I see. Maybe it depends on something else then, probably several contributing factors.
I just thought the reader might have some effect on the outcome since it generates some sort of clock signal of its own and - at least in theory - has the ability to greatly affect the outcome..
After all this is an exploit based on a glitch in booting process, being able to temporarily brick the console to set it in a readable state, and I think that it can't be very exact science without some serious lab grade measuring equipment .. when having to tweak the cable length etc to get the signal levels within tolerances that it glitches in some way, just getting it readable being only thing that matters.
I'll get my other external reader in a few days and will see if anything changes with that. Different model, some generic chinese one.
I wished I could update to 6.1 to play pokemon, but probably not the best idea to update to anything higher than 4.5 until 100% sure it will be able to write back, too.
And there I have a question.
After this hw mod I should be able to update to
any higher-than-current firmware with any generic (not from own dump) update, right? Say like 4.2 (own dump) > 6.1 (retail game cartridge) > 4.2 (own dump) > 4.5 (retail game cartridge) > 6.1 (retail game cartridge or own dump)
Because I would like to have a copy of that infamous 4.5 fw backed up, too, at some point but I'm not going to get it any time soon (don't own any retail games that come with that, browsing ebay at the moment), and IF I want to get dangerous and want to update to 6.1 as soon as the 4.2 dump I have has been proven legit, before that 4.5 game arrives, this should work in theory (although not being very wise).
And hey, big thanks to everyone that has helped me to this point, with direct help or writing to the wiki page and other threads I've been lurking quite heavily, too!