Toggle sidebar

Gaming Daigasso! Band Brothers P

  • Thread starter Thread starter twede86
  • Start date Start date
  • Views Views 111,070
  • Replies Replies 384
  • Likes Likes 2
Anybody got any feedback on how the converter (version 15) has worked for you??? Do you have any songs you want to test? do let me know so we can crack this together.
 
Neobeo said:
Here's my take on a bbp2midi converter while I upgrade degausser to v3.0:
https://adib.fourplusfive.com/bbp2midi/v1.0/

It's compatible with the BBP soundfont2 a few posts earlier. And can also load bdx files.
Click to expand...
Oh, Cool!!

Thank you!!!

Let me ask you a question, did you have a chance to check the converter I uploaded? by chance, do you find it at least decent? does it work differently than the one you uploaded?

I ask all of this because, as you may have read, I am not a programmer and used AI to help me iterate the versions. At this point, I honestly do not know whether I should continue iterating or just wait for people like you (that most likely actually know what they are doing) to improve on it.

BTW, if you are the person that created degausser, THANK YOU SO MUCH!!! I was able to load some new (bbp) songs into my copy of Daigasso.

Thank you (and everyone) for the amazing work.
 
Thinkrs said:
Oh, Cool!!

Thank you!!!

Let me ask you a question, did you have a chance to check the converter I uploaded? by chance, do you find it at least decent? does it work differently than the one you uploaded?

I ask all of this because, as you may have read, I am not a programmer and used AI to help me iterate the versions. At this point, I honestly do not know whether I should continue iterating or just wait for people like you (that most likely actually know what they are doing) to improve on it.

BTW, if you are the person that created degausser, THANK YOU SO MUCH!!! I was able to load some new (bbp) songs into my copy of Daigasso.

Thank you (and everyone) for the amazing work.
Click to expand...
Hi, yes I'm the creator of Degausser (from the old DX Degausser to the more modern Degausser for bbp, and also degausser3ds), though I've been away from the scene for a while, so it's exciting to see things are still happening.

I did have a look at the converter, it's certainly a step up from the original bbp2midi.py which crashes on a lot of stuff. But fundamentally I don't think either the piano chords or the guitar chords are right. And there's no way for the AI to independently rediscover this either since it's really just reverse engineering my Degausser work which already didn't play these correctly.

Roughly speaking, there are two flavours of piano chords (1. generate from root+accidental+stuff, 2. four literal notes), and yours gets it wrong on both counts. So the piano chords is basically random noise.

And there are three flavours of guitar chords (1. generate from root+stuff, 2. six literal notes, 3. bdx migrated), Your AI-improvement gets the third one right, and about half of the "six literal notes" version. So you can actually get decent guitar behaviour. Though it still treats consecutive strums as a legato, and also ignores strumming a subset of strings etc.

The other thing which doesn't behave the same as volume control, and I'm not convinced I have the right formula either. Because there's the master volume, per-instrument volume, per-track volume changes, per-note intensity changes etc., and they combine in mysterious ways. I've made my best guesses which sounds reasonable, but not 100%.

But keep it up anyway! It's exciting to see what AI (even at the free tier) is able to achieve. Maybe even feed my website back into it and see whether it thinks my version is better, could be a fun experiment.
 
  • Like
Reactions: Thinkrs
Neobeo said:
Hi, yes I'm the creator of Degausser (from the old DX Degausser to the more modern Degausser for bbp, and also degausser3ds), though I've been away from the scene for a while, so it's exciting to see things are still happening.

I did have a look at the converter, it's certainly a step up from the original bbp2midi.py which crashes on a lot of stuff. But fundamentally I don't think either the piano chords or the guitar chords are right. And there's no way for the AI to independently rediscover this either since it's really just reverse engineering my Degausser work which already didn't play these correctly.

Roughly speaking, there are two flavours of piano chords (1. generate from root+accidental+stuff, 2. four literal notes), and yours gets it wrong on both counts. So the piano chords is basically random noise.

And there are three flavours of guitar chords (1. generate from root+stuff, 2. six literal notes, 3. bdx migrated), Your AI-improvement gets the third one right, and about half of the "six literal notes" version. So you can actually get decent guitar behaviour. Though it still treats consecutive strums as a legato, and also ignores strumming a subset of strings etc.

The other thing which doesn't behave the same as volume control, and I'm not convinced I have the right formula either. Because there's the master volume, per-instrument volume, per-track volume changes, per-note intensity changes etc., and they combine in mysterious ways. I've made my best guesses which sounds reasonable, but not 100%.

But keep it up anyway! It's exciting to see what AI (even at the free tier) is able to achieve. Maybe even feed my website back into it and see whether it thinks my version is better, could be a fun experiment.
Click to expand...
It is an honor!

Then, please find attached a report. I asked the AI to create a document to report on the findings "we have had" since I started iterating with it. I asked for the report to be technical enough as I thought that might come in handy for you, since you do know what you are doing and I do not.

Let me know if this helps in any way.
 

Attachments

Site & Scene News

Go to forum More news

Popular threads in this forum

Misc Rumor  Zelda Breath of the Wild 3DS build

Shin Megami Tensei IV and IV:A Ghosting fix

Hacking Homebrew  3DS-anmboot: Add an official-like boot animation to the 3DS

[Release] Doom RPG (Reverse Engineered) for 3DS — Stereoscopic 3D, Touch HUD & CIA Build

Hacking  [RELEASE] Pokémon Sango Kaizo - A new ROM hack for Pokémon ORAS

Homebrew Ports for 3DS

UNDERTALE on 3ds a full native port im making runs at 60fps :D

Homebrew Homebrew game Project  [Release] REGTA — GTA III, Vice City & Liberty City Stories for New Nintendo 3DS