- Joined
- May 2, 2003
- Messages
- 2,552
- Reaction score
- 35
- Trophies
- 2
- Age
- 36
- Website
- Visit site
- XP
- 193
- Country

IBM 40GB 75GXP DeskStar (yes the one that they got sued over, which was stupid and I didn't claim because IBM didn't deserve to be sued.. anyways...)
So I had 4kb bad sectors after I did a scandisk on it. I was like wow well let's see here, google searched the phone number for IBM RMA. The guy quickly without hesitation issued me an RMA number. Odd? Well ok so they did an advanced exchange.
I got my drive in and was like well my old one still works so let's xcopy everything from the one with bad sectors to the new one. I plugged both drives in and didn't realize that the old drive Molex connector cracked and broke off on the side, so I accidentally plugged in the molex backards (folks, this goes +12V, ground, +5V ground, guess what happens if you FEED +12V into a +5V rail? smoke.)
The computer surged power back through my nice SCSI Plextor 40x CDROM drive and literally arced electricity to the case through the firmware chip which made a big scorch mark inside the CDROM case. This also burned the solder off of one of the molex connection pins to the PCB of the old IBM hard drive that I was replacing.
The new HDD worked and actually it still works and is still inside a Pentium II.
I then RMAd the Plextor CDROM not realizing that they have the shittiest RMA service of any manufacturer besides Asus but that is a whole other story. They sent me a drive that literally was dropped HARD on the ground at the factory and rattled like crazy when spinning a CD. But it accesses files fine. Also the bezel was cracked so I contacted them and they sent me a free "complimentary" bezel. I have never bought a Plextor product again since this.
What did I learn from all of this? Notice crappy build quality on your electronics and when things are this bad make sure that the polarity and voltages are always lined up correctly when plugging into broken electronics.
Did IBM deserve to be sued over the 75GXP Deskstars? No because no hard drive manufacturer is liable for information that you put on their drive. All they should have done for me was RMA one drive which they did. They sent me 2 letters in the mail for claims (one for the drive I bought and one for the one I got in exchange). Well this time around I didn't shaft the company. But what I did didn't put a dent in anything at all,t hey eventually sold out to Hitachi. I still don't buy these drives they aren't a good brand name. Lol they still call them Deskstar.
So I had 4kb bad sectors after I did a scandisk on it. I was like wow well let's see here, google searched the phone number for IBM RMA. The guy quickly without hesitation issued me an RMA number. Odd? Well ok so they did an advanced exchange.
I got my drive in and was like well my old one still works so let's xcopy everything from the one with bad sectors to the new one. I plugged both drives in and didn't realize that the old drive Molex connector cracked and broke off on the side, so I accidentally plugged in the molex backards (folks, this goes +12V, ground, +5V ground, guess what happens if you FEED +12V into a +5V rail? smoke.)
The computer surged power back through my nice SCSI Plextor 40x CDROM drive and literally arced electricity to the case through the firmware chip which made a big scorch mark inside the CDROM case. This also burned the solder off of one of the molex connection pins to the PCB of the old IBM hard drive that I was replacing.
The new HDD worked and actually it still works and is still inside a Pentium II.
I then RMAd the Plextor CDROM not realizing that they have the shittiest RMA service of any manufacturer besides Asus but that is a whole other story. They sent me a drive that literally was dropped HARD on the ground at the factory and rattled like crazy when spinning a CD. But it accesses files fine. Also the bezel was cracked so I contacted them and they sent me a free "complimentary" bezel. I have never bought a Plextor product again since this.
What did I learn from all of this? Notice crappy build quality on your electronics and when things are this bad make sure that the polarity and voltages are always lined up correctly when plugging into broken electronics.
Did IBM deserve to be sued over the 75GXP Deskstars? No because no hard drive manufacturer is liable for information that you put on their drive. All they should have done for me was RMA one drive which they did. They sent me 2 letters in the mail for claims (one for the drive I bought and one for the one I got in exchange). Well this time around I didn't shaft the company. But what I did didn't put a dent in anything at all,t hey eventually sold out to Hitachi. I still don't buy these drives they aren't a good brand name. Lol they still call them Deskstar.














