Hot Take: The Switch 2 Could've Been Better With Discs

  • Thread starter Thread starter PalkaaklaP
  • Start date Start date
  • Views Views 4,888
  • Replies Replies 56
  • Likes Likes 6
He's just a troll who is jealous of the fastest selling console of all-time and ignorant of how many games are exclusive to the platform and how S1 games all run better with the system update and how Sony only has about 4 exclusives left now that they've published everything in superior versions for Windows -- unlike Nintendo which has actual exclusives.

But really: Why are we still discussing the discs thing? There's a ZERO percent chance that Nintendo was ever going to do it because it is a terrible idea for all the reasons stated. What more needs to be said here?
Oh yeah, suuuuuper jealous. Yeah, going through my physical library of SNES and N64 games where there are 30+ bangers on each system, I'm definitely jealous Nintendo is looking at every possible way to milk their old IP dry and produce 5 remotely playable games for the last two generations. It's telling that I've spent more time on the NS1 modifying it than I have actually playing the games.

I especially love that the NS1 upgrades on the NS2 are often paywalled! Yeah you own your hardware, but you should pay Nintendo to use it!
 
Oh yeah, suuuuuper jealous. Yeah, going through my physical library of SNES and N64 games where there are 30+ bangers on each system, I'm definitely jealous Nintendo is looking at every possible way to milk their old IP dry and produce 5 remotely playable games for the last two generations. It's telling that I've spent more time on the NS1 modifying it than I have actually playing the games.

I especially love that the NS1 upgrades on the NS2 are often paywalled! Yeah you own your hardware, but you should pay Nintendo to use it!
The alternative is getting a remaster that you have to re-purchase as if you never owned it in the first place like what you get on other consoles and PC. So I don't think this is that bad. They are effectively remasters.
 
The alternative is getting a remaster that you have to re-purchase as if you never owned it in the first place like what you get on other consoles and PC. So I don't think this is that bad. They are effectively remasters.
Nah, lazy remasters aside, all the "upgrades" are doing is allowing the NS2 to run at higher clock speeds. It's even lazier than the lazy remasters.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: AkikoKumagara
Nah, lazy remasters aside, all the "upgrades" are doing is allowing the NS2 to run at higher clock speeds. It's even lazier than the lazy remasters.
That's factually not true.
They already run at higher clock speeds without the upgrade.
At the very least, the upgrade packs allow them to run at higher resolution/refresh rate with higher resolution textures/higher LOD. Some games have additional changes on top of that (and their upgrade packs are typically priced higher)
All that doesn't come automatically just from increasing the clock speeds. They had to tweak the graphics settings to optimize for the new hardware and put the effort into play testing to make sure that it all works well.
Lazy, perhaps, but no more than any other remaster. That is about what you get from most remasters.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AkikoKumagara
That's factually not true.
They already run at higher clock speeds without the upgrade.
At the very least, the upgrade packs allow them to run at higher resolution/refresh rate with higher resolution textures/higher LOD. Some games have additional changes on top of that (and their upgrade packs are typically priced higher)
All that doesn't come automatically just from increasing the clock speeds. They had to tweak the graphics settings to optimize for the new hardware and put the effort into play testing to make sure that it all works well.
Lazy, perhaps, but no more than any other remaster. That is about what you get from most remasters.
Bro they did no "tweaking". Retroarch upscales a 240P image to 4K automatically. You can also do that with every game system supported by Retroarch. There's no effort put in by Nintendo aside from maybe outsourcing playtesting to 10 people in some impoverished village somewhere.
 
  • Haha
Reactions: AkikoKumagara
Bro they did no "tweaking". Retroarch upscales a 240P image to 4K automatically. You can also do that with every game system supported by Retroarch. There's no effort put in by Nintendo aside from maybe outsourcing playtesting to 10 people in some impoverished village somewhere.
What are you talking about? This isn't upscaling, it's native. If you don't understand the difference, then you clearly have no idea what you're talking about.
 
  • Like
Reactions: AkikoKumagara
While it is true that the "remasters" are not just "allowing it to use higher clock speeds", it is also true most of them are very lazy and is what usually would come for free in other systems... that said, wasn't this thread about the game key card fiasco?

I still stand by what I said before, I am more annoyed by the lack of honesty / false advertisement than for the "all digital" stuff, if you sell a console for which most software is digital only (or depend on servers still being available to install / same shit), make it clear, don't deceive/scam your clients. The same can be said about "game key discs" that require a zero-day updates or always-online checks on other systems, cards are not the problem, the trends/greed in the industry are.
 
  • Like
Reactions: TPMJB
While it is true that the "remasters" are not just "allowing it to use higher clock speeds", it is also true most of them are very lazy and is what usually would come for free in other systems... that said, wasn't this thread about the game key card fiasco?

I still stand by what I said before, I am more annoyed by the lack of honesty / false advertisement than for the "all digital" stuff, if you sell a console for which most software is digital only (or depend on servers still being available to install / same shit), make it clear, don't deceive/scam your clients. The same can be said about "game key discs" that require a zero-day updates or always-online checks on other systems, cards are not the problem, the trends/greed in the industry are.
Well, zoom out enough and it's all a big scam, which is the gripe. Game key cards are the way in which we own nothing at all, and physical data dies. At least on my PC I can backup all my Steam games to my NAS. If Nintendo decides to kill support, I have nothing.
 
It's not that black and white with game key cards or the other guys non-game key card like discs too. There are a couple valid reasons for stuff to go that way, not that I like it, but it's a design choice we're forced to accept, or at least accept at a steep discount sometime later not to encourage it.
 
It's not that black and white with game key cards or the other guys non-game key card like discs too. There are a couple valid reasons for stuff to go that way, not that I like it, but it's a design choice we're forced to accept, or at least accept at a steep discount sometime later not to encourage it.
Nah, not buying it.
 
Nah, fuck these things. I hope to never deal with them ever again.

1780433009914.png
 
Nah, not buying it.
I mean, you'd be wrong, but I get it, if you're that dead set against it, nothing will change your mind. I used to work in the industy, brother still does at a high level so I was saying what you were much about key vs regular cards and we had a good hour discussion on the phone. The only hot points that got me partially on board with it was the design of the game, or in the case of the NS2 the lack of space on the available cards at the time, that was it.

Some games the engines ask for enough consistent data that the memory bottleneck coming off the switch 2 cards or blu ray discs are below a level where the game won't function right without a lot of restructuring, breaking up more areas with more loading moments, and so on. The NS2 has a slower card, notably than an optional express card, and that is still a bit slower than internal (and same can be said with the read disc time vs ssd on the other guys.) Those games, and with ones that don't fit on NS2 (like the 90GB FF7 Rebirth) you key card or have zero second hand resale rights with a rental/buy eshop button price.

But I look at the reality of it first before buying. If I see the game does NOT need it, and the developer is just being a nasty control freak playing DRM nonsense, or they're being just cheapskates and not paying for storage I either just outright won't buy it, or I'll wait for a hard up sale where the price sinks hard enough I don't care anymore. Like I'd love to get Pragmata but $60 for a key card...NOPE. If I see it second hand and it takes 6 months or 6 years and it's like $30 sure. I'm not going to encourage it, but not deny myself either.
 
I mean, you'd be wrong, but I get it, if you're that dead set against it, nothing will change your mind. I used to work in the industy, brother still does at a high level so I was saying what you were much about key vs regular cards and we had a good hour discussion on the phone. The only hot points that got me partially on board with it was the design of the game, or in the case of the NS2 the lack of space on the available cards at the time, that was it.

Some games the engines ask for enough consistent data that the memory bottleneck coming off the switch 2 cards or blu ray discs are below a level where the game won't function right without a lot of restructuring, breaking up more areas with more loading moments, and so on. The NS2 has a slower card, notably than an optional express card, and that is still a bit slower than internal (and same can be said with the read disc time vs ssd on the other guys.) Those games, and with ones that don't fit on NS2 (like the 90GB FF7 Rebirth) you key card or have zero second hand resale rights with a rental/buy eshop button price.

But I look at the reality of it first before buying. If I see the game does NOT need it, and the developer is just being a nasty control freak playing DRM nonsense, or they're being just cheapskates and not paying for storage I either just outright won't buy it, or I'll wait for a hard up sale where the price sinks hard enough I don't care anymore. Like I'd love to get Pragmata but $60 for a key card...NOPE. If I see it second hand and it takes 6 months or 6 years and it's like $30 sure. I'm not going to encourage it, but not deny myself either.
I'd add one more situation where a GKC might seem reasonable, and that involves a game that drastically replaces itself over time from patches. Star Wars Outlaws is one in particular, where the majority of the game's data has been swapped out through updates for optimization purposes. Granted, that could be more of a fault of the developer for not having it up and running well in the beginning, but still.
 
I'd add one more situation where a GKC might seem reasonable, and that involves a game that drastically replaces itself over time from patches. Star Wars Outlaws is one in particular, where the majority of the game's data has been swapped out through updates for optimization purposes. Granted, that could be more of a fault of the developer for not having it up and running well in the beginning, but still.
You're right, very right. If a game wasn't going to be re-run at a huge cost because of massive overhauls and additions the key card makes sense. Given sadly it's all online now, you have your key, keyed in on the system, and as you slept the game repaired itself with lots of upgrades and fixes.

The sad way No Man's Sky came out compared to what a decade later would be a hell of a case too.
 
I mean, you'd be wrong, but I get it, if you're that dead set against it, nothing will change your mind. I used to work in the industy, brother still does at a high level so I was saying what you were much about key vs regular cards and we had a good hour discussion on the phone. The only hot points that got me partially on board with it was the design of the game, or in the case of the NS2 the lack of space on the available cards at the time, that was it.

Some games the engines ask for enough consistent data that the memory bottleneck coming off the switch 2 cards or blu ray discs are below a level where the game won't function right without a lot of restructuring, breaking up more areas with more loading moments, and so on. The NS2 has a slower card, notably than an optional express card, and that is still a bit slower than internal (and same can be said with the read disc time vs ssd on the other guys.) Those games, and with ones that don't fit on NS2 (like the 90GB FF7 Rebirth) you key card or have zero second hand resale rights with a rental/buy eshop button price.

But I look at the reality of it first before buying. If I see the game does NOT need it, and the developer is just being a nasty control freak playing DRM nonsense, or they're being just cheapskates and not paying for storage I either just outright won't buy it, or I'll wait for a hard up sale where the price sinks hard enough I don't care anymore. Like I'd love to get Pragmata but $60 for a key card...NOPE. If I see it second hand and it takes 6 months or 6 years and it's like $30 sure. I'm not going to encourage it, but not deny myself either.
You are wasting your time typing. Both of us and many others have spelled out the pros and cons of the gkc to others, but it's not changing anything for these people. If they say they ain't buying it, they ain't buying. All that we can do is block our ears when they complain and bitch about it.
 
  • Like
Reactions: VmprHntrD
You are wasting your time typing. Both of us and many others have spelled out the pros and cons of the gkc to others, but it's not changing anything for these people. If they say they ain't buying it, they ain't buying. All that we can do is block our ears when they complain and bitch about it.
You're right, when someone is that close minded and entitled there's little words will do because most of them are beyond help or reasoning rationally. I was more on their side 6 months ago, but after I had it spelled out in detail to me with reasons, the rationalization of it, the loss if it didn't exist, I changed my mind enough. Just enough to accept them in cases when it was a limit of the hardware or game card sizes, but if it's just about control, I'll hit up play-asia if another region did it right as I did a few times already.
 

Site & Scene News

Popular threads in this forum