Gaming So is the release list wrong?

[Drusenija]

Apologies if this has already been answered, but I can't seem to see it anywhere. From what I've seen, the original ROM 1328 " Ganbaru Watashi no Kakei Diary (v1.1)" was nuked due to a hacked icon. On the DS-Scene release list, this game was removed, and every subsequent game moved down to fill the gap (ie, Luminous Arc is now 1328, Rune Factory 1329, etc).

According to 4ppleseed in this thread (http://gbatemp.net/index.php?showtopic=58119), this revised numbering scheme is also being used, yet on the release list here at GBA-Temp, it still has the original numbering.

Which is correct?

 

[pkprostudio]

According to ADVANsCEne, iNDEPENDENT released a Proper version of #1328, so that will replace the nuked release by Loli.

 

[Drusenija]

So does this mean the release list as DS-Scene is now wrong then, since they've removed the original 1328 entirely?

 

[pkprostudio]

Probably. One of the roms site has the proper version as #1339, so from #1340 on will be the same. It's just #1328-1339 that has some problems.

 

[Drusenija]

Urgh >.< So which list is considered the authoritative list when it comes to DS games then?

 

[NDSFreak]

Don't know why DS-Scene nuked it insteed of replacing it when a proper was available, it was only an icon hack but fully functional (i guess thats why lolis release isn't nuked here), and with other releases like 1210 - Platinum Sudoku and the really screwed up release 1209 - Vegas Casino High 5! (didn't even work for all) they kept the relno and replaced it when Sir VG propered them. DS-Scene don't act consequent
We replaced it at ADVANsCEne because we list the most proper of the scene releases