Skyward Sword sucks deku nuts as a Zelda game

Played it when it came out, all I can say is that it's very decent, not great just decent, still better than zelda on the 3do...

@Vilagamer999 Zelda on the 3DO?

oop my bad, it was on the other shitty console, the cd-i

The four-to-eight slot Pouch is retardedly limited, making the ammo bags (which should be part of the Gear screen, as they are in other games!) practically useless since you'll never be able to fit them in alongside your shield(s), Potions, and Medals (two of which are essentially Heart Containers, which is another dumbass design decision since it's impossible to reach 20 Hearts without them).
The game would work just fine without the Pouch, if not be an objectively better game.

The Silent Realms too "suck Deku Nuts", since the 90-second timer is far too short when the Tears are quite spread out and you also have to deal with limited stamina; why not 120 or 180 seconds? Further, why do these Realms have a goddamn reset condition, with the only "consolation prize" being the marking of previously-collected Tears on your map? It's utterly aggravating when you've collected most of the Tears, only to be slashed by a noclipping Guardian - or a supersonic, ground-locked one - from outta nowhere and forced to do the entire awful thing all over again.
Also, why the hell does water invalidate the timer and wake up the Guardians? Spotlights, sure, but water?

Limited stamina should speak for itself, as should the three Imprisoned fights; that whole game is filled with utter inanity and braindead design decisions, not helped by it originally being a Wii-exclusive (so porting it to a console that isn't so addicted to garbage motion controls isn't as simple as just remapping buttons, instead requiring a convoluted workaround to the borked motion system).

not as bad as breath of the wild

@Plstic BOTW understands what makes Zelda good.

@MORSHU8KRTXON I respectfully disagree. It's games like Twilight Princess, The Wind Waker and Majora's Mask (for 3D) and A Link Between Worlds and Link's Awakening (for 2D) that truly understands what makes the series so enticing, such a wonderful experience.

BotW tries something new, and...it really doesn't work out.

@AkiraKurusu These also understand Zelda