Nintendo is requesting $4.5 million in damages from a Reddit moderator

nitnendologo.png

Nintendo is going after more people who were involved in distributing Nintendo Switch warez and popularizing it on Reddit. A moderator, "Archbox", of the r/switchpiracy subreddit, is being sued by Nintendo for copyright infringement through distributing and hosting pirated Switch games. According to the court document, Nintendo attempted to reach out multiple times to the defendant, named James Williams, to get them to stop hosting "pirate shops" that would allow for seamless illegal game downloads from the Nintendo Switch console directly. Williams also requested user donations to help pay for the costs of hosting the illegal warez. Allegedly, after Nintendo reached out a final time with a cease and desist order, Williams stated a legal counsel would be in contact imminently, to which Nintendo claims never happened.

As a result, Nintendo is seeking $4.5 million dollars ($150,000 per infringement) from Williams in damages to their brand, as he was willfully breaking the law with "reckless abandon".

:arrow: Source
 
Guy who accepted donations, vs Nintendo. This is gonna be a controversial one for GBATemp, whose users love Nintendo and are always happy to pay for things.
I mean, Nintendo is 100% in their right to do so. That reddit guy is also 100% guilty of that. Which one do I support? None, really. I just find it funny because it is just an Hydra game.
Nintendo thinks this will dissuade others from hosting such sites again, when in reality, if they cut one head, ten more will pop out. It's almost as if they didn't learn this lesson
 
Is there a way BOTH sides can lose on this one?

I hate Nintendo Legal as much as anyone on this site rightfully should. But, it's Reddit. The regulars on that site CONSTANTLY joke about how they have hostages in their basement and other cursed shit like that. Yet simultaneously are the most grotesquely obese and unflinching of sense of humor on the entire internet. It's to the point I inwardly feel repulsed the rare times I DO have to follow a reddit thread for ANY kind of support or advice on something.

In as many words, they both suck.
 
I just realized this is probably to scare anyone in to leaking Z-A specifically might i suggest mullvad (and use crypto as payment) set everything right (kill switch ect.) and set the server to either sweden or russia) nothing they can do (I mean germany tried to seize stuff but came up empty and the ceo even threatened legal action for international illegal seizure (company's based in sweden)
 
I mean, Nintendo is 100% in their right to do so. That reddit guy is also 100% guilty of that. Which one do I support? None, really. I just find it funny because it is just an Hydra game.
Nintendo thinks this will dissuade others from hosting such sites again, when in reality, if they cut one head, ten more will pop out. It's almost as if they didn't learn this lesson
Yet the "heads" that come out have almost consistently gotten stupider and less able to practice basic safety measures against companies suing that even people using Napster/Limewire used to know. They're going to eventually win simply because of the sheer illiteracy and incompetence modern pirates have gotten will eventually lead to some form of major win that will make piracy harder to do in the future in places like the US or EU.



I just realized this is probably to scare anyone in to leaking Z-A specifically might i suggest mullvad (and use crypto as payment) set everything right (kill switch ect.) and set the server to either sweden or russia) nothing they can do (I mean germany tried to seize stuff but came up empty and the ceo even threatened legal action for international illegal seizure (company's based in sweden)
You're fuming too hard, go home, Frieza.
 
You mean that they didn't want to sue the government that absolutely could have forced the outcome in thier favor through thier ability to just print infinite money to hire a ton of lawyers that already was alighed for the outcome they wanted alone? No... You don't say?



And now the goverment could easily use that as grounds to strip your SSDI if Nintendo did take you to court and win and the only lawyer you'd have being the one they have to give you due to being too broke to pay for one, congrats, you fucking moron.
trust me i said "stuff" it's a shame the 14th even exist because if we must reset the government we reallly can't (fuck you lincon for not thinking of the possibility we would need to revolt legally)
 
It's another case where you can't really be surprised.
100% agreed
It'd be one thing if they actually were just moderating, but to be hosting warez and after having multiple opportunities to remove them..? What did they expect would happen?
it's risky even having megathreads detailing where to get switch game dumps/ & guides for how to hack the switch etc. even without any monetary gain. but to attach bit.ly-type links (to these links) to earn money with clicks is a sure way to get sued for big $$$, and would eventually be the final nail in their coffin (like it happened time and time again)
 
That title has to be one of the stupidest things I've ever read. Him being a moderator on a subreddit is irrelevant to the issue. Charging for access to pirated content is wild, regardless of the outlet of choice.

On the other side, the number is made up bullshit.
 
That title has to be one of the stupidest things I've ever read. Him being a moderator on a subreddit is irrelevant to the issue. Charging for access to pirated content is wild, regardless of the outlet of choice.

On the other side, the number is made up bullshit.
It's funny, calling him just a "Reddit moderator" was presumably subconscious editing to make him seem more personable vs Nintendo, you know, he's just a random guy. Calling him a "paid distributor of pirated content" wouldn't do that.

But then it backfires anyway because everyone hates Reddit moderators.
 
can these assholes not go one fucking month now without suing someone?! :rofl2:

they need to change their motto to: GOTTA SUE THEM ALL!!
Post automatically merged:

can nintendo/gamefreak sue the us government as well for copyright? bros are going after a reddit mod but not the white house. so they pick and choose who they take to court.
oh of course they don't have the guts to sue the government! they only go after the weak indies and fan projects but when it's actually someone with power using their brand they are scared fucking shitless to do anything!!
 
  • Like
Reactions: Snintendog
Sounds like an infinite money glitch to me.
I mean, they went after "one guy" and not against "a website", meaning this guy was insanely stupid, as @BlusterBong said. Otherwise, they would have gone after an entity, such as a subreddit or a website. He probably bragged about something, thinking he was annonymous or whatever. When doing such shit online, you better be careful and take some basic safety measures, which he didn't do, obviously.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Chrono_Nightmare
"Williams also requested user donations to help pay for the costs of hosting the illegal warez"
"Nintendo reached out a final time with a cease and desist order"

Okay, your turn people who are angry with Nintendo: Nintendo was patient with this criminal and he pretty much demanded that they sue him. So they sued him. Still have a problem with how they handled it? If so, you're just a scumbag thief who supports fellow criminals.
Period!


🏴‍☠️P.S., I'm a scumbag thief too, I'm just not also a hypocrite and I admit who I am.🏴‍☠️
 
can nintendo/gamefreak sue the us government as well for copyright? bros are going after a reddit mod but not the white house. so they pick and choose who they take to court.
Of course. The bully doesn't go after the teacher, they go after the smaller children on the playground. The teacher doesn't give a shit as they aren't paid enough to give a shit.
 
Stupid people be stupid, I don't like those integrated shops anyways, they're obviously made for people who don't know shit about console hacking and think piracy is the only end goal of it, they're even too lazy for looking up the internet on how to download and install stuff manually...

Piracy actors should stop being so bold and focus on the long con instead of swagging all around and raising the legal actors awareness for no good reasons (but wait, there's no ponzicoins donations to be made through that...).
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum