Why the saddest games aren't melodramas.

Video games right? They're all good fun until the best character dies. Games can have really impactful moments in their stories. They can be heart wrenching and leave you really distressed if they need to be. A lot of games try to be depressing the whole time and it just becomes an uninteresting melodrama. I want to talk about how games can tear your heart out without having to resort to melodrama. Spoilers for Xenoblade Chronicles and probably Mother 3 I guess.

Xenoblade is the inspiration for this. I'm a few hours in and I just reached
Fiora's Death
. This scene left me shocked and was the first time in a long time a game had made me genuinely sad. I got thinking about *why* I got upset though. I've played sad games. I recently beat Celeste and even though that game had a lot of sad and relatable moments, I never got upset by it.

I believe the difference between these two games is their tones. Celeste comes out of the gate as somber. It sets it's tone as hopeless and you already expect the worst. XC however, had an epic opening scene and resolves into a peaceful beginning. You spend a decent chunk of time getting to know these characters in a carefree environment. Once things become to go wrong, its only about 15 minutes until tragedy strikes.

The false security is the key here. The first time I had a similar experience with games was Mother 3. [SPOILERS] Even though Hinawa's death has a lot more build up than in XC, you still don't expect it to end how it does. The imagery of the fang in her heart, Flint's rage, the music, it all has the perfect shock factor to invoke feelings of sorrow. [/SPOILERS]

Anyway, these are just some disorganized thoughts I have and wanted to write down somewhere. Thanks for reading I guess.
  • Like
Reactions: 1 person

Comments

There are many sad parts in most of the video games, yes xenoblade after the first 5 hours or so I was shocked, i was sad and angry and confused, so after that scene I knew it's going to be an epic journey, the story have a lot of shocking moments, so wait and see.
The death of any beloved characters doesn't always mean sad, sometimes it's boring and it doesn't have any feelings.
Have you played Nier or Nier Automata? The death of some characters is not the sad parts in those games, the sad part is the story itself, I don't want to spoil it so play them yourself.
 
Video Game stories are usually bad. I guess they got better nowadays but, eh.

Fiora Fiora Fiora Fiora Fiora Fiora Fiora Fiora, Manado Mando Manado Manado Manado you’ll be hearing that a lot.
 
@Lazyboss Nier is on my list of games to play. I'll eventually get around to it

@SG854 you're right about games not usually having great stories. There are a few exceptions in my book though. I will say that I'm not sure if I can handle "it's Reyn time" for 60 hours though
 
@SG854 Cleary you didn't finish XC1 otherwise you won't say manado, it's Monado.
And the story of XC1 is the most optimized story in any video game, sure there are some plot holes but they are few comparing to other games.
And don't forget it's a Japanese anime story style "this world sucks, let's destroy it" kind of story, but this one is kinda unique.
 

Blog entry information

Author
SecureBoot
Views
292
Comments
12
Last update

More entries in Personal Blogs

  • 4: Reddit
    Finally, number 4! Never thought this day would come, did you? Uhh...
  • books
    1. I am cool as hell, have one million dollars 2. I am banned from...
  • Syncthing is fun!
    Having been kinda active in an Android forum I quickly got sick about...
  • Feeling at home here
    Not much to say this time. I'm depressed. Like almost always. Trying to...
  • I'll start, rate mine 1-10
    It's a very mixed bag, some rock, some rap, some video game music, a...

More entries from SecureBoot

Share this entry

General chit-chat
Help Users
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    Try a hot wet towel (almost burning hot) on your upper neck almost the base of your skull. Might provide temporary relief
    +1
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    It's why she cannot swallow hard food
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    :( I feel sorry for you, man.
    +1
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    Genetics
  • RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars:
    Ive done that a lot. Hot compresses.
  • RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars:
    It does provide temp relief but comes back right away.
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    A simple surgery might be able to correct it for both of you
    +1
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    The source of this information for me is Dr House. Some of the stories where based on actual cases
    +1
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    One episode helped me save a life one time
  • HiradeGirl @ HiradeGirl:
    House M.D. is great.
  • HiradeGirl @ HiradeGirl:
    Sad for the pain. I hope it gets better somehow. @RedColoredStars
    +2
  • RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars:
    Yes. Thats what Ive read. Surgery is most likely required. I sent a message to the ENT center with my concerns and asked if I should be seen much sooner and not wait, since it will be 71 days since symptoms started until my appointment.
    +1
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    Guy came in his lips where turning blue, I knew he was having a heart attack and I raced him to the ER they saved him
    +2
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    Without House I wouldn't have recognized the symptoms
    +1
  • HiradeGirl @ HiradeGirl:
    Blue like this?
    rk4URjod_ZYte_1024.webp
  • RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars:
    House was fantastic show from the episodes I've seen. Maybe I should watch the entire series.
    +3
  • Psionic Roshambo @ Psionic Roshambo:
    @HiradeGirl, almost, definitely a noticeable difference than normal color
  • RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars:
    Are your lips blue like that Hirada?
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    @RedColoredStars, The theme for House M.D. reminds me of when Computer Clan used this as their intro music.
  • SylverReZ @ SylverReZ:
    I miss the old days.
  • RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars:
    Me too. When I was young and not all fucking broken.
  • HiradeGirl @ HiradeGirl:
    @RedColoredStars Maybe I'm having a stroke. Sorry gtg, will update later.
  • RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars:
    Getting older really sucks if you have health problems. I was a preemie and have had health issues off and on my entire life. But its gotten much worse since I hit 40. That was 12 years ago.
  • RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars:
    Probably wont live to see 70.
    RedColoredStars @ RedColoredStars: Probably wont live to see 70.