entails but I'm pretty sure it qualifies as cruel and unusual punishment.

The reason for the big dollar amount is for the publicity and deterrent effect. In other words, to send a signal out to other pirate bosses to take off the eye patch or this could happen to them too. Nintendo will probably be happy to settle with the guy for a lot less, with an NDA to make sure you never really know how much. They just want the win.
 
Gotta catch 'em all, except the US government. When the government use your intellectual property then it's called fair use :rofl2:
 
Gotta catch 'em all, except the US government. When the government use your intellectual property then it's called fair use :rofl2:
....Because it IS fair use, like dude, Fair Use Law is far more defined for shit like video game footage, movies and television shows than it is for ROM Hacks or Fangames (most of which use assets ripped from the games the IP it's a fangame of btw), the fuck were you expecting unless you wanted the government to force a win for them as i hammed in again again?, for a company like Nintendo or Disney to sue the government for using something from a TV show they made or had a hand in and never have anything come from it?
 
  • Haha
Reactions: ZeroT21
Oh hey, I'm hosting Nintendo games on Reddit, getting money for it, but I call them "DONATIONS", LOL! Oh, Nintendo just sent me a C&D! I'll ignore it, what could possibly go wrong?!

I have a hate boner for Nintendo like the others, but this guy was a complete moron and deserved it, lol.
 
....Because it IS fair use, like dude, Fair Use Law is far more defined for shit like movies and television shows than it is for ROM Hacks or Fangames (most of which use assets ripped from the games the IP it's a fangame of btw), the fuck were you expecting unless you wanted the government to force a win for them as i hammed in again again?, for a company like Nintendo or Disney to sue the government for using something from a TV show they made or had a hand in and never have anything come from it?
Only focusing on the important points and clarifying them, fair use can be summarized as such: "if money is changing hands, legality concerns can arise. Otherwise they don't really care." So that is why many Nintendo game commentators are never targeted by Nintendo. They typically do not make enough money and it is from the commentary, moreso than the games they play.

I've seen major stores have custom 3D prints of star wars vehicles on display; Disney never sued them because it's fair use; they never sold counterfeit star wars products. They were there to advertise what could be done if you purchased one of their many 3D printers.

Technically, I could design my own star wars action figures and do a far better job than any official producer, and Disney can do _nothing_ about it at all...provided I _never_ sell them. Same as if I somehow custom designed and built my own version of the switch 2 and all of their games without having access to anything that belongs to their propeitary information, but only if I never sold any of them (personal use only).

Games workshops _hate_ that, but other than saying you are uninvited if you say you design customs, they can do nothing except say you cannot go on their territory unless you begin to sell them directly. You absolutely may use them to advertise a different product that you do have the right to sell.

If any of you want to have your own video of pokemon music playing as you strike a bag or lift weights, Nintendo doesn't care. you could even use that in a montage video of your gym and what it offers for clients. However, Nintendo _does_ care if you sell that music or offer their own games for free, which is why this person who was sent to court is in hot water.

It's like my company: I don't care if anyone says what I say and tries to imitate me and my approach to robotics; if anything I see that as a form of flattery/"follow the leader"; but if someone said they are part of my company and offered monetary services for robotics using my company propeitary information in my name or my company's name to deliberately make money off me, then I _would_ sue.
 
Last edited by MPRTwice,
That title has to be one of the stupidest things I've ever read. Him being a moderator on a subreddit is irrelevant to the issue. Charging for access to pirated content is wild, regardless of the outlet of choice.

On the other side, the number is made up bullshit.
Nobody normal relates to a Redditor; at least I'd hope so. 😰
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum