I Hate You Rockbox

Awhile back, before the Rockbox build was even stable, I decided to put Rockbox firmware on my Sansa Fuze V2. I knew there was a risk of bricking at the time, as only v1 was actually stable, but I still went for it. The customization and games were nice at first, but a few months ago, it started having more and more problems. I looked for a stable build, and sure enough, there was a stable build. This was about two months ago. Installed it with the Rockbox installer, moved on.

I found that it didn't actually solve any of the issues I was having though. There were an incredible amount of interface issues that made me realize that stable just means that it won't brick your device.

Tonight, I went ahead and decided to uninstall it. Apparently, this isn't a simple endeavor. I choose the install that removes everything except the bootloader, and then only a normal firmware update would be needed to remedy that. I take all the necessary steps, do a normal firmware update, and it still tried to boot into the Rockbox firmware. Only difference was, it said there was no firmware there, and shut off about 6 seconds later. I boot back into the normal firmware through USB connection (thankfully USB support hadn't been added yet for Rockbox of this variety). I try removing any music I didn't already have back ups of (music from friends) and find some of it is corrupted for one reason or another and the extra Rockbox files won't delete.

I get music off of it, then format through the original firmware. It STILL tried to boot into Rockbox. I went ahead and looked to see if maybe I needed to update the firmware again, and there was a 21MB update file. I updated it once, and got a warning that there wasn't enough room (over 7GB isn't enough room for 21MB....wut?). I update again, and am successful. Now, it finally boots into the normal firmware again, where I now need to carefully watch the battery while I still have warranty. All traces of Rockbox are gone, so I shouldn't have any issues getting a repair if I need it, though they may see the water indicator is a color indicating that the device got wet and consider otherwise (even though that was about five months ago).

tl;dr - If you get Rockbox, make sure it works really well on your device, and make sure you really want it.

Comments

Wait... you do know with the rockbox bootloader you hold LEFT while starting up to boot the original firmware, right?

I've got a V2 and have been using it since the unstable, no issues here (other than one buggy skin I tried).
 
[quote name='Rydian' post='3617261' date='Apr 28 2011, 09:09 PM']Wait... you do know with the rockbox bootloader you hold LEFT while starting up to boot the original firmware, right?

I've got a V2 and have been using it since the unstable, no issues here (other than one buggy skin I tried).[/quote]

Never saw that anywhere, and my Rockbox installation was plagued with issues for one reason or another. I completely gave up on it. Regardless, I'm back into the normal firmware completely, which is where I wanted to be. If my Fuze is starting to have any issues that require use of the warranty, I can't have a single trace of Rockbox left on there.
 
[quote name='TwinRetro' post='3617266' date='Apr 29 2011, 12:14 AM']Rock Box is the BEST for everything! :)[/quote]
Fixed that for you ^_^
 
Sadly, I only just sold both of my Rockboxed Sansas last night. They went toward a good cause...


Buying me a 3DS :evil:
 
Rockbox is just no good for somebody who only uses their music player to listen to music. I never use it for anything else, so Rockbox felt unnecessary with all of the problems I was personally having with it.
 
I only listen to music, and I can't use anything but Rockbox.
I need it, the way it works and the way it store the files are the best, compared to Ipod DRM'ed iTunes with filename randomness and PC synchronization. (really, who find that useful?)
 
[quote name='Cyan' post='3618181' date='Apr 29 2011, 12:01 PM']I only listen to music, and I can't use anything but Rockbox.
I need it, the way it works and the way it store the files are the best, compared to Ipod DRM'ed iTunes with filename randomness and PC synchronization. (really, who find that useful?)[/quote]

Thankfully, I don't use a picky iPod. The normal firmware for the Sansa Fuze is pretty excellent at organizing the music you place in there.
 
I had MANY problems with the default Sansa firmware.

Album art not showing, album art showing up with inverted colors, songs not showing tags properly, songs not showing up at all, and most of all...NO FOLDER ACCESS


I switched to Rockbox, and I never looked back. I even rockboxed my wife's Fuze, and she won't use anything else to listen to her audiobooks.
 
[quote name='TwinRetro' post='3618200' date='Apr 29 2011, 12:16 PM']I had MANY problems with the default Sansa firmware.

Album art not showing, album art showing up with inverted colors, songs not showing tags properly, songs not showing up at all, and most of all...NO FOLDER ACCESS


I switched to Rockbox, and I never looked back. I even rockboxed my wife's Fuze, and she won't use anything else to listen to her audiobooks.[/quote]

The Sansa Fuze firmware works pretty fantastically, although both the Rockbox firmware and the Fuze firmware are 50/50 for showing the cover art. The only thing I didn't like about the normal firmware was the lack of a game function, but that's no longer an issue for me since I don't care anymore. Plus, Rockbox had this terrible habit of duplicating songs for certain bands making going through songs really freaking difficult and annoying.
 

Blog entry information

Author
Nathan Drake
Views
370
Comments
22
Last update

More entries in Personal Blogs

More entries from Nathan Drake