Gaming F1 2011 - VITA vs 3DS Comparison

[T-hug]

3DS

VITA

Source: http://andriasang.co..._2011_vita_3ds/

 

[DiscostewSM]

3DS

VITA

Source: http://andriasang.co..._2011_vita_3ds/

The 3DS version is just brighter because it doesn't incorporate the glow/bloom effects shown in the Vita version (and no corner dimming). Other than that, and the higher resolution of the Vita version, I don't see a whole lot of difference between the two.

 

[Satangel]

True, it doesn't look that much of a difference. But that's mainly because rushed development and the fact that the handheld is entirely new. The longer the handhelds are out, the more developers will really put the power to use.

 

[Maedhros]

I prefer no jaggies after all. Even not being that good, Vita version is leagues ahead of 3DS one. Not 3DS fault though, as 3DS can do much better than this shit they will try to sell for full price.

 

[chris888222]

I prefer no jaggies after all. Even not being that good, Vita version is leagues ahead of 3DS one. Not 3DS fault though, as 3DS can do much better than this shit they will try to sell for full price.

This game is simply rushed. Both versions.

Agreed with the last part.

 

[granville]

I agree, neither game is really taking advantage of its respective hardware. We know the Vita is the more powerful system regardless though.

 

[The Composer]

It looks ok on Vita and terrible on the 3DS.

 

[chris888222]

It looks ok on Vita and terrible on the 3DS.

Both look horrible. The Vita version adds 'bloom' effects, that's all.

Did anyone expect this game to be good anyway.

 

[Depravo]

Graphics don't make the game. As the source says "let's be inappropriate and compare the two".

Visuals aside, I don't think a precision, high speed racer like this is suited to handheld formats at all so it will probably suck on both Vita and 3DS.

 

[Deleted User]

I love jiggles

 

[Satangel]

F1 2011 PSV preview

Looking better now, puts the 3DS version to shame

 

[ryan90]

this game is so ugly, i have seen screens in full Vita resolution 960x544 on neogaf and you can see the game does not render at the screens full and native resolution, no idea why. All the textures where very blurry and the glow effect looks over done. If you ever see the crowd animation up close you would be shocked at how pixelated they are. Its a direct port of 3ds version with very little upgrades.

I wonder what the devs paid that reviewer.

 

[Deleted User]

Am I the only one that thinks that:
a) Andriasang is slightly biased
b) Why the heck does the comparison exist
c) Why do people care

 

[prowler]

a) Andriasang is slightly biased

How are they biased?
http://andriasang.com/comz54/f1_2011_vita_3ds/

They didn't say anything about which version is better. They even said

so let's be inappropriate and compare the two.

 

[Deleted User]

a) Andriasang is slightly biased

How are they biased?
http://andriasang.co..._2011_vita_3ds/

They didn't say anything about which version is better. They even said

so let's be inappropriate and compare the two.

Yes, it is to reference that quote which made them seem biased. (so let's be inappropriate and compare the two) Why did they feel the need to be inappropriate?

 

[emigre]

For shits and giggles.

 

[T-hug]

New gameplay video, skip to 6.00.



I'm on the fence with this, doesn't look to great on either machine, though the Vita version is way ahead of the 3DS one in every way. Pretty much looks identical to the 360 version.

 

[Maedhros]

I prefer no jaggies after all. Even not being that good, Vita version is leagues ahead of 3DS one. Not 3DS fault though, as 3DS can do much better than this shit they will try to sell for full price.

After looking at other screens they released, I was mistaken... it's the same fucking game with a paint of bloom and better lightning/models/pollygons on the Vita version, but essentially the same shit. Shame Codemaster/Sumo...

 

[chris888222]

I prefer no jaggies after all. Even not being that good, Vita version is leagues ahead of 3DS one. Not 3DS fault though, as 3DS can do much better than this shit they will try to sell for full price.

After looking at other screens they released, I was mistaken... it's the same fucking game with a paint of bloom and better lightning/models/pollygons on the Vita version, but essentially the same shit. Shame Codemaster/Sumo...

If you're in racers:

PS VITA: ModNation Racers, WipEout?
3DS: Mario Kart 7, Ridge Racer 3D?

There are better choices. Personally, I find that RR3D (said to look quite bad - IMO roughly on par with PSP version) looks even better than this.