Hardware USB 2.0 or USB 3.0 HDD ?

[Vladimir]

So, i am trying to decide between 2 Adata HDD's, they cost the same, both are shock resistive and water proof like these ones, they're also identical http://cdn.pcel.com/...eaa0966a20f.jpg .

The thing is, one is USB 2.0 and the other is 3.0.

I'm planning on using it for my Wii backups with USB Loader GX, and with my RGH modded Xbox 360 for loading backups too, and obviously, for saving some personal and private information :Ifyouknowwhatimean:, but the main purpose, is playing my Wii and Xbox 360 backups.

I've been told that USB 3.0 doesn't work with the Wii, and that i have to use an USB 3.0 to 2.0 adapter, however i still don't know if it would work right, the same thing with the Xbox 360, but i can't ignore the fact the USB 3.0 is going to be the standard for the next years.

So my question is, should i go for the 2.0? or taking the risk with a 3.0 using an adapter? Thanks.

 

[DiscostewSM]

I'd say go with the USB 3.0 if both are the same price. As far as an adapter goes, the one out of the box should still work, as it should be backwards compatible, containing both the USB 2.0 lines and the USB 3.0 lines as depicted in this image.

 

[Vladimir]

I'd say go with the USB 3.0 if both are the same price. As far as an adapter goes, the one out of the box should still work, as it should be backwards compatible, containing both the USB 2.0 lines and the USB 3.0 lines as depicted in this image.

Whoa man, thanks a lot!, didn't knew it came with an adapter!.

 

[JN_big3]

Get 3.0 if the price is the same

 

[Vladimir]

Get 3.0 if the price is the same

Thanks. Do you know if it works well with the Wii?

 

[BitBandit]

I thought you could use USB 3 devices (i.e. HDD drives) on USB 2 ports (i.e. computers, gaming consoles, etc) but you just didn't get the benefits that USB 3 offers (mainly faster speeds). I.e. they are backwards compatible.

 

[JN_big3]

Get 3.0 if the price is the same

Thanks. Do you know if it works well with the Wii?

Actually it doesn't do anything to the Wii if it's 3.0 or 2.0. But in PC, 3.0 has a faster Transfer rate than the USB 2.0.

 

[Vladimir]

Get 3.0 if the price is the same

Thanks. Do you know if it works well with the Wii?

Actually it doesn't do anything to the Wii if it's 3.0 or 2.0. But in PC, 3.0 has a faster Transfer rate than the USB 2.0.

Thanks for the help everyone. I'll buy it tomorrow (The 3.0 one). I'll tell you what happened

 

[JN_big3]

Get 3.0 if the price is the same

Thanks. Do you know if it works well with the Wii?

Actually it doesn't do anything to the Wii if it's 3.0 or 2.0. But in PC, 3.0 has a faster Transfer rate than the USB 2.0.

Thanks for the help everyone. I'll buy it tomorrow (The 3.0 one). I'll tell you what happened

I forgot to ask, Have you checked if that External HDD is compatible with the Wii? Check Here: http://wiki.gbatemp.net/wiki/USB_Devices_Compatibility_List

Some aren't compatible with the Wii

 

[Vladimir]

I forgot to ask, Have you checked if that External HDD is compatible with the Wii? Check Here: http://wiki.gbatemp....patibility_List

Some aren't compatible with the Wii

It was the first place i checked, but it's not on the list

 

[JN_big3]

You're better of buying the ones that are listed. WD is a good brand

 

[Vladimir]

You're better of buying the ones that are listed. WD is a good brand

The problem is, Western Digital HDD are VERY rare here in Mexico, and very expensive. On the other case, the Adata hardrives are very easy to find and very cheap over here (even cheaper than on USA).

 

[JN_big3]

How about Seagate or Samsung? It is better to be sure than to be unsure

 

[Bladexdsl]

the wii doesnt support usb 3 it wont get to them speeds so just get a 2.0 hdd

 

[Vladimir]

How about Seagate or Samsung? It is better to be sure than to be unsure

Guys, i've found a tutorial that assures that you only have to use a USB 2.0 cable, and its gonna work perfectly. Take a look, the photos are self explanatory. http://www.mediafire...utij4t2pw794yuf

 

[Hunter X]

Get 3.0 if the price is the same

Thanks. Do you know if it works well with the Wii?

Actually it doesn't do anything to the Wii if it's 3.0 or 2.0. But in PC, 3.0 has a faster Transfer rate than the USB 2.0.

That is false. The Wii will only get 2.0 speeds and so will a computer. A computer will get 3.0 speeds only if it has USB 3.0 ports and if the motherboard supports it. Not all computers have USB 3.0 yet. Personally, I'm waiting to build a new computer and get Thunderbolt on it.

 

[Vladimir]

Get 3.0 if the price is the same

Thanks. Do you know if it works well with the Wii?

Actually it doesn't do anything to the Wii if it's 3.0 or 2.0. But in PC, 3.0 has a faster Transfer rate than the USB 2.0.

That is false. The Wii will only get 2.0 speeds and so will a computer. A computer will get 3.0 speeds only if it has USB 3.0 ports and if the motherboard supports it. Not all computers have USB 3.0 yet. Personally, I'm waiting to build a new computer and get Thunderbolt on it.

I think he meant that xD, he just wasn't specific enough.
By the way, i will posts results in a few hours about the USB 3.0 HDD.

 

[Vladimir]

Hi again everyone!, i decided to get a 2.0 (Adata Superior SH93 750GB) after all. I realized i would not have an USB 3.0 compatible PC in a long time...so i decided not to take the risk xD. Thanks everyone.

 

[Bladexdsl]

How about Seagate or Samsung? It is better to be sure than to be unsure

Guys, i've found a tutorial that assures that you only have to use a USB 2.0 cable, and its gonna work perfectly. Take a look, the photos are self explanatory. http://www.mediafire...utij4t2pw794yuf

that's pure bs a magic cable wont make the wii go to 3.0 speeds since it doesnt support them in the 1st place! their the same as them so called adapters that CLAIM (it's also bs) to make the wii 1080p

 

[ZAFDeltaForce]

Get USB 3.0. It's backwards compatible, so it should work with your Wii.

Also, pretty much all future storage drives will be USB 3.0, so better future proof your purchase, especially if both HDDs costs the same